Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre

Take an inside look at opening night with these pictures!

Long Island's largest year-round professional theatrical venue, The Argyle Theatre, will present the Broadway hit Mamma Mia! written by Catherine Johnson with music and lyrics by Benny Andersson and Bjorn Ulvaeus and directed and choreographed by Antoinette DiPietropolo with musical direction by Jonathan Brenner. Mamma Mia! begins performances on March 17 in advance of its opening night on March 19 running through May 1, 2022. The Argyle Theatre (34 West Main Street, Babylon, Long Island).

ABBA's hits tell the hilarious story of a young woman's search for her birth father. This sunny and funny tale unfolds on a Greek island paradise. On the eve of her wedding, a daughter's quest to discover the identity of her father brings three men from her mother's past back to the island they last visited 20 years ago. The story-telling magic of ABBA's timeless songs propels this enchanting tale of love, laughter, and friendship, creating an unforgettable show. And a trip down the aisle you'll never forget!

"The phenomenon that is Mamma Mia comes to Babylon and The Argyle Theatre. Come dance, sing and rock out with this wonderfully infectious cast who are having the time of their lives. We've waited a long time to bring this joyous show to our stage and this is the perfect time for our audiences to celebrate." Argyle Theatre's Artistic Director, Evan Pappas.

The cast Julie Cardia (Broadway: Les Miserables) as Donna, Gina Milo (Broadway: Les Miserables) as Tanya, Jaelle Laguerre (Regional: A Christmas Carol) as Rosie, Benjamin Eakeley (Broadway: She Loves Me) as Sam, James Donegan (New York: Forbidden Broadway) as Harry Bright, Mark Woodard (Regional: 42nd Street) as Bill, Anna Catherine Smith (Regional: Beauty and the Beast) as Sophie Sheridan, Aidan Cole (Regional: Legally Blonde) as Sky, Matthew Rafanelli (Argyle's The Little Mermaid) as Eddie, Kuppi Alec Jessop (Regional: Footloose) as Pepper, Courtney Fekete (Argyle's Legally Blonde) as Lisa, Trinity Mikel as Ali, with Sergio Dijiani (International: The Phantom of the Opera), Logan Dolence (Regional: What a Wonderful World), Melissa Goldberg (Regional: Newsies. Argyle's Elf), Ashley Gale Munzek (Metropolitan Opera:Turando), Livvie Hirshfield, Kwasi Perry (Asian Tour: Dreamgirls), Nikki Rinaudo-Concessi (Argyle's Cabaret), and Bryce Colby Vaewsorn (National Tour: Escape to Margaritaville)

The creative team includes Set Design by Tim Golebiewski, Lighting Design by John Burkland, Costume Design by Matthew Solomon, Sound Design by Carlos Dias, Jr., Prop Design by Courtney Alberto, Music Coordinator is Russell Brown, Associate Costume Designer is Amy Pinto. The Production Stage Manager is Daniel Schultz with Assistant Stage Manager Kenneth Kyle Martinez. Covid Safety Managers are Dana Aveta, Callie Hester, Emily Todt. The Production Coordinator is Alison Savino. The Casting Director is Michael Cassara, CSA.

NOW ON SALE, tickets for Mamma Mia! priced from $45 - $79 and may be purchased online at www.argyletheatre.com or by calling (631) 230-3500.

Mamma Mia! will play Thursday through Saturday evenings at 7:30 PM, Saturday afternoons at 2:30 PM, and Sunday afternoons at 2:00 PM (added performance on Wednesday, April 27 at 7:30 PM).

Take a look at the photos from opening night below!

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre


Trinity Mikel and Courtney Fekete

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Kuppi Alec Jessop and Matthew Rafanelli

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
James Donegan

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jaelle Ashley Laguerre and Mark Woodard

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Benjamin Eakeley

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Julie Cardia

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
James Donegan, Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Benjamin Eakeley, Mark Woodard and Julie Cardia

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
The Cast of Mamma Mia!

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Anna Catherine Smith and The Cast of Mamma Mia!

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Aidan Cole and Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Gina Milo, Julie Cardia and Jaelle Ashley Laguerre

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Gina Milo, Julie Cardia and Jaelle Laguerre

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Gina Milo, Julie Cardia and Jaelle Ashley Laguerre

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Gina Milo, James Donegan, Julie Cardia, Benjamin Eakeley, and Mark Woodard

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Julie Cardia and Benjamin Eakeley

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Julie Cardia, Benjamin Eakeley and Jaelle Laguerre

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Gina Milo, James Donegan, Julie Cardia, Benjamin Eakeley, Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Mark Woodard, Aidan Cole and Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Julie Cardia and Benjamin Eakeley

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
James Donegan, Benjamin Eakeley and Evan Pappas (Artistic Director)

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Kuppi Alec Jessop

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
James Donegan

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Benjamin Eakeley

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Mark Woodard, Benjamin Eakeley and James Donegan

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Mark Woodard,Julie Cardia, Benjamin Eakeley and James Donegan

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Mark Woodard, Julie Cardia, Benjamin Eakeley, Gina Milo and James Donegan

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Mark Woodard, Julie Cardia, Benjamin Eakeley,Antoinette DiPietropolo (Director/Choreographer) Gina Milo and James Donegan

