tracker
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses

IF WE REALLY WERE WITCHES Will Return to NYC This Month

Performances run October 23rd & 25th.

By: Oct. 09, 2025
IF WE REALLY WERE WITCHES Will Return to NYC This Month  Image

Mildred, Agnes and Suds are real witches who travel through time and space to show injustice a thing or two. They are summoned to Newtown by a forgetful ghost to rescue Obediently Snead and other innocent townsfolk from execution. They come up against the Pricks of Puritanical Piety Guild and Social Club-- a rabid group of witch hunters who use witch prickers (and other "modern science") to test their victims.

Four actors, twelve characters, sixty minutes. What could go wrong? Join us as we take back the power.

If We Really Were Witches is flying into Under St. Marks as part of the FRIGID New York & Something From Abroad's Days of The Dead Festival after returning from two sold-out performances in The Scranton Fringe!

Written & Directed by Kelly F. Burr
Produced by Scene 24 Productions
Marketing/PR: Kelly Moran
Assistant Director: Eleanor O'Meara
Stage Manager: Siobhan Petersen

Starring: Siena D'Addario (Mildred/Richard/Obediently), Jaida Foreman (Agnes/Willy/Charity), Timothy Beaton (Suds/John Thomas/Humility) & Maddie Nguyen (Ghost Janet/Peter/Modesty).




Need more Off-Off-Broadway Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Fall season, discounts & more...


Videos