Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: BUDDY-THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY at Dutch Apple Dinner Theater

Buddy-The Buddy Holly Story claims to be" the most successful rock n' roll musical of all time", and with good reason. It highlights the main events in the last three years of the singer's life, during which he went from local country singer, to rock 'n roll pioneer, to cultural icon. Throw into the mix, more than a dozen classics hits, played live by the actors on stage, and you get a fun and energetic night of entertainment.

Kyle Jurassic plays Holly with a sense of confidence and independence. Jurassic's impressive guitar licks really help enhance the transformation. His lanky frame and thick glasses highlight the fact that this was a musician who became a star based on his talents, not necessarily his looks. Instead, Holly's distinct appearance emphasizes the fact that he was a free-spirit, refusing to bow to 1950's conformity.

Jonah M. Martin and Ben Hill play Joe Maudlin and Jerry Allison, respectively. They play Buddy's friends and the original members of his band, The Crickets. They are excellent musicians and do a great job conveying a sense of playfulness and energy. It was interesting to see their personalities evolve from local Texas boys to national celebrities.

Holly's story is told through several vignettes that recall important events in his rise to fame. Memorable scenes include his interactions with Texas DJ and early supporter Hipockets Duncan (played humorously by Dale Givens), meeting and recording his biggest hits with manager, Norman Petty (Seth Garrett Antes), and a memorable appearance at the Apollo Theater in Harlem. These events bring to life some of the key events that led to Holly's meteoric rise,

The second act introduces Maria Elena Santiago (Danielle Poznanovic), a Puerto Rican receptionist, and the love of Buddy's life. She quickly becomes his supportive and caring wife in a case of love at first site. When things turn sour with his manager and band mates, Holly is forced to go on the road to make ends meet. The final half hour or so of the show is a recreation of his final concert with Richie Valens (Nathaniel Burich) and the Big Bopper (Mike Brennan) that took place just prior to the three of them getting on that charter plane that tragically ended their short lives.

One of the things to understand about this show is it prioritizes celebrating Holly's music over explaining what made him tick. By focusing only on the final three years of his life, we get little idea of how he got so interested in music, or why rock 'n roll was so important to him. There also seems to be no characterization to explain why Buddy liked playing what was considered "Black music" or fell head over heels for a Hispanic girl. Such a level of multicultural acceptance and appreciation would be considered pretty rare in 1950's Texas. It deserves mention. Such concerns are a flaw of the script, not necessarily Dutch Apple's production.

What the show may lack in characterization, it makes up for in musicality. The immediacy of Jurassic and friends playing their instruments on stage brings raw energy and vitality to the theater. Audience toe-tapping evolved into full-fledged dancing in the aisles by the end of the show. Buddy-The Buddy Holly Story is a great celebration of the one of rock 'n roll's true pioneers.

Buddy-The Buddy Holly Story is playing at the Dutch Apple Dinner Theater now through November 11. Tickets and more information can be found at their website- https://dutchapple.com/



Popcorn Hat Players to Present THE ELVES & THE SHOEMAKER in December Photo
Popcorn Hat Players will present The Elves & The Shoemaker from December 3 - 22, 2022 on Saturdays at 1:00 PM.

Review: TWAS THE NIGHT BEFORE CHRISTMAS at Little Theatre Of Mechanicsburg Photo
This adorable show will have audiences of all ages laughing and believing in the magic of the holiday. Take a break from the hustle and bustle of this busy time of year and bring the family to ‘Twas the Night Before Christmas.

First Stats Released For The BroadwayWorld Central Pennsylvania Awards; Ephratas GENTLEMAN Photo
The first live standings have been announced for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Central Pennsylvania Awards! Nominations were reader-submitted and now our readers get to vote for their favorites.

Review: WHITE CHRISTMAS at Fulton Theatre Photo
Fulton Theatre’s current production of the tepid White Christmas is an excellent example of the old adage “there are no small parts, only small actors”. Fulton Theatre?


From This Author - Rich Mehrenberg

Rich Mehrenberg was introduced to the magic of theater when he played "The Boy" in his first grade class production of "The Giving Tree". It has been a long term love affair eve... (read more about this author)


Review: WHITE CHRISTMAS at Fulton TheatreReview: WHITE CHRISTMAS at Fulton Theatre
November 20, 2022

Fulton Theatre’s current production of the tepid White Christmas is an excellent example of the old adage “there are no small parts, only small actors”. Fulton Theatre?

Review: THE COLOR PURPLE at EPACReview: THE COLOR PURPLE at EPAC
October 15, 2022

Pleasant surprises are the best kind.

Review: SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER at Dutch Apple Dinner TheatreReview: SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre
October 3, 2022

If you ever owned a leisure suit or drank a can of Billy beer, this show has something for you. However, if you expect something beyond a live version of the 1977 movie, you might be disappointed.

Review: THE BOOK OF MORMON at Hershey TheaterReview: THE BOOK OF MORMON at Hershey Theater
September 30, 2022

What did our critic think of THE BOOK OF MORMON at Hershey Theater? The Book of Mormon is a contradiction in that it is both totally filthy and wonderfully wholesome at the same time. This leads to non-stop laughs, a few gasps, and a good feeling in the bottom of your heart when it is all over.

Review: FOR COLORED BOYZ at Fulton TheatreReview: FOR COLORED BOYZ at Fulton Theatre
September 19, 2022

it will get you talking and get you thinking. It will stay with you. Theater on Fulton's 4th floor is often more complex, more intense, and more thought-provoking than what is performed on the main stage. Past shows such as Blackbird, Sweat, and I Am My Own Wife are perfect examples of this mission. However, their current production of FOR COLORED BOYZ on the verge of a nervous breakdown/ when freedom ain't enuff takes those expectations to a whole new level.