Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Broadway Critics Report Card

See the Average Critics Ratings for EVERY Show on Broadway!

Broadway Show Reviews

Ain't Too Proud Broadway Reviews Ain't Too Proud Average
 7.2
Aladdin Broadway Reviews Aladdin Average
 6.8
American Utopia Broadway Reviews American Utopia Average
 8.2
Caroline, or Change Broadway Reviews Caroline, or Change Average
 9.1
Chicago Broadway Reviews Chicago Average
 9.5
Clyde's Broadway Reviews Clyde's Average
 8.1
Come From Away Broadway Reviews Come From Away Average
 8.0
Diana Broadway Reviews Diana Average
 3.4
Flying Over Sunset Broadway Reviews Flying Over Sunset Not Yet Available
Freestyle Love Supreme Broadway Reviews Freestyle Love Supreme Average
 8.3
Girl from the North Country Broadway Reviews Girl from the North Country Average
 8.1
Hadestown Broadway Reviews Hadestown Average
 8.2
Hamilton Broadway Reviews Hamilton Average
 9.7
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Broadway Reviews Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Average
 8.9
Jagged Little Pill Broadway Reviews Jagged Little Pill Average
 7.3
Lackawanna Blues Broadway Reviews Lackawanna Blues Average
 8.6
Moulin Rouge! Broadway Reviews Moulin Rouge! Average
 7.6
Mrs. Doubtfire Broadway Reviews Mrs. Doubtfire Average
 5.9
Pass Over Broadway Reviews Pass Over Average
 7.9
SIX Broadway Reviews SIX Average
 8.4
Slave Play Broadway Reviews Slave Play Average
 8.1
The Book of Mormon Broadway Reviews The Book of Mormon Average
 8.7
The Lehman Trilogy Broadway Reviews The Lehman Trilogy Average
 8.9
The Lion King Broadway Reviews The Lion King Average
 8.8
The Phantom of the Opera Broadway Reviews The Phantom of the Opera Average
 6.8
Thoughts of a Colored Man Broadway Reviews Thoughts of a Colored Man Average
 7.6
Tina: The Tina Turner Musical Broadway Reviews Tina: The Tina Turner Musical Average
 7.1
To Kill A Mockingbird Broadway Reviews To Kill A Mockingbird Average
 8.0
Trouble in Mind Broadway Reviews Trouble in Mind Average
 7.7
Waitress Broadway Reviews Waitress Average
 7.7
Wicked Broadway Reviews Wicked Average
 5.3

Rating System:

10 - effusive praise

9 - excellent

7 or 8 - positive with some reservations

5 or 6 - respectfully unenthused

3 or 4 - mostly negative

2 - little to recommend

1 - offended, insulted, angered
   

Broadway Show Reviews

Review Roundup: MRS. DOUBTFIRE Opens on Broadway Photo MRS. DOUBTFIRE Opens on Broadway
by Review Roundups - December 05, 2021
Review Roundup: CLYDE'S Opens On Broadway- See What the Critics Are Saying! Photo CLYDE'S Opens On Broadway- See What the Critics Are Saying!
by Review Roundups - November 23, 2021
Review Roundup: TROUBLE IN MIND Opens On Broadway Starring Tony-Winner, LaChanze Photo TROUBLE IN MIND Opens On Broadway Starring Tony-Winner, LaChanze
by Review Roundups - November 18, 2021
Review Roundup: Pre-Broadway Run of PARADISE SQUARE Opens in Chicago Photo Pre-Broadway Run of PARADISE SQUARE Opens in Chicago
by Review Roundups - November 18, 2021
Review Roundup: CULLUD WATTAH Opens at The Public Theater Photo Off-Broadway: CULLUD WATTAH Opens at The Public Theater
by Review Roundups - November 18, 2021

New York Show Reviews
BWW Review: A Beloved New York Stage Actor Recalls Six Decades of Theatre in JOH Photo A Beloved New York Stage Actor Recalls Six Decades of Theatre in JOHN CULLUM: AN ACCIDENTAL STAR
by Michael Dale - April 12, 2021
BWW Review: Lupita Nyong'o and Juan Castano Are Bilingual Lovers in The Public's Photo Lupita Nyong'o and Juan Castano Are Bilingual Lovers in The Public's Radio Drama ROMEO Y JULIETA
by Michael Dale - March 28, 2021
BWW Review: Patrick Page Leads a Sumptuous Ensemble in Shakespeare@'s Radio Dram Photo Patrick Page Leads a Sumptuous Ensemble in Shakespeare@'s Radio Drama JULIUS CAESAR
by Michael Dale - March 02, 2021
BWW Review: Theatre Artists Adapt To A Drastically Changed World as The Seeing Photo Theatre Artists Adapt To A Drastically Changed World as The Seeing Place Presents Liz Duffy Adams' DOG ACT
by Michael Dale - February 06, 2021
BWW Review: Jefferson Mays Plays 50+ Characters In A Beautifully Realized Adapt Photo Jefferson Mays Plays 50+ Characters In A Beautifully Realized Adaptation A CHRISTMAS CAROL
by Michael Dale - November 29, 2020

