Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Broadway Critics Report Card

See the Average Critics Ratings for EVERY Show on Broadway!

Broadway Show Reviews

Ain't Too Proud Broadway Reviews Ain't Too Proud Average
 7.2
Aladdin Broadway Reviews Aladdin Average
 6.8
American Utopia Broadway Reviews American Utopia Average
 8.2
Chicago Broadway Reviews Chicago Average
 9.5
Chicken and Biscuits Broadway Reviews Chicken and Biscuits Average
 6.0
Come From Away Broadway Reviews Come From Away Average
 8.0
Dana H Broadway Reviews Dana H Average
 8.8
Freestyle Love Supreme Broadway Reviews Freestyle Love Supreme Not Yet Available
Girl from the North Country Broadway Reviews Girl from the North Country Average
 8.1
Hadestown Broadway Reviews Hadestown Average
 8.2
Hamilton Broadway Reviews Hamilton Average
 9.7
Is This a Room Broadway Reviews Is This a Room Average
 8.1
Jagged Little Pill Broadway Reviews Jagged Little Pill Average
 7.3
Lackawanna Blues Broadway Reviews Lackawanna Blues Average
 8.6
Moulin Rouge! Broadway Reviews Moulin Rouge! Average
 7.6
Pass Over Broadway Reviews Pass Over Average
 7.9
SIX Broadway Reviews SIX Average
 8.4
The Lehman Trilogy Broadway Reviews The Lehman Trilogy Average
 8.9
The Lion King Broadway Reviews The Lion King Average
 8.8
The Phantom of the Opera Broadway Reviews The Phantom of the Opera Average
 6.8
Thoughts of a Colored Man Broadway Reviews Thoughts of a Colored Man Average
 7.6
Tina: The Tina Turner Musical Broadway Reviews Tina: The Tina Turner Musical Average
 7.1
To Kill A Mockingbird Broadway Reviews To Kill A Mockingbird Average
 8.0
Waitress Broadway Reviews Waitress Average
 7.7
Wicked Broadway Reviews Wicked Average
 5.3

Rating System:

10 - effusive praise

9 - excellent

7 or 8 - positive with some reservations

5 or 6 - respectfully unenthused

3 or 4 - mostly negative

2 - little to recommend

1 - offended, insulted, angered
   

Broadway Show Reviews

Review Roundup: TOOTSIE National Tour Kicks Off This Month; What Are The Critics Photo TOOTSIE National Tour Kicks Off This Month; What Are The Critics Saying?
by Review Roundups - October 26, 2021
Review Roundup: THE LION KING Tour Roars Back to the Stage; What Are The Critics Photo THE LION KING Tour Roars Back to the Stage; What Are The Critics Saying?
by Review Roundups - October 26, 2021
Review Roundup: COME FROM AWAY National Tour Returns to the Stage; What Did the Photo COME FROM AWAY National Tour Returns to the Stage; What Did the Critics Think?
by Review Roundups - October 26, 2021
Review Roundup: THE BAND'S VISIT National Tour Takes the Stage; What Did the Cri Photo THE BAND'S VISIT National Tour Takes the Stage; What Did the Critics Think?
by Review Roundups - October 26, 2021
Review Roundup: PRETTY WOMAN: THE MUSICAL Kicks Off its National Tour; What Did Photo PRETTY WOMAN: THE MUSICAL Kicks Off its National Tour; What Did the Critics Think?
by Review Roundups - October 26, 2021

New York Show Reviews
BWW Review: A Beloved New York Stage Actor Recalls Six Decades of Theatre in JOH Photo A Beloved New York Stage Actor Recalls Six Decades of Theatre in JOHN CULLUM: AN ACCIDENTAL STAR
by Michael Dale - April 12, 2021
BWW Review: Lupita Nyong'o and Juan Castano Are Bilingual Lovers in The Public's Photo Lupita Nyong'o and Juan Castano Are Bilingual Lovers in The Public's Radio Drama ROMEO Y JULIETA
by Michael Dale - March 28, 2021
BWW Review: Patrick Page Leads a Sumptuous Ensemble in Shakespeare@'s Radio Dram Photo Patrick Page Leads a Sumptuous Ensemble in Shakespeare@'s Radio Drama JULIUS CAESAR
by Michael Dale - March 02, 2021
BWW Review: Theatre Artists Adapt To A Drastically Changed World as The Seeing Photo Theatre Artists Adapt To A Drastically Changed World as The Seeing Place Presents Liz Duffy Adams' DOG ACT
by Michael Dale - February 06, 2021
BWW Review: Jefferson Mays Plays 50+ Characters In A Beautifully Realized Adapt Photo Jefferson Mays Plays 50+ Characters In A Beautifully Realized Adaptation A CHRISTMAS CAROL
by Michael Dale - November 29, 2020

