tracker
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses

CENTRAL NEW YORK THEATER REVIEWS

The latest reviews and critic recommendations from Central New York
Review: WICKED at Proctors Theatre

Review: WICKED at Proctors Theatre

by Peyton VanDerheyden — November 1, 2025
What did our critic think of WICKED at Proctors Theatre? The WICKED national tour has seen nearly 25 million patrons across the country, and for good reason....
Review: TWELFTH NIGHT at Pendragon Theatre

Review: TWELFTH NIGHT at Pendragon Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — August 2, 2025
Pendragon Theatre’s production of Twelfth Night delivers a fresh and delightfully offbeat take on the Shakespearean classic, transporting audiences from Illyria to a rustic Adirondack summer camp (Illyria Lake)....
Review: THE FERRYMAN at Rochester Community Players

Review: THE FERRYMAN at Rochester Community Players

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — April 27, 2025
What did our critic think of THE FERRYMAN at Rochester Community Players? Every so often, a production comes along that reminds you exactly why Irish theatre holds such a special place in the dramatic canon. Rochester Community Players’ The Ferryman by Jez Butterworth is one such production—spoo...
Review: PURE NATIVE at Geva Theatre

Review: PURE NATIVE at Geva Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — April 24, 2025
Geva Theatre’s latest production, Pure Native by Vickie Ramirez, is a gripping and gorgeously realized exploration of identity, tradition, and the complicated interplay between cultural survival and economic progress. ...
Review: LITTLE WOMEN at Geva Theatre

Review: LITTLE WOMEN at Geva Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — March 2, 2025
Geva Theatre’s production of Little Women is superb—a moving, beautifully crafted adaptation that honors Alcott’s legacy while offering fresh insights into Jo’s artistic journey....
Review: NINA SIMONE: FOUR WOMEN at Geva Theatre

Review: NINA SIMONE: FOUR WOMEN at Geva Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — January 24, 2025
What did our critic think of NINA SIMONE: FOUR WOMEN at Geva Theatre?...
Review: DANCING WITH THE STARS: LIVE! TOUR at Proctors Theatre

Review: DANCING WITH THE STARS: LIVE! TOUR at Proctors Theatre

by Peyton VanDerheyden — January 23, 2025
What did our critic think of DANCING WITH THE STARS: LIVE! TOUR at Proctors Theatre?...
Review: THE PRINCE OF EGYPT at OFC Creations Theatre Center

Review: THE PRINCE OF EGYPT at OFC Creations Theatre Center

by Matea Kanicki — December 17, 2024
What did our critic think of THE PRINCE OF EGYPT at OFC Creations Theatre Center?...
Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Geva Theatre

Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Geva Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — December 8, 2024
What did our critic think of A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Geva Theatre?...
Review: LES MISERABLES at Rochester Broadway Theatre League

Review: LES MISERABLES at Rochester Broadway Theatre League

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — October 16, 2024
The Rochester Broadway Theatre League begins its 2024-2025 season with one of the 20th century’s most iconic musicals; one that has traversed the globe, been spun into multiple screen adaptations and has done pit stops at the West Herr Auditorium Theatre on more than one occasion in recent years. ...
Review: SWEENEY TODD: THE DEMON BARBER OF FLEET STREET at Blackfriars Theatre

Review: SWEENEY TODD: THE DEMON BARBER OF FLEET STREET at Blackfriars Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — September 15, 2024
What did our critic think of SWEENEY TODD: THE DEMON BARBER OF FLEET STREET at Blackfriars Theatre?...
Review: RENT at Blackfriars Theatre

Review: RENT at Blackfriars Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — July 21, 2024
What did our critic think of RENT at Blackfriars Theatre?...
Review: A CHORUS LINE at JCC Centerstage Theatre

Review: A CHORUS LINE at JCC Centerstage Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — July 15, 2024
Reviewing summer youth theatre productions is always an assignment I eagerly anticipate, because I’m reminded of the treasure trove of young theatrical talent that Rochester has to offer. Summer youth shows in Rochester (Blackfriars Theatre and JCC both have them) consistently feature professional...
Review: THE COLOR PURPLE at Geva Theatre

Review: THE COLOR PURPLE at Geva Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — June 8, 2024
What did our critic think of THE COLOR PURPLE at Geva Theatre?...
Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL at JCC CenterStage Theatre

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL at JCC CenterStage Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — May 10, 2024
What did our critic think of BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL at JCC CenterStage Theatre?...
Review: CABARET at Blackfriars Theatre

Review: CABARET at Blackfriars Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — May 10, 2024
One of theatre’s many powers is its ability to reflect the happenings of the outside world, illuminating events and societal trends, and even portending things to come. When “Cabaret” was written in 1966 we were only one generation removed from the biggest global conflict in world history, in ...
Review: THREE MOTHERS at Capital Repertory Theatre

Review: THREE MOTHERS at Capital Repertory Theatre

by Noah Casner — May 3, 2024
I’ll be the first to admit that when it came time for me to see Three Mothers, I was a bit worried what the experience would be. Watching three women grieve the loss of their sons didn’t sound like the kind of activity I would generally choose to subject myself to for entertainment— it frankl...
Review: CHICAGO THE MUSICAL at Proctors Theatre

Review: CHICAGO THE MUSICAL at Proctors Theatre

by Peyton VanDerheyden — April 21, 2024
What did our critic think of CHICAGO THE MUSICAL at Proctors Theatre?...
Review: STELLA AND LOU at Out Of Pocket Productions

Review: STELLA AND LOU at Out Of Pocket Productions

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — April 20, 2024
What did our critic think of STELLA AND LOU at Out Of Pocket Productions?...
Review: CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF at Company Theatre

Review: CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF at Company Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — April 13, 2024
What did our critic think of CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF at Company Theatre?...
Review: SISTERS IN LAW at JCC Centerstage Theatre

Review: SISTERS IN LAW at JCC Centerstage Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — April 8, 2024
Currently playing at Rochester’s JCC Centerstage Theatre is a play that seems out of place in our modern era of intense division and heightened polarization because it explores the deep respect and affection between two people who hold sharply different political and philosophical views, performed...
Review: JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR: 50TH ANNIVERSARY TOUR at Proctors

Review: JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR: 50TH ANNIVERSARY TOUR at Proctors

by Noah Casner — April 7, 2024
What did our critic think of JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR: 50TH ANNIVERSARY TOUR AT PROCTORS at Proctors?...
Review: SANCTUARY CITY at Geva Theatre

Review: SANCTUARY CITY at Geva Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — March 29, 2024
Currently playing on Geva Theatre’s Fielding Stage is “Sanctuary City”, a powerful—and timely—story about the American dream and the concept of home....
Review: MRS. DOUBTFIRE at Rochester Broadway Theatre League

Review: MRS. DOUBTFIRE at Rochester Broadway Theatre League

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — February 22, 2024
f you’re a 90’s kid like me, that famous greeting from cinema’s most iconic Scottish nanny is permanently imprinted on your memory, especially if, like me, your childhood home had “Mrs. Doubtfire” playing on repeat throughout your formative years (I think we eventually burned out the VHS t...
Review: OEDIPUS REX at Company Theatre

Review: OEDIPUS REX at Company Theatre

by Colin Fleming-Stumpf — February 18, 2024
What did our critic think of OEDIPUS REX at Company Theatre?...
Next »
Page 1 of 3

Videos