Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: MR. DICKENS AND HIS CAROL at The Seattle Rep

Review: MR. DICKENS AND HIS CAROL at The Seattle Rep

A seemingly biographical play that never happened … and shouldn’t have.

Review: MR. DICKENS AND HIS CAROL at The Seattle Rep
Members of the cast of
Mr. Dickens and His Carol at Seattle Rep.
Photo credit: Lindsay Thomas.

Charles Dickens' "A Christmas Carol" is an enduring classic. We all know this. It's never been out of publication since its first publishing in 1843. It has spawned numerous movie, TV, and stage adaptations from the serious to the Muppets. Now the Seattle Rep has come along with a World Premiere of Samantha Silva's "Mr. Dickens and His Carol", based on her book of the same name. Taking a supposed look at the creation of this classic tale, this historical fiction is heavy on the fiction and light on the history, cutting a wide swath with its poetic license about the author and turning him into a pompous buffoon in a story and a production in desperate need of an editor.

Silva's fiction starts with the truth that Dickens, a celebrated and successful author, finds his latest book "Martin Chuzzlewit" underperforming in its sales. So much so that his publishers are looking to reduce his monthly income to pay for the poor sales and encourage him to write a Christmas story, as they tended to sell well. And that's where the truth starts to wane. The rest of the play is filled with inanities of Dickens complaining about people demanding money from him, physically turning himself into the likeness of Scrooge to evade his family and creditors, and cheating on his wife several times, turning this beloved author into a philandering, whining, miser.

OK, fine, no one is above parody, but the story and play itself has no idea what story it wants to tell. Act one meanders about, introducing character after character that lend nothing to any assemblance of plot. In fact, it takes an inordinate amount of time introducing his family and then dismisses them for the majority of the play making me wonder why we needed all that exposition about them. Overly complicated seems to be the theme of this show as it keeps trying to turn Dickens into Scrooge and somehow correlate his life during the creation of "A Christmas Carol" with the story itself. Right down to a crutch wielding little boy named Tim and an overly contrived ghost. And then to try and make light of these situations, she insists on throwing in instance after instance where the characters reference Dickens' quotes, titles, and characters in their daily conversation which just felt pandering.

To make matters worse, Silva, whose notes in the program say she's much more experienced with writing screenplays than stage plays, treats the structure of the show like a movie. Way too many locations and characters, forcing director Braden Abraham to include several moments where people wander about the stage on a turntable, saying nothing, to indicate the passage from one place to the next. So many times, in fact, that several moments began to look like montages ... on stage!

Review: MR. DICKENS AND HIS CAROL at The Seattle Rep
Adam Standley and Basil Harris in
Mr. Dickens and His Carol at Seattle Rep.
Photo credit: Lindsay Thomas.

The need for an editor of the staging and script extends to the production as well with a set from Scott Bradley that, at first, looked interesting but then felt overly complicated, under thought out, and overdressed. The most egregious point came when we entered Mr. Bumble's (the name of a character from "Oliver Twist") toy shop. Remember it's 1843 but the décor has crates with the Coca-Cola emblem (which wasn't introduced until 1886) and worse, a prominently displayed board game of "The Waltons" TV show. Because the kids in 1843 liked to watch 1970's television shows?!

The cast of Seattle A-listers tries their best with this overblown script, but they look at if they are trying. Adam Standley as Dickens comes off as a one-note fool who doesn't so much grow in the story, as he just prattles until the show is over. An ending that seemed to happen five or six times mind you in this over two-and-a-half-hour play. Other wonderful actors forced into horrible roles include Julie Briskman and Basil Harris in multiple roles trying to keep the levity up and Sunam Ellis whose character seems to be utterly clueless as to how money works. The one moment of sincerity in the show, unsurprisingly, comes from R. Hamilton Wright as Dickens' mooching father.

Overly complicated script, overly complicated staging, and an overly complicated set in a tale that acts like it's history but is definitely not makes this one of the rare severe fumbles from an otherwise solid theater company. And so, with my three-letter rating system, I give "Mr. Dickens and His Carol" an "I guess I'm the Scrooge here", NAH Humbug. A show, based on real people, with not one likable character in the bunch.

"Mr. Dickens and His Carol" performs at the Seattle Rep through December 23rd. For tickets or information visit them online at www.seattlerep.org.



Review: SENSE AND SENSIBILITY at Village Theatre Photo
Love and longing, mistakes and matches, SENSE AND SENSIBILITY pairs all the ups and down and ins and outs of love and marriage in one show. Village Theatre’s production of this Kate Hamill adaptation also pairs the traditional story with exaggerations of the humor and sarcasm. It is light and diverting as well as deep and meaningful. In short, it has a bit of everything to satisfy the tastes of all the Mariannes and Elinors out there.

