My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Off-Broadway Show Reviews & Critics' Ratings

Discover the best reviewed Off-Broadway shows, including musicals and plays, according to BroadwayWorld's top critics.
Filter: All Musicals Plays
11 to Midnight
11 to Midnight
7.0
Opened Feb 11, 2026
An Ark
An Ark
5.9
Opened Jan 13, 2026
BATSU! The Live Japanese Gameshow Experience
BATSU! The Live Japanese Gameshow Experience
Not Yet Rated
Opened Jan 10, 2011
Bigfoot! A New Musical
Bigfoot! A New Musical
4.4
Opened Mar 1, 2026
Blood/Love
Blood/Love
7.7
Opened Mar 3, 2026
Burnout Paradise
Burnout Paradise
8.0
Opened Mar 5, 2026
Chinese Republicans
Chinese Republicans
6.0
Opened Feb 26, 2026
DATA
DATA
8.0
Opened Jan 25, 2026
Drunk Shakespeare
Drunk Shakespeare
Not Yet Rated
Opened Jul 2, 2021
Fear and Misery in the Third Reich
Fear and Misery in the Third Reich
Not Yet Rated
Opened Mar 5, 2026
Friends! The Musical Parody
Friends! The Musical Parody
Not Yet Rated
Opened Mar 29, 2022
Gazillion Bubble Show
Gazillion Bubble Show
Not Yet Rated
Opened Oct 9, 2021
Goddess
Goddess
7.3
Opened Jun 4, 2025
Heathers: The Musical
Heathers: The Musical
7.5
Opened Jul 10, 2025
Hold Onto Your Butts
Hold Onto Your Butts
Not Yet Rated
Opened Feb 15, 2026
Jamie Allan’s Amaze
Jamie Allan’s Amaze
Not Yet Rated
Opened Aug 13, 2025
Katsura Sunshine's Rakugo
Katsura Sunshine's Rakugo
Not Yet Rated
Opened Sep 28, 2019
Little Shop of Horrors
Little Shop of Horrors
8.3
Opened Sep 21, 2021
Lost in Del Valle
Lost in Del Valle
Not Yet Rated
Opened Feb 23, 2026
Marcel on the Train
Marcel on the Train
8.0
Opened Feb 22, 2026
Masquerade
Masquerade
7.6
Opened Jul 31, 2025
Meat Suit, or the shitshow of motherhood
Meat Suit, or the shitshow of motherhood
6.0
Opened Feb 25, 2026
Mexodus
Mexodus
Not Yet Rated
Opened Mar 6, 2026
Mindplay
Mindplay
Not Yet Rated
Opened Jan 13, 2025
Mother Russia
Mother Russia
6.4
Opened Feb 25, 2026
Night Side Songs
Night Side Songs
6.4
Opened Mar 2, 2026
Pen Pals A New Play
Pen Pals A New Play
Not Yet Rated
Opened Aug 15, 2025
Perfect Crime
Perfect Crime
Not Yet Rated
Opened Apr 18, 2021
Pied à Terre
Pied à Terre
Not Yet Rated
Opened Mar 4, 2026
Shitzprobe
Shitzprobe
Not Yet Rated
Opened Jan 1, 2022
Silver Manhattan
Silver Manhattan
Not Yet Rated
Opened Feb 18, 2026
Spread
Spread
Not Yet Rated
Opened Mar 2, 2026
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
9.4
Opened Nov 17, 2025
The Amazing Sex Life of Rabbits
The Amazing Sex Life of Rabbits
Not Yet Rated
Opened Mar 2, 2026
The Fever
The Fever
Not Yet Rated
Opened Feb 16, 2026
THE HULA-HOOPIN' QUEEN
THE HULA-HOOPIN' QUEEN
Not Yet Rated
Opened Feb 28, 2026
The Monsters
The Monsters
8.2
Opened Feb 11, 2026
The Office! A Musical Parody
The Office! A Musical Parody
Not Yet Rated
Opened Jul 1, 2021
The Paparazzi
The Paparazzi
Not Yet Rated
Opened Mar 6, 2026
The Play That Goes Wrong
The Play That Goes Wrong
Not Yet Rated
Opened Oct 15, 2021
The Reservoir
The Reservoir
6.5
Opened Feb 24, 2026
The Unknown
The Unknown
7.0
Opened Feb 12, 2026
The Waterfall
The Waterfall
Not Yet Rated
Opened Feb 15, 2026
What We Did Before Our Moth Days
What We Did Before Our Moth Days
7.4
Opened Mar 5, 2026
You Got Older
You Got Older
6.5
Opened Feb 23, 2026

Review Roundups

Review Roundup: BLOOD/LOVE Arrives Off-Broadway
Review Roundup: BLOOD/LOVE Arrives Off-Broadway
Nicole Rosky • March 6, 2026
BLOOD/LOVE has officially arrived off-Broadway. The production will now continue performances through May 10 at Theater 555 in New York City. Let's see what the critics are saying...
Review Roundup: BURNOUT PARADISE Opens At Astor Place Theatre
Review Roundup: BURNOUT PARADISE Opens At Astor Place Theatre
A.A. Cristi • March 5, 2026
Critics stopped by BURNOUT PARADISE, the new theatrical experience created by Australian collective Pony Cam. BURNOUT PARADISE features five performers attempting to complete a series of escalating tasks while running on four treadmills. Read the reviews!
Review Roundup: Wallace Shawn's WHAT WE DID BEFORE OUR MOTH DAYS Opens Off-Broad
Review Roundup: Wallace Shawn's WHAT WE DID BEFORE OUR MOTH DAYS Opens Off-Broadway
A.A. Cristi • March 5, 2026
The critics are weighing in on Wallace Shawn’s new play, What We Did Before Our Moth Days, directed by André Gregor, running now at the Greenwich House Theater (27 Barrow St). The production stars Hope Davis, Maria Dizzia, John Early, and Josh Hamilton. Read the reviews.
Review Roundup: NIGHT SIDE SONGS Opens Off-Broadway
Review Roundup: NIGHT SIDE SONGS Opens Off-Broadway
Chloe Rabinowitz • March 2, 2026
Lincoln Center Theater is presenting the new musical Night Side Songs, written by duo, The Lazours who are reuniting with Lortel and Obie Award-winning director Taibi Magar. See what the critics are saying in BroadwayWorld's Review Roundup!
Review Roundup: BIGFOOT! A NEW MUSICAL Off-Broadway
Review Roundup: BIGFOOT! A NEW MUSICAL Off-Broadway
Gillian Blum • March 1, 2026
BIGFOOT! A NEW MUSICAL opened Off-Broadway at New York City Center Stage, and critics are sharing their reviews of the new musical comedy, running now.
Review Roundup: CHINESE REPUBLICANS Opens at Roundabout Theatre Company
Review Roundup: CHINESE REPUBLICANS Opens at Roundabout Theatre Company
A.A. Cristi • February 26, 2026
Read reviews for the Off-Broadway production of Chinese Republicans, opening tonight at Roundabout Theatre Company's Laura Pels Theatre in the Harold and Miriam Steinberg Center for Theatre. See what the critics are saying!

Videos