Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: SANCTUARY CITY at Geva Theatre

What did our critic think of SANCTUARY CITY at Geva Theatre?

By:
Review: SANCTUARY CITY at Geva Theatre

Currently playing on Geva Theatre’s Fielding Stage is “Sanctuary City”, a powerful—and timely—story about the American dream and the concept of home.

“Sanctuary City” is a play by Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright Martyna Majok. In post-9/11 Newark, NJ, two teenagers who were brought to America as children become one another’s sanctuaries from harsh circumstances. When G (Cheryse Dyllan) becomes naturalized, she and B (Shawn Denegre-Vaught) hatch a plan to marry so that he may legally remain in the country and pursue the future he imagines for his life. But as time hurtles on and complications mount, the young friends find that this act challenges and fractures the closest relationship either has ever had.

“Sanctuary City” gives the audience a devastating glimpse into the everyday existence of an undocumented immigrant; one where there is little hope, no reprieve, and no rest in sight. B’s story is one in which he can’t live openly and freely, can’t pursue his dreams, and functionally has nowhere to call home. His mother has long left him to return to their country of origin, and despite being an overachieving student his immigration status makes higher education unobtainable. His plight traps him in a hamster wheel of grinding out long hours at under-the-table service jobs, only to rinse and repeat the next day. He has little memory of his home country, but his DREAMer status makes it impossible for America to ever seem like home, either. “Sanctuary City”, while devastating, illustrates America’s hypocrisy and utterly broken immigration system.

“Sanctuary City” is a bit hard to digest at first, with its beginning 30-40 minutes presented as rapid back-and-forth cuts between different moments in B and G’s friendship, which struck me as a somewhat dizzying storytelling vehicle. That said, the play’s second half packs an emotional wallop that’s well worth the wait. In the play’s back half, we meet Henry (Robert Denzel Edwards), B’s boyfriend, whom G immediately identifies as an existential threat in B/G’s marriage plot (if authorities were to discover Henry, it would become clear that B/G’s marriage was for show, potentially leading to imprisonment for G and deportation for B). Edwards is astounding, delivering a performance that is at times confrontational, sympathetic, enraged, and confounded. His chemistry with both Denegre-Vaught and Dyllan is palpable and authentic, and his character rounds-out the play’s message; that for DREAMers like B, living a full, happy, authentic life is impossible.

“Sanctuary City” is a gripping, heartbreaking play that will have you contemplating the concept of the American dream—and whether it’s still possible—long after leaving Geva. For tickets and more information, click here.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Geva Theatre
Upcoming Shows
Get Happy: Angela Ingersoll sings Judy Garland
Get Happy: Angela Ingersoll sings Judy Garland
7/23 - 8/2/2026

Reader Reviews

Love Theater in Central New York? Join The Community!

Whether you've got past experience writing about theater or just starting, the BroadwayWorld Community offers a unique opportunity to become a champion for your local arts community, helping raise awareness of local offerings and adding another local voice to the conversation at a time arts coverage is shrinking in the press across the continent. Join us and become a pivotal part of the movement that celebrates and promotes the arts in the digital age.

Learn More
Don't Miss a Central New York News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Così in Central New York Così
Glimmerglass Festival (7/17-8/14)
Così in Central New York Così
Glimmerglass Festival (7/17-8/14)
Fellow Travelers in Central New York Fellow Travelers
Glimmerglass Festival (7/18-8/16)
Madame Butterfly in Central New York Madame Butterfly
The Glimmerglass Festival (7/11-8/17)
Oklahoma! in Central New York Oklahoma!
The Glimmerglass Festival (7/10-8/17)
THE PROM in Central New York THE PROM
The Wood Theater (8/14-8/23)
OFC Creations Theatre Presents: The Witches of Eastwick in Central New York OFC Creations Theatre Presents: The Witches of Eastwick
OFC Creations Theatre Center (3/04-3/21)
Annie Jr. in Central New York Annie Jr.
Foothills Performing Arts Center (7/24-7/26)
Mystic Pizza in Central New York Mystic Pizza
Capital Repertory Theatre (7/10-8/09)
A Dream (Role) Come True in Central New York A Dream (Role) Come True
Don’t Tell Mama NYC (1/10-12/05)