Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Dallas Summer Musicals' THE KING AND I Casting Causes Controversy

While many in New York are looking forward to the upcoming Broadway revival of THE KING AND I starting rehearsals in the coming week, a controversial decision to cast a Caucasian actor as King Mongkut in Dallas Summer Musicals' forthcoming production is generating the opposite response. As of January 23, The Asian American Performers Action Coalition (AAPAC) wrote an open letter to Dallas Summer Musicals expressing their disgust with the organization's choice to use the practice of yellowface in their production.

Yellowface, or the practice of white actors donning overdone face paint and costumes that serves as a caricatured representation of traditional Asian garb, is a practice that has fallen out of favor and is offensive to both Asians and non-Asians alike. Productions of Gilbert and Sullivan's THE MIKADO, Katy Perry's geisha-inspired performance at the American Music Awards in November 2013, Jonathan Pryce as the Engineer in MISS SAIGON, and productions of Puccini's MADAMA BUTTERFLY all are examples of contested uses of this practice.

Conversely, in recent years, the theatergoing world has seen the Asian-American actor embraced. David Henry Hwang's CHINGLISH, the Off-Broadway hit HERE LIES LOVE, and even Bartlett Sher's casting of the Broadway revival of THE KING AND I have given Asian-American actors and audiences opportunity to achieve, enjoy, and expect improved levels of authenticity in the American theater. Thus, it is no surprise that many find fault with Glenn Casale's casting of a Caucasian actor to play King Mongkut at Dallas Summer Musicals.

As AAPAC points out, at the most base level, "the casting of a white King dramaturgically undermines a story about a clash between Western and Eastern cultures." Yet, the issue runs deeper than that. "Asian impersonation denies Asians our own subjecthood. It situates all the power within a Caucasian-centric world view," states AAPAC in their open letter to Dallas Summer Musicals. "This begs the question, 'Who is your production really intended for?'"

Like many of the American classic musicals, there are already problems that exist in the book. THE KING AND I can and has been taken to task for issues surrounding othering and orientalism. Therefore, this poor casting decision is just another slap in the face to both Asian culture and the theatergoing populace.

"Dallas Summer Musicals touts itself as 'bringing the best of Broadway to the Dallas/Ft. Worth area.' If that is true, then we expect you to take a cue from the standard that is being set on Broadway with the upcoming revival of THE KING AND I directed by Bartlett Sher who has appropriately cast Asian actors in all of the Asian roles," says AAPAC. Personally, I don't feel that that's too much to ask for.

To read the full open letter by AAPAC, please click here. AAPAC also asks that if you agree with their open letter that you re-post it to your own social media sites; share your own public missive on Dallas Summer Musicals' Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/DallasSummerMusicals; take a moment to reach out to the President of Dallas Summer Musicals, Michael Jenkins, at mjenkins@dallassummermusicals.org; and/or to forward their message to any friends and colleagues in the Dallas/Fort Worth area who might have a vested interest.

Tell us what you think in the comments below!



Related Stories

From This Author - David Clarke

David Clarke has had a lifelong love and passion for the performing arts, and has been writing about theatre both locally and nationally for years. He joined BroadwayWorld.com running their Houston... (read more about this author)


Album Review: A STRANGE LOOP (Original Broadway Cast Recording) is Poignant and Entertaining
July 8, 2022

A STRANGE LOOP is a refreshing Black, queer fantasia on the artistry of creating modern musical theater. It’s similar to [TITLE OF SHOW], but with more to say.

BWW Album Review: SONDHEIM UNPLUGGED: THE NYC SESSIONS - VOLUME TWO is Glorious
May 6, 2022

Released on what would have been Stephen Sondheim's 92nd birthday - March 22, 2022 - Yellow Sound Label’s SONDHEIM UNPLUGGED: THE NYC SESSIONS - VOLUME TWO is the glorious middle chapter of an epic trilogy of beloved Sondheim showtunes sung by musical theater luminaries. Like the previous entry, this collection is chock full of talented artists skillfully performing hits from Sondheim’s complex yet accessible catalog with glorious dexterity.

BWW Album Review: ASSASSINS (The 2022 Off-Broadway Cast Recording) is Pistol-Smart and Deeply Satisfying
April 12, 2022

Earlier this spring, Broadway Records released ASSASSINS (The 2022 Off-Broadway Cast Recording), giving fans of Stephen Sondheim our third English language commercially released recording of this brilliant score. Closed early because of Omicron, Broadway Records preserved this cast's wonderfully nuanced performances.

BWW Album Review: BETTY BUCKLEY SINGS STEPHEN SONDHEIM Sparkles With Grace and Heart
March 24, 2022

Marking the passing of legendary composer and lyricist Stephen Sondheim and just ahead of the anniversary of his birth, Tony Award winner Betty Buckley released BETTY BUCKLEY SINGS STEPHEN SONDHEIM. Each rendition from Sondheim’s catalog sparkles with Buckley’s grace and heart, making the album a beautiful love letter to one of musical theater’s greatest artists.

BWW Album Review: FLYING OVER SUNSET (Original Broadway Cast Recording) Shimmers Beautifully But Leaves Us Grounded
March 4, 2022

FLYING OVER SUNSET had the kind of pedigree that made it a must-see show. Yet, many of us missed it. Masterworks Broadway offers theatre lovers a window into the production with FLYING OVER SUNSET (Original Broadway Cast Recording). Despite its beauty, the album exposes why the show shuttered so quickly.