REGIONAL REVIEWS
  or



BWW Review: PIPELINE at Virginia Rep Photo Central Virginia: PIPELINE at Virginia Rep
by Susan Haubenstock - October 26, 2021
BWW Review: JACOB KHALIL TRIO: AUTUMN IN NEW YORK Showcases an Eclectic New Arti Photo Cabaret: JACOB KHALIL TRIO: AUTUMN IN NEW YORK Showcases an Eclectic New Artist at Pangea
by Ricky Pope - October 26, 2021
BWW Review: The San Diego Opera Presents STEPHANIE BLYTHE IN RECITAL at the Balb Photo Opera: The San Diego Opera Presents STEPHANIE BLYTHE IN RECITAL at the Balboa Theatre
by Ron Bierman - October 26, 2021
BWW Review: FANNIE at Goodman Theatre Photo Chicago: FANNIE at Goodman Theatre
by Rachel Weinberg - October 26, 2021
BWW Review: IF IT ONLY EVEN RUNS A MINUTE CELEBRATES THE UNDERAPPRECIATED MUSICA Photo Cabaret: IF IT ONLY EVEN RUNS A MINUTE CELEBRATES THE UNDERAPPRECIATED MUSICALS OF HAL PRINCE at Feinstein's/54 Below Scores High Marks
by Stephen Mosher - October 26, 2021
BWW Review: GROAN UPS, Theatre Royal Glasgow Photo Scotland: GROAN UPS, Theatre Royal Glasgow
by Natalie O'Donoghue - October 26, 2021
BWW Review: SHUTTER SISTERS at The Old Globe Photo San Diego: SHUTTER SISTERS at The Old Globe
by E.H. Reiter - October 26, 2021
BWW Review: MYSTICISM & MUSIC at Constellation Theatre Company Photo Washington, DC: MYSTICISM & MUSIC at Constellation Theatre Company
by Rachael F. Goldberg - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: LOS ANGELES OPERA'S TANNHÄUSER at Home Computer Screens Photo Los Angeles: LOS ANGELES OPERA'S TANNHÄUSER at Home Computer Screens
by Maria Nockin - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: NATALIE NEEDS A NIGHTIE Fills Your Chest with Laughter at HOMEWOOD T Photo Birmingham: NATALIE NEEDS A NIGHTIE Fills Your Chest with Laughter at HOMEWOOD THEATRE
by David Edward Perry - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: PIPELINE at Unicorn Photo Kansas City: PIPELINE at Unicorn
by Kelly Luck - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: Wall Street Takes Center Stage at Live Theatre Workshop Photo Phoenix: Wall Street Takes Center Stage at Live Theatre Workshop
by Robert Encila-Celdran - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: CATERINA CASELLI UNA VITA, 100 VITE al FESTIVAL DEL CINEMA DI ROMA Photo Italy: CATERINA CASELLI UNA VITA, 100 VITE al FESTIVAL DEL CINEMA DI ROMA
by ETTORE FARRATTINI - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: PRETTY FIRE at Blackfriars Theatre Photo Central New York: PRETTY FIRE at Blackfriars Theatre
by Colin Fleming-Stumpf - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: DER FREISCHÜTZ at Opera Wroclaw Photo Opera: DER FREISCHÜTZ at Opera Wroclaw
by Natalia Jarczynska - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: Stages' 25TH ANNUAL PUTNAM COUNTY SPELLING BEE Steals the Show for B Photo Houston: Stages' 25TH ANNUAL PUTNAM COUNTY SPELLING BEE Steals the Show for Best Fall Musical
by Armando Urdiales - October 25, 2021
Photo Coverage: Isaac Sutton Returns to New York City at the Green Room 42 Photo Cabaret: Photo Coverage: Isaac Sutton Returns to New York City at the Green Room 42
by Stephen Sorokoff - October 25, 2021
BWW Special Event: TIN PAN ALLEY DAY Fills The Air With Music and The Streets Wi Photo Cabaret: BWW Special Event: TIN PAN ALLEY DAY Fills The Air With Music and The Streets With Dancing
by Stephen Mosher - October 25, 2021
BWW REVIEW: Queenie van de Zandt's CHOOSE YOUR OWN ADVENTURE – ONLINE EDITION De Photo Australia - Melbourne: BWW REVIEW: Queenie van de Zandt's CHOOSE YOUR OWN ADVENTURE – ONLINE EDITION Delivers A Truly Interactive Online “Theatre” Experience
by Jade Kops - October 25, 2021
BWW Review: MICHAEL FEINSTEIN, St George's Bristol Photo UK / West End: MICHAEL FEINSTEIN, St George's Bristol
by Shane Morgan - October 25, 2021