Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: LILLY AND THE PIRATES THE MUSICAL at Orlando Family Stage

This production runs through March 15th.

By:
Review: LILLY AND THE PIRATES THE MUSICAL at Orlando Family Stage

Yo ho ho! Ahoy mateys!  X marks the spot on this musical based on the 2013 novel by Phyllis Root. Lilly and the Pirates is about a 10 year old girl (Lilly) who has a lot of worries.  When her eccentric scientist parents send her to live with a relative while they are in search of an exotic form of fruit fly, she has to overcome her anxieties in the face of adversity.  

The show was really cute. It was adapted for the stage by John Maclay with music by Brett Ryback (who also served as the show’s music director).  There was one song early in the show about books and there were lots of references to authors and famous literature; I appreciated the references as an English teacher.   Most of the references went over the heads of most of the audience, as it was primarily composed of children (and their parents) but could be appreciated by both demographics.   It featured a small cast (7 actors) and had a run time of about an hour.  The cast is as follows: Kesley Kline (Ensemble/Swing), Radamés Medina Meléndez, (Dad/Redheart/Ensemble), Katie Michaels (Mrs. Teagarden/Ensemble), Juliette Naranjo (Lilly), Zoey Natal (Lilly Alternate); Nathan Olmeda (Ensemble/Swing), Jessica Stone (Mom/Millicent Murray/Ensemble), and Chase Williams (Uncle Earnest/William Barnacle/Ensemble).  From a technical standpoint, the show utilized some clever (but simple) techniques.  In the opening sequence, there was some choreography but it was in shadow.  A water effect was created by using a sheet, some lighting effects and two of the cast members moving it and in pure pirate fashion, there were a few birds (a parrot and some seagulls) that were worked in via puppetry.  

This story has themes relevant to today’s generation such as overcoming anxiety, understanding that you are stronger than you think, and of course, my personal favorite, the importance of books.  

Lilly and the Pirates is a delight for young audiences, especially fans of the book.  I don’t think I was the target audience for this show, but did find it entertaining.  I am also a theater director and would consider putting it on if the right opportunity presented itself.  Lilly and the Pirates is playing at Orlando Family Stage now through March 15.  Don’t miss it or you’ll be forced to walk the plank!  


 

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Orlando Family Stage
Upcoming Shows
The Best Halloween Ever
The Best Halloween Ever
10/10 - 11/1/2026
Brundibár / Vedem
12/12 - 12/13/2026
Recent Articles
Interview: Jeff Revels On 20 Years as Artistic Director and 30 Years at Orlando Family Stage
Interview: Jeff Revels On 20 Years as Artistic Director and 30 Years at Orlando Family Stage
10/7/2026
Special Offer: The Best Halloween Ever Makes Its World Premiere in Orlando
Special Offer: The Best Halloween Ever Makes Its World Premiere in Orlando
10/5/2026

Reader Reviews


Local Shows
REDRUM The Unauthorized Parody Musical of The Shining in Orlando REDRUM The Unauthorized Parody Musical of The Shining
Dr. Phillips Center (10/22-11/01)
The Best Halloween Ever in Orlando The Best Halloween Ever
Orlando Family Stage (10/10-11/01)
Feltman: World's First Hot Dog in Orlando Feltman: World's First Hot Dog
Orlando Family Stage - Black Box Theater (10/23-10/23)
Written in Blood: A Jack the Ripper Tale in Orlando Written in Blood: A Jack the Ripper Tale
Highlander Auditorium (10/22-10/25) PHOTOS
Fiddler on the Roof in Orlando Fiddler on the Roof
Ormond Beach Performing Arts Center (11/06-11/15)
Clue in Orlando Clue
Riverside Theatre (1/06-1/31)
Hairspray in Orlando Hairspray
Riverside Theatre (4/15-5/09)
A Texas Carol in Orlando A Texas Carol
Daytona Playhouse (12/11-12/20)
Ted Swindley’s Honky Tonk Angels in Orlando Ted Swindley’s Honky Tonk Angels
Athens Theatre (2/26-3/21)
Jekyll and Hyde in Orlando Jekyll and Hyde
Little Theatre New Smyrna Beach (10/08-10/25) PHOTOS

BroadwayWorld TV