My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City

Delaney “Lanes” May directs the world premiere of the new drama exploring youth, recovery, and the will to live.

By:

Connoly, a new play by Stefan Diethelm, opens November 6 at Theatre for the New City, directed by Delaney “Lanes” May. Check out photos of the production below!

The play follows a teenage girl navigating recovery inside a mental health facility with the help—and complications—of those who love her most. Running through November 23, Connoly offers a moving meditation on family, healing, and the fragile hope that keeps us alive.

After surviving a suicide attempt, Connoly, a teenage girl, is placed in an in-patient mental health facility. There, she begins the slow, painful process of recovery with the support of her older sister Dingo, a strict yet compassionate nurse named Natalya, and her best friend Georgie—who may be imaginary, or perhaps something more spectral. As Connoly struggles to find meaning in survival, she and those around her must face the limits of love, faith, and endurance.

A contemporary tragedy of youth, Connoly confronts the realities of mental illness and the resilience it demands. Diethelm’s writing balances empathy and intensity, revealing both the darkness of despair and the beauty of persistence.

The cast features Emily Kendall Cohen, Madi Daning, Abby Messina, Nikki Neuberger, and Alessia Seclì. The creative and production team includes Cody Hom (lighting/sound design) and Matthew Seepersad (stage management). The play is produced by Stefan Diethelm, Delaney “Lanes” May, and Bradly Valenzuela.

Content Advisory: Connoly contains sensitive material including references to suicide, self-harm, and mental illness.

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City Image
Nikki Neuberger, Abby Messina, Emily Kendall

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City Image
Nikki Neuberger

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City Image
Emily Kendall

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City Image
Abby Messina, Nikki Neuberger, Emily Kendall

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City Image
Nikki Neuberger, Abby Messina, Emily Kendall

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City Image
Abby Messina

Photos: Stefan Diethelm’s CONNOLY Premieres at Theatre for the New City Image
Alessia Secl , Nikki Neuberger, Abby Messina, Emily Kendall



Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Lead Performer in a Musical - Top 3
1. LJ Benet - The Lost Boys, A New Musical
20.4% of votes
2. Joshua Henry - Ragtime
15.7% of votes
3. Sam Tutty - Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
9.7% of votes

Don't Miss a Off-Off-Broadway News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Broadway Magic Hour in Off-Off-Broadway Broadway Magic Hour
Broadway Comedy Club (1/01-6/30) VIDEOS
Barbie Fest: The Unauthorized Unofficial Parodies of the Princess & the Pauper and the Three Musketeers in Off-Off-Broadway Barbie Fest: The Unauthorized Unofficial Parodies of the Princess & the Pauper and the Three Musketeers
The Chain (5/21-5/24)
Rock Never Dies in Off-Off-Broadway Rock Never Dies
Hard Rock Cafe (5/29-8/30) PHOTOS VIDEOS
"Present Laughter" by Noel Coward  in Off-Off-Broadway "Present Laughter" by Noel Coward
Stag & Lion Theatre (5/14-5/24)
Miss Robusta's Reel to Real: From Film to Footlights in Off-Off-Broadway Miss Robusta's Reel to Real: From Film to Footlights
The Stonewall Inn (5/27-5/27)
THE CIRCUIT: An Immersive Silent Disco Ballet in Off-Off-Broadway THE CIRCUIT: An Immersive Silent Disco Ballet
New York Theatre Company (5/15-6/29)
Intrepid Museum’s Battle of the Big Bands in Off-Off-Broadway Intrepid Museum’s Battle of the Big Bands
Intrepid Museum (5/23-5/23)
Don’t Cry For Me, My Yeshiva in Off-Off-Broadway Don’t Cry For Me, My Yeshiva
92nd Street Y (6/21-6/21)
Shakespeare In Love in Off-Off-Broadway Shakespeare In Love
Springer Opera House (4/23-5/02)
Shitzprobe! feat. Jason Kravits in Off-Off-Broadway Shitzprobe! feat. Jason Kravits
Asylum NYC (5/18-5/18)