Review - All's Well That Ends Well: He's Just Not That Into You

While Shakespeare's canon includes many couples whose relationships are of questionable health - Kate and Petruchio, Beatrice and Benedick, Mr. and Mrs. Scottish - few are as discomfortingly mismatched as the lead pair of All's Well That Ends Well.

Helena, a physician's daughter of lowly birth, cures the king of France of an illness and is rewarded by being allowed to marry any high-born gentleman she desires. She chooses her long-time crush, Bertram, who has already made it very clear that he has absolutely no interest in her. In fact, after the king forces him to marry her, Bertram chooses to go off to war rather than live with Helena as husband and wife, sending her a letter laying down two seemingly impossible conditions under which he would agree to return to France and be with her. Helena's plot to satisfy those conditions includes committing a rape. And when Bertram is caught having committed a dishonorable act, he places the blame on another.

While director Daniel Sullivan's elegant and witty production doesn't exactly leave you pulling for those two crazy kids to get together and live happily ever after, neither come off as fully reprehensible either. Annie Parisse's Helena is of the Smart Women/Foolish Choices variety, possessing attractive intelligence and cleverness but inexplicably throwing herself at a man who doesn't want her. Parisse smoothly takes the character from being a lovesick girl to a confident woman who grows with inner strength as she destroys every barrier placed before her; an admirable quality if her cause wasn't so questionable and her method not so vile.

Unfortunately, there are no apparent clues to the reasons for Helena's persistency in Andre Holland's rather bland Bertram. Granted, the role lacks the juice of Helena, but while the character is described as a young ladies man and a heroic warrior, none of that is evident in Holland's performance, which comes off more as a nice young man who has yet to outgrow unkind impulses.

But the supporting company is anything but bland. It's such a pleasure to hear the versatile tones of John Cullum speaking Shakespeare's words and as the French king he balances chipper humor with brash forcefulness. Tonya Pinkins is warm and regal as Bertram's mother, who sides with Helena, and Reg Rogers, whose outlandishly broad comic antics have lit up Broadway stages in The Royal Family and A Free Man of Color, gives another hilarious turn as Parolles, making the braggart warrior with a yellow streak down his back a sneering, foppish wise-cracker. Katz's may have the best corned beef in town but Reg Rogers always serves up the tastiest ham.

Sullivan smartly sets the piece during the First World War, a time when class distinctions were crumbling and women were claiming more control over their lives. Scott Pask's set is dominated by a lovely ornamental arcade and Jane Greenwood's costumes show traditional Edwardian styles giving way to hints of what's to come in the roaring 20s. Tom Kitt's piano and string music lightly embraces the text. This may not be one of Shakespeare's strongest plays but Sullivan and company do quite Well by it.

Photos by Joan Marcus: Top: John Cullum and Annie Parisse; Bottom: Andre Holland and Reg Rogers.

Click here to follow Michael Dale on Twitter.

From Jerry Herman's Parade to Martin Charnin's No Frills Revue to nights with Betty Comden, Adolph Green and The Revuers, the original song and sketch revue has been a favorite of downtown audiences for nearly a century. With The Greenwich Village Follies, a new show that takes its name from a legendary production from the 1920s, composer/lyricist Doug Silver and bookwriter/lyricist Andrew Frank not only capture the smart, freestyle irreverence that made downtown revues so popular, but they use the format to offer an eighty-minute lesson on the history of America's first haven for artists, free-thinkers and non-conformists.

The extremely tiny space at Manhattan Theatre Source is a square room with three rows of seats on two sides, allowing for maximum intimacy and minimal design flourishes. A makeshift banner that appears to be recycled from the Sullivan Street production of The Fantasticks and some minor costume pieces and wigs are the only design elements. Pianist Michael Harren and drummer Spencer Cohen (alternating with Bryan Bisordi) are tucked away in a corner and director John-Andrew Morrison doesn't have much playing space to maneuver his cast of four around, so the emphasis is squarely on the material, which, fortunately, is clever, tuneful and a lot of fun.

Eight actors alternate performances, and the evening's quartet when I attended consisted of Morrison himself, along with Meghann Dreyfus, Patti Goettlicher and Guy Olivieri; each possessing fine musical theatre voices and displaying the kind of energetic, youthful wackiness that makes this kind of show work.

Beginning from the days when the Lenape Indians called the area "Sapokanican" (meaning "wild tobacco"), Silver and Frank manage to find music in some of the most unlikely scenarios. The spirited march, "Resist The Grid," recalls how Village residents of 1811 protested the city's plan to destroy existing streets and replace them with numbered streets and avenues. "Splatter Me All Over" is a sexy vamp that has Dreyfus, dressed as a blank canvass, hitting vocal and org*smic climaxes as she temps Olivieri's Jackson Pollack to have his way with her. The whispered offers of drug pushers ("Smoke, smoke." "Y'need any?") are presented as rhythmic scoring to an evening in Washington Square Park.

In more sobering moments, Morrison sings "The Eleven of Us," a beautifully simple request for freedom by one of the slaves brought to New Amsterdam by the Dutch West India Company, with touching sincerity and Goettlicher and Dreyfus are very effective as stunned witnesses to the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire. Goettlicher is also very funny in a song that chronicles the rise and fall of an eager young woman's career studying at NYU, a number that cabaret singers should be fighting over any day now.

The Beat Poets, Edna St. Vincent Millay, Peter Stuyvesant and the drag queens who led the Stonewall Rebellion are also featured, and the evening concludes with a warm tribute to all the unsung artists whose names will never be famous, but whose drive and creativity is what keeps the spirit of Greenwich Village alive.

If I have one quibble with the authors, it's that their brief section on the creation of Off-Off Broadway makes no mention of Joe Cino's Caffe Cino, regarded as the birthplace of Off-Off Broadway and Gay Theatre. But hey, there's nothing like a free souvenir condom to settle any differences.

Photos by Peter James Zielinski: Top: Meghann Dreyfus, Chris French, Patti Goettlicher and Kevin R. Free; Bottom: Chris French, John-Andrew Morrison, Meghann Dreyfus and Patti Goettlicher.

Click here to follow Michael Dale on Twitter.

To post a comment, you must register and login.