My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses

LONG ISLAND THEATER REVIEWS

The latest reviews and critic recommendations from Long Island
Review: GREASE Is The Word at The Argyle Theater

Review: GREASE Is The Word at The Argyle Theater

by Nicholas Pontolillo — July 21, 2023
What did our critic think of GREASE at The Argyle Theater?...
Review: DIAL M FOR MURDER at Bay Street Theatre

Review: DIAL M FOR MURDER at Bay Street Theatre

by Melissa Giordano — July 9, 2023
What did our critic think of DIAL M FOR MURDER at Bay Street Theatre?...
Review: HEAD OVER HEELS at Cultural Arts Playhouse

Review: HEAD OVER HEELS at Cultural Arts Playhouse

by Andrew J. Koehler — June 27, 2023
HEAD OVER HEELS opened this weekend at the Cultural Arts Playhouse in Syosset this past Saturday night. Based on the 1593 story “The Countess of Pembroke’s Arcadia,” this 2018 Broadway hit features the music of the Go-Go’s, including “We Got The Beat,” “Heaven Is A Place On Earth,” �...
Review: SUMMER, THE DONNA SUMMER MUSICAL at The Gateway

Review: SUMMER, THE DONNA SUMMER MUSICAL at The Gateway

by Melissa Giordano — June 23, 2023
What did our critic think of SUMMER, THE DONNA SUMMER MUSICAL at The Gateway? Bellport's beautiful Gateway Playhouse certainly has another hit on their hands with their current offering of Summer, The Donna Summer Musical. The energetic production of the Tony nominated musical runs through July 16t...
Review: MEAN GIRLS at Cultural Arts Playhouse

Review: MEAN GIRLS at Cultural Arts Playhouse

by Andrew J. Koehler — June 13, 2023
What did our critic think of MEAN GIRLS at Cultural Arts Playhouse? The 2018 smash-hit musical MEAN GIRLS, based on the 2004 cult classic is playing at the Cultural Arts Playhouse in Merrick. Directed by Taneisha Corbin, the production is bursting at the seams with energy and electricity. ...
Review: The World Premiere of DOUBLE HELIX at Bay Street Theatre

Review: The World Premiere of DOUBLE HELIX at Bay Street Theatre

by Melissa Giordano — June 9, 2023
What did our critic think of THE WORLD PREMIERE OF DOUBLE HELIX at Bay Street Theatre?...
Review: THE PORTUGUESE KID At Quogue Community Hall Presented By The Hampton Theatre

Review: THE PORTUGUESE KID At Quogue Community Hall Presented By The Hampton Theatre Company

by Melissa Giordano — June 2, 2023
What did our critic think of THE PORTUGUESE KID at Quogue Community Hall Presented By The Hampton Theatre Company?...
Review: “Nothing's as amazing as” Theatre Three's production of SOMETHING ROTTEN!

Review: “Nothing's as amazing as” Theatre Three's production of SOMETHING ROTTEN!

by Nicholas Pontolillo — June 1, 2023
What did our critic think of SOMETHING ROTTEN! at Theatre Three?...
Review: MATILDA at Cultural Arts Playhouse

Review: MATILDA at Cultural Arts Playhouse

by Andrew J. Koehler — May 27, 2023
What did our critic think of MATILDA at Cultural Arts Playhouse?...
Review: THE SOUND OF MUSIC at The John W. Engeman Theater

Review: THE SOUND OF MUSIC at The John W. Engeman Theater

by Melissa Giordano — May 30, 2023
Seeing a show like Rodgers and Hammerstein's The Sound Of Music is nothing short of fulfilling. And, true to form, the exquisite John W. Engeman Theater brilliantly delivers this iconic musical. Director Drew Humphreys has splendidly put together an amazing cast to present this enchanting production...
Review: MAMMA MIA! at Plaza Theatrical Productions

Review: MAMMA MIA! at Plaza Theatrical Productions

by Andrew J. Koehler — May 22, 2023
MAMMA MIA! will have you smilin' and havin' fun! Read about it here:...
Review: EVITA at The Gateway

Review: EVITA at The Gateway

by Melissa Giordano — May 12, 2023
What did our critic think of EVITA at The Gateway?...
Review: ROCK OF AGES at The Argyle Theatre