REGIONAL REVIEWS
  or



BWW Review: Deborah Zecher Takes Don't Tell Mama Crowd to Schul with JEWISH CARO Photo Cabaret: Deborah Zecher Takes Don't Tell Mama Crowd to Schul with JEWISH CAROLING
by Stephen Mosher - December 07, 2021
BWW Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL is a Festive Hug at the MILWAUKEE REP Photo Milwaukee, WI: A CHRISTMAS CAROL is a Festive Hug at the MILWAUKEE REP
by Kelsey Lawler - December 07, 2021
BWW Review: A Glorious Return of JAMIE DeROY & FRIENDS Enlivens and Enriches Eve Photo Cabaret: A Glorious Return of JAMIE DeROY & FRIENDS Enlivens and Enriches Evening at Birdland
by Stephen Mosher - December 07, 2021
BWW Review: LOVE ACTUALLY LIVE Sparkles Like a Tree Full of Ornaments on Christm Photo Los Angeles: LOVE ACTUALLY LIVE Sparkles Like a Tree Full of Ornaments on Christmas Eve
by Harker Jones - December 07, 2021
BWW Review: CINDERELLA at Manatee Performing Arts Center Photo Sarasota: CINDERELLA at Manatee Performing Arts Center
by Jacob Ruscoe - December 07, 2021
BWW Review: A JOLLY HOLIDAY at Paper Mill Playhouse is a Musical Treasure Photo New Jersey: A JOLLY HOLIDAY at Paper Mill Playhouse is a Musical Treasure
by Marina Kennedy - December 07, 2021
BWW Review: CINDERELLA at Synetic Theater Photo Washington, DC: CINDERELLA at Synetic Theater
by Dara Homer - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: GAY MEN'S CHORUS OF WASHINGTON ---THE HOLIDAY SHOW Photo Washington, DC: GAY MEN'S CHORUS OF WASHINGTON ---THE HOLIDAY SHOW
by David Friscic - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE: A LIVE RADIO PLAY at Lucie Stern Theatre Photo San Francisco: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE: A LIVE RADIO PLAY at Lucie Stern Theatre
by Steve Murray - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: GEEZERS at Ankeny Community Theatre Photo Des Moines: GEEZERS at Ankeny Community Theatre
by DC Felton - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: THE WICKHAMS: CHRISTMAS AT PEMBERLEY at Ensemble Theatre Company Photo Santa Barbara: THE WICKHAMS: CHRISTMAS AT PEMBERLEY at Ensemble Theatre Company
by Maggie Yates - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE: A LIVE RADIO PLAY at Lucie Stern Theatre Photo San Francisco: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE: A LIVE RADIO PLAY at Lucie Stern Theatre
by Steve Murray - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: A STRANGE LOOP at Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company Photo Washington, DC: A STRANGE LOOP at Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
by Timothy Treanor - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: STORIA DI UNA BELLA E DI UNA BESTIA alla Cappella Orsini Lab Photo Italy: STORIA DI UNA BELLA E DI UNA BESTIA alla Cappella Orsini Lab
by ETTORE FARRATTINI - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL is Magnificently Heartwarming at The Alliance Thea Photo Atlanta: A CHRISTMAS CAROL is Magnificently Heartwarming at The Alliance Theatre
by Ella Outlaw - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: WONDERLAND at The Can Can Photo Seattle: WONDERLAND at The Can Can
by Jay Irwin - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Geva Theatre Photo Central New York: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Geva Theatre
by Colin Fleming-Stumpf - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: RENT at Golden Gate Theatre Photo San Francisco: RENT at Golden Gate Theatre
by Steve Murray - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: AMINE HACHEM Takes Feinstein's/54 Below Patrons on a Musical Trip Ar Photo Cabaret: AMINE HACHEM Takes Feinstein's/54 Below Patrons on a Musical Trip Around the World
by Stephen Mosher - December 06, 2021
BWW Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL AT CHESAPEAKE SHAKESPEARE COMPANY at Chesapeake Sh Photo Baltimore: A CHRISTMAS CAROL AT CHESAPEAKE SHAKESPEARE COMPANY at Chesapeake Shakespeare Company
by Timoth David Copney - December 06, 2021