Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Long Island Theater Reviews

The latest reviews and critic recommendations from Long Island.

Review: ANNIE at Merrick Theatre And Center For The Arts

Review: ANNIE at Merrick Theatre And Center For The Arts

by Sam Desmond — March 11, 2026

The opening night production of “Annie” on Friday, March 6 at the Merrick Theatre & Center for the Arts marked the fourth viewing of the scrappy, upstart orphan I’ve seen this winter alone (there was actually a fifth I could’ve reviewed if BroadwayWorld hired me two weeks earlier).

Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Cultural Arts Playhouse-SYOSSET

Review: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF at Cultural Arts Playhouse-SYOSSET

by Sam Desmond — March 5, 2026

A devastatingly timely production of “Fiddler on the Roof,” by Cultural Arts Playhouse in Syosset brings us to the small, earnest existence of Anatevka, a Jewish town in the Russian empire during the tumultuous turn of the century.

Review: GODSPELL at Theatre Three

Review: GODSPELL at Theatre Three

by Sam Desmond — March 4, 2026

With theatre that touches upon the religious, it can be tricky to strike a balance between artistry and accuracy that carries the audience’s imagination instead of accidentally shunning creativity.

Review: AND THEN THERE WERE NONE at South Shore Theatre Experience

Review: AND THEN THERE WERE NONE at South Shore Theatre Experience

by Sam Desmond — February 9, 2026

With exuberant dramatic tension and ballroom fluidity in blocking, the South Shore Theatre Experience’s production of “And Then There Were None” was filled with tension, retribution, and an impressive number of blood packets.

Review: NEWSIES at The Argyle Theatre

Review: NEWSIES at The Argyle Theatre

by Sam Desmond — February 4, 2026

A musical forged in ambition of set, stage, and stamina, director Tommy Ranieri’s vision of a world only beginning to stand up for their rights was sprawling and spectacular.

Review: BRIGHTON BEACH MEMOIRS at Theatre Three

Review: BRIGHTON BEACH MEMOIRS at Theatre Three

by Sam Desmond — January 23, 2026

The world of late 1930s Brooklyn is brought to life and elucidated in Theatre Three’s triumphant run of the Neil Simon classic,”Brighton Beach Memoirs.

Review: ALICE BY HEART at CAP Syosset

Review: ALICE BY HEART at CAP Syosset

by Sam Desmond — January 15, 2026

The ether of war-torn Britain is all-encompassing in “Alice By Heart,” but director Tony Frangipane’s vision overcomes the Nazi raids to create a personal hell of its own that the young characters escape through a British mainstay—literature.

Review: ANNIE at CAP Syosset

Review: ANNIE at CAP Syosset

by Sam Desmond — January 6, 2026

CAP Syosset had their opening night for this winter’s production of “Annie” on Saturday, January 3 and it was a standout version of the classic rags-to-riches musical with a strong, bonded cast.

Review: HOLIDAY SPECTACULAR ON ICE at The Gateway

Review: HOLIDAY SPECTACULAR ON ICE at The Gateway

by Sam Desmond — December 6, 2025

With the magical notion of having a real ice skating rink on a dramatic stage, the Holiday Spectacular on Ice at the Gateway in Bellport creates wonder in the audience from inception and delivers well beyond expectations in person.

Review: ANNIE at Smithtown Performing Arts Center

Review: ANNIE at Smithtown Performing Arts Center

by Sam Desmond — December 5, 2025

For some holiday cheer, “Annie” at the Smithtown Performing Arts is the Christmas production to bring families that spirit of generosity and can-do attitude for December.

Review: ANASTASIA at The Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company

Review: ANASTASIA at The Lighthouse Repertory Theatre Company

by Sam Desmond — December 3, 2025

In the perennially winter tale of “Anastasia,” a musical about the young Russian woman with claims to be being the lone survivor of the royal Romanov family’s massacre, The Lighthouse Repertory captured the magic and warmth of a Christmas-time story while creating great dramatic tension.

Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three

Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three

by Sam Desmond — November 21, 2025

In the world of Dickens, the reader is for the long-haul of human emotions, and Theatre Three’s 41st annual production has perfected conveying that panoply of passions in the classic, “A Christmas Carol.

Review: ANNIE at The Argyle Theatre

Review: ANNIE at The Argyle Theatre

by Sam Desmond — November 17, 2025

A perennial, heart-warming tale of personal and societal triumph, the Argyle Theatre’s opening night of “Annie” was a celebratory reminder of why we should never give up on our dreams, even if they look a little different when they come true.

Review: FAHRENHEIT 451 at Bay Street Theater

Review: FAHRENHEIT 451 at Bay Street Theater

by Sam Desmond — November 16, 2025

Ray Bradbury’s prescient, Cold War classic, “Fahrenheit 451” was brought to the stage at Bay Street Theater with even more urgency and relevance to our increasingly curated, aesthetic, and good vibes based lives in 2025.

Review: BOO! A MUSICAL ADVENTURE at Bayway Arts Center

Review: BOO! A MUSICAL ADVENTURE at Bayway Arts Center

by Sam Desmond — October 28, 2025

Parents looking to introduce their children to the world of theater patronage should look no further than “Boo! The Musical Adventure” playing at the Bayway Arts Center in East Islip on Saturday and Sunday, November 1 and 2 at 11 am.

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL at CAP Syosset

Review: BEAUTIFUL: THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL at CAP Syosset

by Sam Desmond — October 20, 2025

As in-depth, thrilling, and heart-breaking as Carole King’s legendary album, Tapestry, Cultural Performing Arts Center Syosset’s production of “Beautiful: The Carole King Musical” was a full ride of the human emotions that was embodied in the songs that defined American music for a generatio

Review: LITTLE WOMEN at CAP Merrick

Review: LITTLE WOMEN at CAP Merrick

by Andrew J. Koehler — April 16, 2025

LITTLE WOMEN, the musical based on the 1869 novel of the same name written by Louisa May Alcott, is currently running at CAP Merrick through April 27th.

BroadwayWorld TV


Come From Away in Long Island Come From Away
The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (8/07-9/06)
Little Shop of Horrors: 40th Anniversary Screening Hosted By Ellen Greene in Long Island Little Shop of Horrors: 40th Anniversary Screening Hosted By Ellen Greene
Patchogue Theatre (8/30-8/30)
The Lucky Bride in Long Island The Lucky Bride
Debut Theater Company (8/21-8/30)
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show in Long Island The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective Long Island (9/26-9/26)
CM Teens Presents: Be More Chill in Long Island CM Teens Presents: Be More Chill
CM Teens (11/06-11/08)
Waitress in Long Island Waitress
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (3/23-3/23)
Disney & Pixar's Finding Nemo in Long Island Disney & Pixar's Finding Nemo
The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre (8/23-9/19)
Leopoldstadt in Long Island Leopoldstadt
BACCA Arts Center (12/05-1/03)
Funny Girl in Long Island Funny Girl
The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (1/22-2/21)
The Importance of Being Earnest in Long Island The Importance of Being Earnest
Theatre Three - NY (4/04-4/23)