Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

American Repertory Theater of WNY Presents SOMETHING WICKED

By:

American Repertory Theater of WNY Presents SOMETHING WICKED ImageThe American Repertory Theater of WNY will be co-producing with Navigation Theatre Company's in presenting the second showcasing of Western New York playwrights featuring the original work SOMETHING WICKED by James A Marzo. This deliciously fiendish story of the murderous plotting of three brothers and the botched cover-up will be presented at the Compass Performing Arts Center, 545 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo NY.

Show-dates are April 16th through May 9th, Thursday through Saturday with showtimes 8 pm, Thursday and Friday and 5 pm, Saturday. Tickets are $20 General Admission. $15 Student and Arts Industry. For information contact 716-697-0837.

The year 1825 was a momentous one for Buffalo, New York. The Erie Canal opened, connecting Lake Erie to the Hudson River, a celebration honoring the Marquis de Lafayette, hero of the American Revolution was held in Buffalo, and the city held its first and only public hanging. At least 20,000 witnesses gathered in Niagara Square to watch thee brothers-Nelson, Israel, and Isaac Thayer-hang from the same gallows. This is the basis of James Marzo's SOMETHING WICKED. Through his weaving of tight dialogue and dark humor, Marzo crafts a loose history of this macabre story how the Thayer brothers hatched a nefarious plan to murder money lender John Love in a desperate move to eliminate debt and avoid prison.

Marzo intertwined period music into his work employing the music talents of Buffalo musician, and Americana folk music researcher, Tylor Bagwell to help tell this story. With Bagwell, Marzo penned an original, "Sadie's Song", that brings the play's narrating character 'Sadie' (portrayed by Suzanne Hibbard) and Israel (portrayed by Justin Pope) together in an emotional "what could have been". Bagwell also incorporated the traditional "Low Bridge, Everyone Down" as an effective historical reference. "Combined with the music, I believe we made this piece totally unique." Said Marzo on the music and narrative ties. "If you don't have emotion in theater, you really don't have much at all, unless you are writing an all out farce, or comedy".

Along with Suzanne Hibbard and Justin Pope, Navigation Theatre Company alumni Timothy Coseglia ("Kindness of Strangers" joins Joshua Leary as the other two Thayer brothers. Additional cast members feature ART/WNY alumnus John F Kennedy, as 'Sheriff Torrey' and Patrick Caughill (portraying 'Deputy Willard') with Dylan Brozyna as the unfortunate character of 'John Love'. Navigation Theatre Company (Kindness of Strangers) and ART/WNY alumni Matthew LaChiusa directs SOMETHING WICKED.

SOMETHING WICKED opens on April 16th and runs to May 9th.

Ticket prices are $20 General Admission and $15 for Students and Industry. Online tickets can be purchased by visiting Brown Paper Ticket at https://m.bpt.me/profile/16599 or to make reservations contact 716-0837 Mon-Fri 9 am to 3 pm and Saturday 10 am to 4 pm. For more please go to www.compassperformingartscenter.com.





Don't Miss a Buffalo News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Churchill Starring Daniel Payne in Buffalo Churchill Starring Daniel Payne
Shea's Smith Theatre (11/05-11/08)
'Equus' by Peter Shaffer in Buffalo 'Equus' by Peter Shaffer
Reid Castle Events (7/30-8/02)
Girl On An Altar in Buffalo Girl On An Altar
Irish Classical Theatre Company (6/12-6/28)
Neglia Ballet Summer Gala in Buffalo Neglia Ballet Summer Gala
Nichols Flickinger Performing Arts Center (6/27-6/27)
Rent in Buffalo Rent
Shea's Smith Theatre (1/29-2/14)
The Golden Girls - The Lost Episodes Viii in Buffalo The Golden Girls - The Lost Episodes Viii
Shea's Smith Theatre (8/14-8/30)
NYSCA-Funded Performance in Buffalo: Bridging Acts (July 25, 2026) | 6:30-7:45pm in Buffalo NYSCA-Funded Performance in Buffalo: Bridging Acts (July 25, 2026) | 6:30-7:45pm
Center for the Arts - University at Buffalo (7/25-7/25)
Tony N'' Tina''s Wedding in Buffalo Tony N'' Tina''s Wedding
Shea's Smith Theatre (3/05-3/21)
The Lion King in Buffalo The Lion King
Auditorium Theatre (4/28-5/16)
Sister''s Christmas Catechism: The Mystery of the Magi''s Gold in Buffalo Sister''s Christmas Catechism: The Mystery of the Magi''s Gold
Shea's Smith Theatre (12/23-12/23)