My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company

The production runs from February 13 to March 9, 2025.

By:

Marking the start of another extraordinary season dedicated to new voices and compelling stories, New Jersey Repertory Company will launch its 28th season of groundbreaking world premieres with Make Believe by acclaimed playwright John Biguenet, directed by NJ Rep’s Artistic Director SuzAnne Barabas. See photos from the production.

The production runs from February 13 to March 9, 2025, and will celebrate its opening on February 15 at NJRep’s intimate theater in Long Branch. For more information and to purchase tickets, please visit www.NJRep.org.

Make Believe is a nostalgic, haunting look back at the world of 1930's Hollywood, where larger-than-life movie stars went to great lengths to keep their secrets from coming to light. Starring Quentin Chisholm (NJRep’s The Bookstore. Film: BORN2LOSE, West) and Éilis Cahill (The Road to Jerusalem. British indie film Mind-set) as Eleanor and Bailey as two lost souls who are thrown together to create a fantastical scenario that could only be dreamed up in Hollywood, the land of dreams.

The creative team includes set design by Jessica Parks, lighting design by Jill Nagle, technical direction by Brian Snyder, costume design by Patricia E. Doherty, sound design by Nick Simone, and choreography by  Jordan Ryder, with assistant director Janey Huber. 

John Biguenet, author of Broomstick, Rising Water, and numerous other works, brings his unique storytelling to NJ Rep once again. His accolades include the O. Henry Award, Harper’s Magazine Writing Award, and recognition in The Best American Short Stories. Biguenet’s works have been celebrated across the U.S. and internationally, solidifying his reputation as a master playwright and storyteller.

The production is helmed by SuzAnne Barabas, whose extensive directing credits at NJ Rep include The Housewives of Mannheim, Broomstick, The Adjustment, and more. A dedicated advocate for new works, Barabas brings her visionary direction to Make Believe, ensuring a season opener that audiences won’t forget.

Photo Credit: NJ Rep 

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill

Photos: MAKE BELIEVE At New Jersey Repertory Company Image
Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill



Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Ensemble - Top 3
1. The Lost Boys
22.3% of votes
2. Schmigadoon!
12% of votes
3. Chess
11.1% of votes

Need more New Jersey Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Raymie Nightingale, A World Premiere Musical in New Jersey Raymie Nightingale, A World Premiere Musical
StageWorks Theatre (5/07-5/17)
Hey! I Heard You're Black in New Jersey Hey! I Heard You're Black
Unidentified Stages (6/05-6/06)
Not the Right Mom Written & Performed by Megan Dolan in New Jersey Not the Right Mom Written & Performed by Megan Dolan
Avenel Performing Arts Center (5/30-5/30) PHOTOS VIDEOS
A Change of Position in New Jersey A Change of Position
New Jersey Repertory Company (7/30-8/23)
Frozen in New Jersey Frozen
Hackensack Meridian Health Theatre at the Count Basie Center (2/12-2/14)
Hollywood Hits: From West Side Story to Spirited Away in New Jersey Hollywood Hits: From West Side Story to Spirited Away
Count Basie Center for the Arts (10/10-10/10)
Memphis in New Jersey Memphis
Hackensack Meridian Health Theatre at the Count Basie Center (4/23-4/25)
The Vienna Lessons in New Jersey The Vienna Lessons
New Jersey Repertory Company (6/04-6/28)
And Then There Were None in New Jersey And Then There Were None
Spotlight Players @ The Fist Presbyterian Church of Matawan (5/08-5/17)
Mrs. Christie in New Jersey Mrs. Christie
McCarter Theatre Center (5/06-5/31)