SUBMIT UPDATES
Bay Street Theater Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Bay Street Theater is at 1 The Long Warf, Sag Harbor, NY.
Bay Street Theater is at 1 The Long Warf, Sag Harbor, NY.
The Moondogs Mystery Tour (4/25/25-4/25/25)
The Main Event: A Barbra Streisand Tribute (4/19/25-4/19/25)
Kissed by a Prince (4/12/25-4/12/25)
Joseph Vecsey's All Star Comedy Show (4/5/25-4/5/25)
Women of Rock (3/29/25-3/29/25)
Soul Spectacular (3/8/25-3/8/25)
The Paumanok Stompers (3/1/25-3/1/25)
Winter Jazz Series: CocoMama (2/22/25-2/22/25)
Motown Night (2/8/25-2/8/25)
Nancy Atlas Fireside Sessions (1/18/25-2/15/25)
Videos
 |
Dance to the Holidays
Patchogue Theatre (12/16 - 12/16) | |
 |
Anastasia -The Musical
Lighthouse Repertory Theatre (11/28 - 12/28) | |
|
Winnie the Pooh
Theatre Three (1/24 - 2/21) | |
|
Dear Evan Hansen
The Gateway (3/13 - 4/12) | |
|
Gala: Mandy Patinkin in Jukebox
Staller Center for the Arts (5/2 - 5/2) | |
|
Rhythm of the Dance
Staller Center for the Arts (3/14 - 3/14) | |
|
A Christmas Carol
Theatre Three (11/8 - 12/27) | |
|
Circus Vazquez New York City, November-December 2025
Citi Field (11/25 - 12/14) | |
|
Haunted Encounters - Magic Show
Theatre Three (12/31 - 12/31) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Long Island's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Long Island & beyond.
