The return of All Star Comedy features comedians Chris Clarke, Brendan Sagalow, and Aiko Tanaka, and as always is hosted by New York-based comedian Joseph Vecsey, who founded the stand-up comedy showcase in 2010. In that time, the series has been headlined by stand-up veterans and fresh faces alike, growing to become the East Ends premiere live comedy series.Vecsey himself has been selected as one of Comedy Centrals Comics To Watch, has toured with Adam Sandler, David Spade, and Rob Schneider, and has worked as co-producer on Sandlers Netflix special, 100% Fresh. He is also producer of Netflixs The Wrong Missy, in which he stars.
SUBMIT UPDATES
Bay Street Theater Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Black Film Festival (9/7/24-9/7/24)
Ha Ha Hamptons Comedy (9/14/24-9/14/24)
Kyle Barisich Special (9/21/24-8/21/24)
Sag Harbor American Music Festival (9/27/24-9/28/24)
All Star Comedy (10/5/24-10/5/24)
Bobby Collins (10/13/24-10/13/24)
Divaria Opera (10/18/24-10/19/24)
Hamptons Comedy (10/26/24-10/26/24)
Literature Live (11/11/24-12/1/24)
Bay Street Theater is at 1 The Long Warf, Sag Harbor, NY.
Bay Street Theater is at 1 The Long Warf, Sag Harbor, NY.
The Moondogs Mystery Tour (4/25/25-4/25/25)
The Main Event: A Barbra Streisand Tribute (4/19/25-4/19/25)
Kissed by a Prince (4/12/25-4/12/25)
Joseph Vecsey's All Star Comedy Show (4/5/25-4/5/25)
Women of Rock (3/29/25-3/29/25)
Soul Spectacular (3/8/25-3/8/25)
The Paumanok Stompers (3/1/25-3/1/25)
Winter Jazz Series: CocoMama (2/22/25-2/22/25)
Motown Night (2/8/25-2/8/25)
Nancy Atlas Fireside Sessions (1/18/25-2/15/25)
Videos
 |
Dance to the Holidays
Patchogue Theatre (12/16 - 12/16) | |
 |
Anastasia -The Musical
Lighthouse Repertory Theatre (11/28 - 12/28) | |
|
Andrea Chénier
Staller Center for the Arts (12/14 - 12/14) | |
|
Haunted Encounters - Magic Show
Theatre Three (12/31 - 12/31) | |
|
Jazz at Lincoln Center | Great American Crooners
Staller Center for the Arts (3/20 - 3/20) | |
|
Godspell
Theatre Three (2/21 - 3/22) | |
|
Christmas with Chris Ruggiero LIVE in East Islip, NY on December 21, 2025
Bayway Arts Center (12/21 - 12/21) | |
|
A Very Expensive Poison
BACCA Arts Center (12/20 - 1/4) | |
|
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective Long Island (12/20 - 12/20) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Long Island's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Long Island & beyond.
