Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: MURDER FOR TWO at Hillbarn Theatre

Murder for Two continues through November 2.

By:
Review: MURDER FOR TWO at Hillbarn Theatre

Celebrated author Arthur Whitney is murdered at his birthday party and all the guests become instant suspects. Joe Kinosian and Kellen Blair’s madcap musical murder mystery continues Hillbarn’s 85th season and is a smashing success reminiscent of the whodunit films of years past with a touch of comedy and vaudeville thrown in. This two-hander features two tour-de-force performances by Kevin Kelley as the inexperienced police officer eager to solve the case, and Michelle Lemon as all the suspects.

Review: MURDER FOR TWO at Hillbarn Theatre Image
Kevin Kelly and Michelle Lemon

Jeffrey Bracco directs this whirlwind of song and quick character changes as the story reveals the guest’s motives for murder. The author’s wife, who cares more about some missing ice cream, a prima ballerina who turns out to be a jilted lover, the town psychiatrist who knows too much, a bickering elderly couple, a wannabe detective niece and even a trio of tough choirboys all add to the mayhem that transpires. The charming score is capably delivered by Kelley and Lemon on the piano, and the pacing is a whirlwind of comic acting.

Review: MURDER FOR TWO at Hillbarn Theatre Image
Michelle Lemon (suspects) and Kevin Kelly (Marcus).

Murder for Two, which premiered in 2011, originally featured a male actor as the suspects. Here Lemon shines brilliantly as she quick changes characters using a hat, a pair of glasses, posture, and vocal inflections. It’s a challenging task to inhabit multiple characters and make them instantly distinguishable, but Lemon masters the roles. There are clues delivered through the author’s past books, a second murder and even a thwarted romance thrown into the wild mix.

Review: MURDER FOR TWO at Hillbarn Theatre Image

Those who love the old Agatha Christie or Thin Man movies with a touch of The Mystery of Irma Vep thrown in will love this clever musical. Go see it for the delicious farce and the sensational performances.

Murder for Two continues through November 2nd.

Photo Credit: Mark Kitaoka and Tracy Martin

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Hillbarn Theatre
Upcoming Shows
Pickleball
8/20 - 9/13/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a San Francisco / Bay Area News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


The Still Point: An Immersive Experience in San Francisco / Bay Area The Still Point: An Immersive Experience
SOMArts Cultural Center (7/16-7/25) VIDEOS
The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark in San Francisco / Bay Area The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark
SPARC (7/03-7/26)
Help Is On The Way: Broadway & Beyond – 32nd Anniversary Concert & Gala in San Francisco / Bay Area Help Is On The Way: Broadway & Beyond – 32nd Anniversary Concert & Gala
Marines' Memorial Theatre (8/02-8/02)
Sara Felder’s Class Act in San Francisco / Bay Area Sara Felder’s Class Act
The Marsh San Francisco (8/12-8/15)
The Employee Dharma Handbook in San Francisco / Bay Area The Employee Dharma Handbook
Lucie Stern Theatre (7/08-8/02)
The Rocky Horror Picture Show Spooktacular Tour with Barry Bostwick in San Francisco / Bay Area The Rocky Horror Picture Show Spooktacular Tour with Barry Bostwick
Curran Theatre (10/11-10/11)
The Last Five Years by Jason Robert Brown in San Francisco / Bay Area The Last Five Years by Jason Robert Brown
Santa Cruz Shakespeare (9/11-10/03)
Fences by August Wilson in San Francisco / Bay Area Fences by August Wilson
Santa Cruz Shakespeare (7/28-8/28)
Broadway Under the Stars - Mamma Mia! in San Francisco / Bay Area Broadway Under the Stars - Mamma Mia!
Transcendence Theatre Company (8/13-8/30)
Little Shop of Horrors 40th Anniversary Tour with Ellen Greene (the Original Audrey) in San Francisco / Bay Area Little Shop of Horrors 40th Anniversary Tour with Ellen Greene (the Original Audrey)
Curran Theatre (8/16-8/16)