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Logan Dolence, Mattew Rafanelli, Courtney Fekete, Sergio Dijiani, Ashley Gale Munzek, Kuppi Alec Jessop, Melissa Goldberg, Nikki Rinaudo-Concessi, Bryce Colby Vaewsorn, Kwasi Perry, Antoinette DiPietropolo, Livvie Hirshfield and Trinity Mikel

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Evan Pappas, Antoinette DiPietropolo, Ashley Gale Munzek and Jonathan Brenner (Music Director)

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Antoinette DiPietropolo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Bryce Colby Vaewsorn

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Matthew Rafanelli

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Courtney Fekete

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Aidan Cole and Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Aidan Cole

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Sergio Dijiani

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Kwasi Perry

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Ashley Gale Munzek

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre Jaelle Jaelle Ashley Laguerre

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Mark Woodard

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Julie Cardia

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jonathan Brenner

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Julie Cardia and Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Julie Cardia and Anna Catherine Smith

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Julie Cardia and Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Julie Cardia and Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
JJaelle Ashley Laguerre , Julie Cardia, Anna Catherine Smith and Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Julie Cardia, Antoinette DiPietropolo, Anna Catherine Smith and Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Julie Cardia, Antoinette DiPietropolo, Anna Catherine Smith and Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Antoinette DiPietropolo, Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Julie Cardia, Anna Catherine Smith, Gina Milo and Evan Pappas

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Antoinette DiPietropolo and Jonathan Brenner

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Marty Rubin, Dylan Perlman, Michael Cassara, Antoinette DiPietropolo, Evan Pappas and Mark Perlman

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Evan Pappas and Gina Milo

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Evan Pappas and Julie Cardia

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Evan Pappas and Scott Willis

Photos: MAMMA MIA! Opens at The Argyle Theatre
Cast and Creative Team of Mamma Mia that includes- Nikki Rinaudo-Concessi, Courtney Fekete, James Donegan, Aidan Cole, Kwasi Perry, Kuppi Alec Jessop, Sergio Dijiani, Antoinette DiPietropolo, Trinity Mikel, Melissa Goldber, Livvie Hirshfield, Logan Dolence, Anna Catherine Smith, Julie Cardia, Jaelle Ashley Laguerre , Jonathan Brenner, Ashley Gale Munzek, Matthew Rafanelli, Gina Milo and Bryce Colby Vaewsorn



East End Special Players to Present TURTLES ON THE TARMAC! in April Photo
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts has announced the return of The East End Special Players to the Bay Street stage. Following a two year hiatus, the Players are appearing in a premiere benefit performance of their new play Turtles on the Tarmac on Saturday, April 29, at 4 p.m. at Bay Street Theater. The event begins Saturday, April 29, with a reception and silent auction starting at 3 p.m.

The John W. Engeman Theater at Northport Presents SEUSSICAL THE MUSICAL Photo
The John W. Engeman Theater announces the cast and creative team for SEUSSICAL THE MUSICAL TYA. Performances will begin on Saturday, April 1, 2023, and will run through Sunday, April 30, 2023.

Review: THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT at Hampton Theatre Company Photo
What did our critic think of THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT at Hampton Theatre Company?

SEUSSICAL THE MUSICAL TYA to Play The John W. Engeman Theater in April Photo
The John W. Engeman Theater announced the cast and creative team for SEUSSICAL THE MUSICAL TYA. Performances will begin on Saturday, April 1, 2023, and will run through Sunday, April 30, 2023.


From This Author - Genevieve Rafter Keddy


Photos: TV WESTFEST Takes Place in TucsonPhotos: TV WESTFEST Takes Place in Tucson
March 27, 2023

It was Willie Nelson who first said 'My heroes have always been cowboys.' If your heroes have always been television cowboys then TV WESTFEST held from Thursday, March 16th, thru Sunday March 19th, in Tucson, AZ was all that you would want.

Photos: Go Inside THE MARVELOUS MARILYN MAYE with the New York Pops at Carnegie HallPhotos: Go Inside THE MARVELOUS MARILYN MAYE with the New York Pops at Carnegie Hall
March 25, 2023

Cabaret legend and Grammy nominee Marilyn Maye appeared with The New York Pops, led by Music Director and Conductor Steven Reineke, to celebrate a very special birthday on Friday, March 24, 2023 at 8:00 p.m. in Stern Auditorium / Perelman Stage at Carnegie Hall. Check out photos from the concert here!

Photos: DOG MAN: THE MUSICAL Celebrates Opening Night At New World StagesPhotos: DOG MAN: THE MUSICAL Celebrates Opening Night At New World Stages
March 14, 2023

See photos from opening night of Dog Man: The Musical at New World Stages!

Photos: The Drama League Announces The Irene Gandy Stage Directing AssistantshipsPhotos: The Drama League Announces The Irene Gandy Stage Directing Assistantships
March 7, 2023

The Drama League’s Bonnie Comley, Gabriel Stelian-Shanks, and Bevin Ross announced the campaign to rename The Drama League Stage Directing Assistantships program to The Irene Gandy Directing Assistantships. Check out photos from the event here!

Photos: Go Inside WEST SIDE STORY Opening Night at The Argyle TheatrePhotos: Go Inside WEST SIDE STORY Opening Night at The Argyle Theatre
February 12, 2023

The Argyle Theatre's production of West Side Story, directed by Evan Pappas and Todd Underwood, choreographed by Todd Underwood, with musical direction by Christopher D. Littlefield opened last night, Saturday, February 11, 2023, and BroadwayWorld was there for the festivities. The production runs through April 2nd. Check out photos from the evening here!