Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

2011 Broadway Show Reviews & Critics' Ratings

Discover the best reviewed Broadway shows by top critics on BroadwayWorld.

Recently Reviewed

A Free Man Of Color
5.0 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 9, 2011
A Little Night Music
7.0 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 9, 2011
American Idiot
6.5 Mixed rating
Closed Apr 24, 2011
Arcadia
7.0 Mixed rating
Closed Jun 19, 2011
Baby It's You!
4.4 Mixed rating
Closed Sep 4, 2011
Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo
6.8 Mixed rating
Closed Jul 3, 2011
Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson
6.4 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
Bonnie & Clyde
5.8 Mixed rating
Closed Dec 30, 2011
Born Yesterday
8.0 Positive rating
Closed Jun 26, 2011
Brief Encounter
6.9 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
Catch Me If You Can
5.0 Mixed rating
Closed Sep 4, 2011
Driving Miss Daisy
7.3 Mixed rating
Closed Apr 9, 2011
Elf - The Musical
5.1 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
Fela!
8.1 Positive rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
Ghetto Klown
6.5 Mixed rating
Closed Jul 10, 2011
Good People
7.9 Mixed rating
Closed May 29, 2011
High
3.1 Negative rating
Closed Apr 24, 2011
In the Heights
7.5 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 9, 2011
Jerusalem
7.9 Mixed rating
Closed Aug 21, 2011
La Bete
7.1 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 9, 2011
La Cage aux Folles
7.9 Mixed rating
Closed May 1, 2011
Lombardi
6.4 Mixed rating
Closed May 22, 2011
Long Story Short
7.5 Mixed rating
Closed Mar 5, 2011
Man and Boy
6.7 Mixed rating
Closed Nov 27, 2011
Master Class
7.8 Mixed rating
Closed Sep 4, 2011
Million Dollar Quartet
6.2 Mixed rating
Closed Jun 12, 2011
Next to Normal
7.6 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 16, 2011
Private Lives
6.8 Mixed rating
Closed Dec 31, 2011
Promises, Promises
5.4 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
Rain: A Tribute to the Beatles
5.5 Mixed rating
Closed Jul 31, 2011
That Championship Season
3.3 Negative rating
Closed May 29, 2011
The Addams Family
4.6 Mixed rating
Closed Dec 31, 2011
The House of Blue Leaves
6.3 Mixed rating
Closed Jun 25, 2011
The Importance of Being Earnest
8.5 Positive rating
Closed Jul 3, 2011
The Merchant of Venice
8.1 Positive rating
Closed Feb 20, 2011
The Motherf**ker With the Hat
7.1 Mixed rating
Closed Jul 17, 2011
The Normal Heart
8.8 Positive rating
Closed Jul 10, 2011
The Pee-wee Herman Show
7.3 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
The People in the Picture
2.9 Negative rating
Closed Jun 19, 2011
Time Stands Still
7.3 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 30, 2011
West Side Story
7.6 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
Women On The Verge Of A Nervous Breakdown
4.5 Mixed rating
Closed Jan 2, 2011
Wonderland
2.8 Negative rating
Closed May 15, 2011

Review Roundups

Review Roundup: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY Arrives on Broadway

Review Roundup: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY Arrives on Broadway

Nicole Rosky • August 25, 2026

Are the critics screaming over the first play of the 2026/27 Broadway season? Paranormal Activity officially opened tonight at the August Wilson Theatre. The new play is written by Levi Holloway and directed by Felix Barrett. Let's see what the critics are saying...

Review Roundup: BENEVOLENT Opens Off-Broadway

Review Roundup: BENEVOLENT Opens Off-Broadway

Chloe Rabinowitz • August 21, 2026

The World Premiere of benevolent by Sophie McIntosh, with Good Apples Collective, is officially open Off-Broadway. See what the critics are saying about the production in Broadwayworld's Review Roundup.

Regional Reviews

All Regional Reviews ›
Review: A CHORUS LINE at The 5th Avenue Theatre

Review: A CHORUS LINE at The 5th Avenue Theatre

Seattle: Jay Irwin • September 19, 2026

Dear Readers, I don’t mean to make anyone feel ancient but “A Chorus Line” is 51 years old! And the 5th Avenue Theatre dusting off the old girl for their current remount may feel like a bit of nostalgia. But if their spectacular production proves anything, it’s that “A Chorus Line” is still the masterpiece it always was.

Gunhild Carling at City Winery – One Dazzling Surprise After Another

Gunhild Carling at City Winery – One Dazzling Surprise After Another

Cabaret: Stephen Sorokoff • September 19, 2026

Like a magician who somehow keeps producing one dazzling surprise after another, musician extraordinaire Gunhild Carling had the audience on the edge of its seat as her jazz/pop music and showmanship delivered one thrilling song after another

Review: THE FABLE FESTIVAL AND MOTHER GOOSED at DreamWrights

Review: THE FABLE FESTIVAL AND MOTHER GOOSED at DreamWrights

Central Pennsylvania: Sandra Harberger • September 19, 2026

DreamWrights presents a double feature with The Fable Festival and Mother Goosed on stage from September 18th to 27th under the direction of Hannah Kuhn. The Fable Festival and Mother Goosed is filled with animals and nursery rhymes gone wrong. It is perfect for families with children. It’s also an excellent opportunity to support local playwrights. Congratulations to the winners of Dreamwrights’ Fable Festival!

Review: JOHN & JEN at La Grange at Bruxellons!

Review: JOHN & JEN at La Grange at Bruxellons!

France: Patrick Honoré • September 19, 2026

Tucked into La Grange's intimate corner of Bruxellons, Andrew Lippa's near-sung-through two-hander proves a musical can carry real psychological weight.

Review: THE LAST SHOW ON EARTH at ERA

Review: THE LAST SHOW ON EARTH at ERA

St. Louis: Steve Callahan • September 19, 2026

A profound and hilarious scattershot examination of AI and the end of the universe. Invigorating! Rejuvenating! Don't miss it!

Review: BEGIN AGAIN at The Old Globe

Review: BEGIN AGAIN at The Old Globe

San Diego: ErinMarie Reiter • September 19, 2026

'Begin Again' at the new musical The Old Globe has plenty of heart, terrific performances, and a theatrical imagination that makes making music feel almost tangible.

Review: BRIGHT STAR Shines at Lincoln Theatre Company

Review: BRIGHT STAR Shines at Lincoln Theatre Company

Sacramento: Courtney Symes • September 19, 2026

Some musicals sweep us away with their original story, while others win us over with their heart. Bright Star falls into the latter category. Written by Steve Martin and Edie Brickell, it tells a story of love, loss, and happiness after tragedy through bluegrass music with plenty of Southern charm.

Review: RENT at Bay Street Players

Review: RENT at Bay Street Players

Orlando: Julie Gardieff • September 18, 2026

How do you measure a year in the life?  This is the question that runs throughout the musical Rent.  I had the opportunity to see Bay Street Players opening night production.

Review: COME FROM AWAY at Texarkana Repertory Company

Review: COME FROM AWAY at Texarkana Repertory Company

Arkansas: Theresa Bertram • September 18, 2026

This year marks the 25th anniversary of 9/11, a day that forever changed our country and the lives of so many people around the world. For those of us who remember September 11, 2001, certain images and emotions never completely leave us. We remember where we were. We remember the fear and uncertainty. We remember watching the news and trying to comprehend what was happening.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71