BWW Reviews: Jeff Macauley Singing the Lyrics of Norman Gimbel is a Delightful Dual Discovery at Don't Tell Mama

By: Dec. 24, 2012

Cabaret Review by Stephen Hanks

As the point person for the 2012 New York Cabaret Awards, I was sent in early November the entire list of nominations in the 20 Award categories so they could be vetted for accuracy (to make sure the nominations were in the right category, whether they were actually 2012 shows, etc.). Scanning the list of Male Vocalist nominees I noticed the name Jeff Macauley, who in August staged the first of what would become seven tribute shows to a lyricist named Norman Gimbel. Talk about double obscurity. Although there was something about Gimbel's name that rang a bell and I soon remembered that he was the man who wrote the lyrics (with music by Charles Fox) to Roberta Flack's 1973 Grammy Award-winning "Killing Me Softly With His Song," which folk singer Lori Lieberman has long claimed was inspired by a poem she wrote about Don McLean (one of my musical heroes). But I still didn't know anything about this guy Macauley or why he was an Award nominee.

Now I know. This past Saturday night, I was finally able to catch Macauley's show, It Was Me: The Lyrics of Norman Gimbel, and found it to be one of the most charming cabaret shows--whether from a man or woman--that I saw this year. Macauley doesn't possess a particularly powerful voice or a wide vocal range, but he has a smooth, endearing baritone that can occasionally hit tough tenor notes, and for this show he displayed a knack for offering interesting and humorous biographical anecdotes as if he were a smooth jazz FM deejay. Dapper and Mad Men-esque in a tight black suit and black bow tie, Macauley presented his show sounding like a classic "lounge lizard," but in the best sense of that term.

Norman Gimbel was, as Macauley called him, "a musical Zelig," whose lyrics could range from quirky to romantic, and who could adapt to many musical styles from an Antonio Carlos Jobim bossa nova (Gimbel wrote the English lyrics to Jobim's "The Girl from Ipanema" and to Pablo Beltran Ruiz's "Sway") to a song from a Hollywood film drama (the 1980 Oscar-winning "It Goes Like It Goes" from Norma Rae), to a 1970s pop tune (the Jim Croce hit "I Got a Name"), to a Charles Fox TV theme song ("Wonder Woman"). With superb arrangements from his Musical Director/Pianist Tex Arnold and the jazzy bass of Jon Burr offering sensual support, Macauley not only proved he was up to singing a wide range of song styles, but he articulated the tunes in a way that conveyed the strength of Gimbel's lyrics. He opened with the swinging "Let Go," and from there never held back, following up on a chilly December night with a warm and cuddly medley of Jobim's "Meditation" with Marcos Valle's "Summer Samba." Later, Macauley offered "Ipanema" and an adorable ballad-like version of the 1963 pop hit "I Will Follow Him" from a gay man's point of view, and was wonderfully whispering and wistful on Gimbel's lyrics and Michael Legrand's melodies on a medley of "I Will Wait for You" and "Watch Watch Happens." from the 1964 French musical film The Umbrellas of Cherbourg.

Throughout the set, Macauley engagingly offered enlightening stories about Gimbel's life and personality (he really liked the ladies) and humorous anecdotes about musicals and films the lyricist worked on (including the very short-lived 1961 Broadway show The Conquering Hero and the 1970 black comedy film Where's Poppa). Norman Gimbel is still around and now a robust 85, Macauley revealed before singing his encore, a deliciously lush rendition of "Live for Life" (music by Francis Lai) from the 1966 French film A Man and A Woman. It was the ideal lyric to end another year and a perfectly sublime cabaret show:

Come with me my love and seize the day and live it,
Live it fully live it fast.
Never thinking once about tomorrow,
Till tomorrow's been and gone and past.
We'll pour the wine and fill the cup of joy and drink it,
Drink as if it were the last.
Live, just live for life.

Happy New Year!


BSC IN NYC Gala to Feature Billy Stritch & More at The Green Room 42 Photo
BSC IN NYC Gala to Feature Billy Stritch & More at The Green Room 42

Barrington Stage Company and Mary Ann & Bruno Quinson are celebrating Artistic Director Alan Paul and Managing Director Meredith Lynsey Schade’s inaugural season with the return of BSC IN NYC Gala on Monday, October 30 at The Green Room 42.

Jazz Great Kristen Lee Sergeant Gotham Bound Photo
Jazz Great Kristen Lee Sergeant Gotham Bound

Acclaimed singer/songwriter Kristen Lee Sergeant will return to The Gotham Restaurant to usher in a festive fall.

Julie Biancheri to Present BACHELORETTE DUET: An Afternoon of Musical Chemistry at The Gre Photo
Julie Biancheri to Present BACHELORETTE DUET: An Afternoon of Musical Chemistry at The Green Room 42

Join Julie Biancheri at The Green Room 42 for an afternoon of Bachelorette Duets on October 14. Experience the best stage chemistry as 12 tenors sing her favorite musical duets. Don't miss this unforgettable showmance and see who gets the final rose! Tickets available now.


Ben Cameron's Broadway Sessions returns to The Green Room 42 this week, featuring cast members from the hit revival of Sweeney Todd! Don't miss this exciting evening of performances and Broadway fun.

From This Author - Stephen Hanks

During four decades as an award-winning magazine publisher/editor/writer for a variety of national magazines and websites, Stephen Hanks has written about sports, health and nutrition, parenting, poli... Stephen Hanks">(read more about this author)



Recommended For You