Review: ROCK OF AGES at The Argyle Theatre

by Melissa Giordano — May 5, 2023
What did our critic think of ROCK OF AGES at The Argyle Theatre?...
Review: THE PROM at CM Performing Arts Center

Review: THE PROM at CM Performing Arts Center

by Jenna Fanelli — May 5, 2023
What did our critic think of THE PROM at CM Performing Arts Center? Ironic, satirical, over-the-top and even borderline problematic at select moments as it may be, the book and script for The Prom are undoubtedly laugh-out-loud funny. While the show reminds audiences that homophobia is still rampant...
Review: PRIDE @ PREJUDICE At Theatre Three

Review: PRIDE @ PREJUDICE At Theatre Three

by Melissa Giordano — April 14, 2023
What did our critic think of PRIDE @ PREJUDICE at Theatre Three?...
Review: THE SOUND OF MUSIC at CM Performing Arts Center

Review: THE SOUND OF MUSIC at CM Performing Arts Center

by Jenna Fanelli — April 5, 2023
What did our critic think of THE SOUND OF MUSIC at CM Performing Arts Center? When it comes to legendary pieces, the goal (and the massive challenge) is always to achieve storytelling justice. The Sound of Music is certainly no exception, and the cast and crew of the production currently running at ...
Review: You'll experience many “Moments to Remember” if you see Plaza Theatrical'

Review: You'll experience many “Moments to Remember” if you see Plaza Theatrical's production of FOREVER PLAID at Elmont Memorial Library Theatre

by Nicholas Pontolillo — April 2, 2023
What did our critic think of FOREVER PLAID at Elmont Memorial Library Theatre?...
Review: The Cast and Crew of The John W. Engeman Theater's THE SCARLET PIMPERNEL Can

Review: The Cast and Crew of The John W. Engeman Theater's THE SCARLET PIMPERNEL Can “Hold Their Heads Even Higher” with Their Stunning Production.

by Nicholas Pontolillo — March 28, 2023
What did our critic think of THE SCARLET PIMPERNEL at John W. Engeman Theater At Northport? I must admit I was a little hesitant in seeing The Scarlet Pimpernel because I was starting to believe Frank Wildhorn was a one-hit wonder on Broadway. That one hit wonder of course being Jekyll & Hyde, a gre...
Review: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING At Bacca Arts Center

Review: MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING At Bacca Arts Center

by Nicholas Pontolillo — March 27, 2023
Part of the Bard's First Folio, Much Ado About Nothing is a comedy about two intertwined love stories. After a group of soldiers arrive in Messina, love emerges between Hero, the Governor's daughter, and Claudio, a young officer. The young pair then conspire with Don Pedro, Claudio's commanding offi...
Review: THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT at Hampton Theatre Company

Review: THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT at Hampton Theatre Company

by Melissa Giordano — March 24, 2023
What did our critic think of THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT at Hampton Theatre Company?...
Review: CLUE At The Gateway Playhouse

Review: CLUE At The Gateway Playhouse

by Jenna Fanelli — March 22, 2023
What did our critic think of CLUE at The Gateway Playhouse?...
Review: SIDE BY SIDE BY SONDHEIM at Theatre Three

Review: SIDE BY SIDE BY SONDHEIM at Theatre Three

by Melissa Giordano — February 23, 2023
What did our critic think of SIDE BY SIDE BY SONDHEIM at Theatre Three?...
Review: WEST SIDE STORY at The Argyle

Review: WEST SIDE STORY at The Argyle

by Melissa Giordano — February 16, 2023
What did our critic think of WEST SIDE STORY at The Argyle?...
Review: THE WEDDING SINGER Brings the 80s Back To Life At The Gateway

Review: THE WEDDING SINGER Brings the 80s Back To Life At The Gateway

by Melissa Giordano — February 2, 2023
What did our critic think of THE WEDDING SINGER at The Gateway?...
Review: DIRTY ROTTEN SCOUNDRELS at John W. Engeman Theater

Review: DIRTY ROTTEN SCOUNDRELS at John W. Engeman Theater

by Melissa Giordano — January 26, 2023
What did our critic think of DIRTY ROTTEN SCOUNDRELS at John W. Engeman Theater?...
« Previous Next »
Page 4 of 5

Videos