Broadway Stars and Emerging Talent Join Forces for WHAT IF? PART 6 at 54 Below
Created and music directed by Jorden Amir, the series invites audiences to consider unexpected pairings—characters singing songs they were never meant to.
The sixth installment of the imaginative concert series What If? will take place at 54 Below on June 1, 2025, bringing together Broadway performers and up-and-coming artists to explore alternate realities in musical theatre.
Created and music directed by Jorden Amir, the series invites audiences to consider unexpected pairings—characters singing songs they were never meant to, in scenes they never got to play.
The cast includes Broadway’s Grace Hodgett Young (Hadestown, Sunset Boulevard), Jordan Barrow (Wicked), Ellie Fishman (Into the Woods), Mikayla Renfrow (Wicked), Lizzy Legregin (Back to the Future), and American Idol finalist Alyssa Wray. They will be joined by a range of performers from top conservatories and training programs, including Angelina Amato, Faith Alhadeff, Kaileigh Fiorillo, Callie Henrysen, Isabela Garcia, Nadia Jewel Vito, Isabel Leoni, Ayden Weinstein, and Abby McDonough. Juliette Ojeda, known for her work in The Notebook on Broadway and The Voice, also appears, alongside Bryson Battle, a finalist from The Voice Season 27, and songwriter Maeve Zamuner.
Together, the cast will perform a mix of musical theatre classics and contemporary songs in newly imagined contexts, continuing the series' tradition of creative reinterpretation. What If? Part 6 builds on the success of previous editions staged between 2022 and 2024, and reflects Amir’s ongoing interest in broadening access to musical theatre and showcasing younger voices in the Broadway community.
What If? Part 6 runs for one night only at 54 Below, 254 West 54th Street. Tickets range from $40 to $84, with a $25 food and beverage minimum. Full details are available at 54below.org/WhatIf.
Videos
|
Finding Their Voice: Broadway Stars Unite to Support Israel's Youth The Jerry Orbach Theatre (6/15-6/15) |
|
Re-Arranged: A Night of New Arrangements 54 Below (8/05-8/05) |
|
54 Goes Classic Rock (Pt. 2): The Moody Blues 54 Below (8/12-8/12) |
|
Voices for Change: A Night of Harmony 54 Below (6/16-6/16) |
|
Treston J. Henderson: The Living Room Session Vol. 2 54 Below (6/15-6/15) |
|
54 Sings Jeff Buckley: It’s Never Over 54 Below (10/01-10/01) |
|
Britani Bateman: What About Me? 54 Below (8/31-8/31) |
|
Kenny Allan Smith: Kenny’s Turn 54 Below (6/30-6/30) |
|
Dancers Over 40 Celebrates George M! With Original Cast Members 54 Below (7/05-7/05) |
|
Write Out Loud: From Contest to Concert Volume 8 54 Below (9/14-9/14) |
| VIEW ALL SHOWS ADD A SHOW | |