My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

LONG ISLAND THEATER REVIEWS

The latest reviews and critic recommendations from Long Island
Review: HEDDA GABLER at Modern Classics Theatre Company Of Long Island

Review: HEDDA GABLER at Modern Classics Theatre Company Of Long Island

by Michelle Nielsen — May 25, 2026
What did our critic think of HEDDA GABLER at Modern Classics Theatre Company Of Long Island?...
Review: CAMELOT at The John W. Engeman Theater

Review: CAMELOT at The John W. Engeman Theater

by Michelle Nielsen — May 21, 2026
Lerner & Loewe’s magical tale of CAMELOT has been brought to life at The John W. Engeman Theater in Northport by Director Drew Humphrey*. A rarely performed show on Long Island, this production was worth waiting for! Humphrey, a veteran director, choreographer, and performer, created a masterpiece...
Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Plaza Theatrical

Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Plaza Theatrical

by Michelle Nielsen — May 20, 2026
The classic showstopper, FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Plaza Theatrical in Elmont is not to be missed! A deeply experienced director, Kevin F. Harrington pulled no punches with this production. From the costumes, scenery, and set pieces to the music, dancing, and acting, the show was polished from start to...
Review: YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN at Theatre Three

Review: YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN at Theatre Three

by Sam Desmond — May 19, 2026
The story follows the grandson of Victor Frankenstein, Frederick, as a trip to Transylvania becomes less about sorting his dead grandfather’s estate and more about taking up the family business of accidental monster making. To help him in his quest, Frederick has a team of quirky personalities who...
Review: JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR at Cultural Arts Playhouse-SYOSSET

Review: JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR at Cultural Arts Playhouse-SYOSSET

by Sam Desmond — May 14, 2026
Playing on the main stage at Cultural Arts Playhouse in Syosset this spring is the operatic, rock ‘n rock “Jesus Christ Superstar.”...
Review: COMPANY at Manes Studio Theatre

Review: COMPANY at Manes Studio Theatre

by Michelle Nielsen — April 28, 2026
Stephen Sondheim’s powerful emotional musical about love, marriage, and being the last single person in a group of married friends, COMPANY, has been brought to life by director Rick Grossman at Manes Studio Theatre. First performed on Broadway in 1970, this groundbreaking show won 6 Tony awards a...
Review: THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD at Star Playhouse At Stage 74

Review: THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD at Star Playhouse At Stage 74

by Michelle Nielsen — April 27, 2026
What did our critic think of THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD at Star Playhouse At Stage 74?...
Review: THE PRINCE OF EGYPT at The Argyle Theatre

Review: THE PRINCE OF EGYPT at The Argyle Theatre

by Sam Desmond — April 27, 2026
A sprawling, epic--literally biblical--story focusing on the deep-seeded bond of two brothers through the societal pressures both have to lead against each other, “The Prince of Egypt” at the Argyle Theatre in Babylon, is the musical for those who want to travel to another world but still feel t...
Review: THE 39 STEPS at Theatre Three

Review: THE 39 STEPS at Theatre Three

by Sam Desmond — April 24, 2026
Reverie Theatre Group presents ‘Edges,’ a funny, thoughtful, highly entertaining four-person song cycle, with no spoken dialogue or discernible plot, that explores the challenges of young adults, including family dynamics, career opportunities, and most significantly, the trials and tribulations...
Review: TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD at The Suffolk

Review: TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD at The Suffolk

by Michelle Nielsen — April 21, 2026
What did our critic think of TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD at The Suffolk?...
Review: JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR at James Street Players

Review: JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR at James Street Players

by Michelle Nielsen — April 20, 2026
Powerhouse vocals, evocative choreography, and a deep emotional connection define director and choreographer Matthew I. Quinn’s vision of Andrew Lloyd Weber and Tim Rice’s timeless and timely rock opera, JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR....
Review: SCHOOL OF ROCK at Cultural Arts Playhouse-Merrick

Review: SCHOOL OF ROCK at Cultural Arts Playhouse-Merrick

by Sam Desmond — April 9, 2026
With a central character seemingly a charming, albeit selfish, peccadillo who goes on redemption journey to connect his passion with his dreams, “School of Rock,” brings humor, honor, and hype to the standing up for yourself no matter how “acceptable” the responsible path is presented....
Review: JAGGED LITTLE PILL: THE MUSICAL at Smithtown Performing Arts Center

Review: JAGGED LITTLE PILL: THE MUSICAL at Smithtown Performing Arts Center

by Sam Desmond — April 1, 2026
The sweeping music and frenetic choreography of a musical and the arrow-piercing drama of a straight play are rarely found together in the same production, but “Jagged Little Pill: the Musical” currently playing at the Smithtown Performing Arts Center through April 19, is a rare melding of those...
Review: THE BODYGUARD at John W. Engeman Theater

Review: THE BODYGUARD at John W. Engeman Theater

by Sam Desmond — March 29, 2026
What did our critic think of THE BODYGUARD at John W. Engeman Theater?...
Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at The Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company

Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at The Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company

by Sam Desmond — March 27, 2026
A bucolic tale of a small community—almost like the town square that Belle from Beauty and the Beast goes through—that makes a sharp turn into human rights violations, “Fiddler on the Roof” asks quite a bit from its actors to go from whimsical country life to a terrified ousted community dee...
Review: CATS at CM Performing Arts Center

Review: CATS at CM Performing Arts Center

by Sam Desmond — March 25, 2026
Feisty felines compete for centerstage through dance and song, with nary a meow as this show features no human characters. Currently playing at the CM Performing Arts Center in Oakdale is a mammoth of the musical theater repertory, “CATS.”...
Review: MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS at Star Playhouse At Stage 74

Review: MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS at Star Playhouse At Stage 74

by Sam Desmond — March 12, 2026
In celebration of the 50th anniversary of Agatha Christie’s death, theaters across Long Island have been producing great works of the beloved mystery author true to the heritage of Christie and the spirit of her creativity....
Review: ANNIE at Merrick Theatre And Center For The Arts

Review: ANNIE at Merrick Theatre And Center For The Arts

by Sam Desmond — March 11, 2026
The opening night production of “Annie” on Friday, March 6 at the Merrick Theatre & Center for the Arts marked the fourth viewing of the scrappy, upstart orphan I’ve seen this winter alone (there was actually a fifth I could’ve reviewed if BroadwayWorld hired me two weeks earlier)....
Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Cultural Arts Playhouse-SYOSSET

Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Cultural Arts Playhouse-SYOSSET

by Sam Desmond — March 5, 2026
A devastatingly timely production of “Fiddler on the Roof,” by Cultural Arts Playhouse in Syosset brings us to the small, earnest existence of Anatevka, a Jewish town in the Russian empire during the tumultuous turn of the century....
Review: GODSPELL at Theatre Three

Review: GODSPELL at Theatre Three

by Sam Desmond — March 4, 2026
With theatre that touches upon the religious, it can be tricky to strike a balance between artistry and accuracy that carries the audience’s imagination instead of accidentally shunning creativity....
Review: AND THEN THERE WERE NONE at South Shore Theatre Experience

Review: AND THEN THERE WERE NONE at South Shore Theatre Experience

by Sam Desmond — February 9, 2026
With exuberant dramatic tension and ballroom fluidity in blocking, the South Shore Theatre Experience’s production of “And Then There Were None” was filled with tension, retribution, and an impressive number of blood packets....
Review: NEWSIES at The Argyle Theatre

Review: NEWSIES at The Argyle Theatre

by Sam Desmond — February 4, 2026
A musical forged in ambition of set, stage, and stamina, director Tommy Ranieri’s vision of a world only beginning to stand up for their rights was sprawling and spectacular. Unlike other versions of “Newsies,” Rainieri’s production had a maturity that touched the cast’s characters to trul...
Review: RENT at Cultural Arts Playhouse Merrick

Review: RENT at Cultural Arts Playhouse Merrick

by Sam Desmond — February 2, 2026
Teenaged theater kids of my generation (elder millennial) loved “Rent.” It was youth-culture, it was edgy, and introduced to many of us suburban kids the magic of New York City where gay men, lesbian women, drag queens, and matinee-idol heteros could all be friends and love each other as family....
Review: RING OF FIRE at John W. Engeman Theater

Review: RING OF FIRE at John W. Engeman Theater

by Sam Desmond — January 28, 2026
The John E. Engeman Theater found not only one, but five such super-talented individuals for their retrospective and introspective production of “Ring of Fire,” a musical based on the life of Johnny Cash....
Review: BRIGHTON BEACH MEMOIRS at Theatre Three

Review: BRIGHTON BEACH MEMOIRS at Theatre Three

by Sam Desmond — January 23, 2026
The world of late 1930s Brooklyn is brought to life and elucidated in Theatre Three’s triumphant run of the Neil Simon classic,”Brighton Beach Memoirs.”...
Next »
Page 1 of 21

Videos


Be Like Blippi Tour! in Long Island Be Like Blippi Tour!
Patchogue Theatre (3/03-6/03)
The Prince of Egypt in Long Island The Prince of Egypt
Argyle Theatre (4/16-6/07)
West Side Story in Long Island West Side Story
The Gateway Playhouse (5/08-5/31)
CAMELOT in Long Island CAMELOT
The John W. Engeman Theater (5/14-6/28)
Sesame Street Live! Elmo's Got the Moves Relaxed performance, co-presented with Round Room Live in Long Island Sesame Street Live! Elmo's Got the Moves Relaxed performance, co-presented with Round Room Live
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts (6/02-6/02)
Derek Hough- Symphony of Dance: Encore in Long Island Derek Hough- Symphony of Dance: Encore
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts (7/19-7/19)
Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations in Long Island Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations
The Gateway Playhouse (6/19-7/19)
Risa Finkel: Grist for the Mill in Long Island Risa Finkel: Grist for the Mill
Lefferts Tide Mill (6/12-6/14) PHOTOS
Young Frankenstein in Long Island Young Frankenstein
Theatre Three - NY (5/17-6/21)
Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra in Long Island Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra
Staller Center for the Arts (10/03-10/03)