Review: HISTORY OF THEATRE: ABOUT, BY, FOR, AND NEAR at ACT Theatre Photo
A new work by ACT Theatre and the Hansberry Project, HISTORY OF THEATRE: ABOUT, BY, FOR, and NEAR will take you on a journey through time and space to meet the people who forged the foundations for Blacks in theater. The show dispels myths about minstrelsy, delves into the hows and whys of black face, and covers key players of early theater in America. Unheard voices are released, forgotten stars are remembered, and a rich legacy is revealed.

Acclaimed Filmmaker Roya Sadat Directs World Premiere of A THOUSAND SPLENDID SUNS at Seatt Photo
When acclaimed Afghan filmmaker Roya Sadat agreed to direct the operatic premiere of A Thousand Splendid Suns, the challenges encountered by the story's Mariam and Laila, two women brought together under brutal Taliban rule, were a reminder of a traumatic period in Afghanistan's history.

Review: METAMORPHOSES at Seattle Repertory Theatre Photo
Compelling storytelling is the focus of METAMORPHOSES at Seattle Rep. Every choice is made with intention, and every facet of the show is a work of collaboration. The gods, the humans, and the demigods are all shown to have strengths and weaknesses. With stories that reach back into the eons of the past, METAMORPHOSES leads you to laugh, to hurt, and to reflect on what it means to be human.


From This Author - Jay Irwin

         Born and raised in Seattle, WA, Jay has been a theater geek for years.  He attends as many shows as he can around the country and loves taking in new exciting... (read more about this author)


Review: BECOMING OTHELLO: A BLACK GIRL'S JOURNEY at Seattle Shakespeare CompanyReview: BECOMING OTHELLO: A BLACK GIRL'S JOURNEY at Seattle Shakespeare Company
January 7, 2023

Dear Readers, you know I find one person shows to be problematic. Often, they get into maudlin territories and end up being someone else’s therapy on stage. So, I was dubious when Seattle Shakespeare Company announced Debra Ann Byrd’s one woman show “Becoming Othello: A Black Girl’s Journey” to start off their 2023. As Byrd stepped onto stage at the Center Theatre, I took it as a good sign that we didn’t get the cliché, “Oh, I didn’t see you there” as if we’d intruded on her private moments. Instead, we got not words but song and movement offering up prayers to her ancestors who got her to where she is today. And then what followed was 90 minutes of a raw, well-paced, well-constructed look into this amazing woman who broke down the barriers erected in front of her by centuries of selfish oppression. Also, what followed was a hell of a way to start off 2023.

SEATTLE CRITIC'S CHOICE AWARDS (JAY'S PICKS) 2022SEATTLE CRITIC'S CHOICE AWARDS (JAY'S PICKS) 2022
January 6, 2023

Dear Readers, I don’t need to tell you, it’s been a crazy year. Many theaters just coming back to life or ramping up again post pandemic. But even with all the chaos, Seattle still comes up with some amazing shows from theaters large and small. Here’s a list of my personal picks for outstanding shows and performers from the past year, 2022.

Review: MOULIN ROUGE! THE MUSICAL at The Paramount TheatreReview: MOULIN ROUGE! THE MUSICAL at The Paramount Theatre
December 17, 2022

More. That, Dear Readers, is the watchword the creators of the stage adaption of the 2001 Baz Luhrmann film, “Moulin Rouge!”, subscribed to. They threw in more sparkle wherever they could in this stage musical, currently playing at the Paramount. Unfortunately, they also threw in more songs, more lights, and certainly more bass in this spectacle that loses the heart and charm of the original in favor of assaulting the audience’s senses.

Review: THE FLIGHT BEFORE XMAS from Macha Theatre WorksReview: THE FLIGHT BEFORE XMAS from Macha Theatre Works
December 4, 2022

Dear Readers, we all know that travelling during the holidays can be a nightmare. Delayed flights, family drama, not to mention dealing with others attempting their own travels. But as frustrating as it can be, what’s not frustrating is the delightful cast of characters created by Maggie Lee in her play, “The Flight Before Xmas”. A wonderful and heartfelt diversion from the usual holiday fare currently playing at West of Lenin from Macha Theatre Works.

Review: MR. DICKENS AND HIS CAROL at The Seattle RepReview: MR. DICKENS AND HIS CAROL at The Seattle Rep
December 1, 2022

Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol” is an enduring classic. We all know this. It’s never been out of publication since its first publishing in 1843. It has spawned numerous movie, TV, and stage adaptations from the serious to the Muppets. Now the Seattle Rep has come along with a World Premiere of Samantha Silva’s “Mr. Dickens and His Carol”, based on her book of the same name. Taking a supposed look at the creation of this classic tale, this historical fiction is heavy on the fiction and light on the history, cutting a wide swath with its poetic license about the author and turning him into a pompous buffoon in a story and a production in desperate need of an editor.