Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

BWW Exclusive: Celebrate National Cookie Day with This Top Secret Recipe from Schmackary's!

December 4 marks National Cookie Day-- what better way than to celebrate with a recipe from Broadway's favorite cookie shop?

It's National Cookie Day and our friends at Schmackary's are sharing a top secret recipe for their Chocolate Explosion cookies with Chocolate Frosting-- yum!

Schmackary's is well-known around the Broadway community for being "the official cookie of Broadway," teaming up with stars of the stage for the annual Broadway Bakes events to help support BCEFA.

Want even more cookies this holiday season? Check out Schmackary's holiday care packages, from 1/2 dozen or 1 dozen cookies with a signature Schmackary's mug and more, available to ship nationwide!

Be sure to check out their seasonal flavors too, including Dirty Peppermint, Mexican Hot Chocolate, and Eggnog.

Now, let's get to baking!

Chocolate Explosion Cookies


2 cups All-Purpose Flour
¼ cup Dutch Process Cocoa
½ teaspoon Baking Soda
½ teaspoon Baking Powder
¼ teaspoon Salt
½ pound (2 sticks) Unsalted Butter, softened
1 cup Brown Sugar
½ cup Sugar + ½ cup sugar for rolling
¾ teaspoon Dark Corn Syrup
2 Eggs
½ tablespoon Vanilla Extract
1 ½ cups Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunks or Chips

Tips for Smashing Cookies

"Smashing" cookies is flattening the cookie out halfway through the baking process. This helps the cookie keep its round shape.

Cookies should be smashed when it's easy to do so. If the cookie does not have an even top surface after smashing, smash again in a few minutes.

Always smash with a large flat spatula and remember to use your oven mitts!

Tips for Rolling Cookies

When you roll cookies in sugar, it gives them a crunchy outer texture.

To roll cookies, scoop cookies into balls and fill a bowl with sugar. Drop each cookie into the bowl and coat evenly with sugar.

To avoid sticking, dip your hands in tap water before handling the scooped cookies. This also helps the sugar stick to the dough.

Step-By-Step Instructions

1. Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Line two large baking sheets with parchment paper or
spray with non-stick cooking spray. Set aside.
2. In a medium-sized bowl, combine flour, cocoa, baking soda, baking powder, and salt.
3. In a separate large bowl, beat softened butter, ½ cup of sugar, and the brown sugar until light and well mixed. Scrape down your bowl often to avoid uneven mixing.
4. Add corn syrup, vanilla extract, and eggs (one at a time) to the creamed mixture. Beat until combined.
5. Add dry ingredients to the sugar mixture gradually until just combined. Do not over-mix.
6. Fold chocolate chunks into the cookie dough. Chill dough until firm
7. Scoop cookies into desired size and roll in additional ½ cup of sugar.
8. Bake cookies at 375 until the cookies are no longer shiny and begin to crack on top (15-18 minutes). Halfway through baking, rotate pans in the oven and "smash" the cookies with a large flat metal spatula.
9. Cool cookies on the baking sheet for about three minutes. Then, transfer to a wire rack to cool to room temperature.
10. Frost cookies once cool!

Chocolate Frosting


8 Tbsp (1 stick) Unsalted Butter, softened
½ lb Cream Cheese, cold
4 Cups 10x Confectioners sugar
¾ Cup Dutch Process Cocoa
1 ½ teaspoons Vanilla Extract
A pinch of salt

Step-by-step Instructions

1. With a wire whisk attachment, add butter, cocoa powder and confectioners sugar to
bowl. Mix slowly until combined, then beat on medium speed until smooth.
2. Add cream cheese and vanilla and continue beating until well-whipped and smooth.
3. Sides of bowl may need to be scraped a few times to ensure frosting is evenly mixed.
4. If frosting is a bit runny, place in the refrigerator for 15-30 minutes until it firms up a bit. Frosting should not be hard, but easy to spread with a frosting spatula.
5. Using an offset spatula, spread frosting over cookies.

Thanks again to our friends at Schmackary's for sharing! Happy baking!

TodayTix Black Friday

Related Stories
Russian Troops Attack Ukraines Theaters, Libraries & More Photo
Russian troops in Ukraine are attacking the country’s theaters, museums, libraries and other cultural institutions to erase Ukrainian culture, according to a report issued by the U.S. and Ukrainian chapters of the international writers’ organization PEN.

Interview: Amanda Kloots on Returning to Acting In FIT FOR CHRISTMAS Photo
Amanda Kloots stars in Fit For Christmas, the new CBS original holiday film, which she also co-created and executive produces. BroadwayWorld caught up with Kloots to discuss how the tragic loss of her husband, Nick Cordero, inspired her to create the film, why fitness should be a part of the holiday season, and if she would ever return to Broadway.

VIDEO: Idina Menzel Reveals How RENT Inspired Her New Documentary Photo
Idina Menzel appeared on CBS Mornings to promote her new documentary, Idina Menzel: Which Way to the Stage? Menzel described what inspired her document the experience of playing at Madison Square Garden, calling back to a lesson she learned while starring in Rent. Watch the new video interview now!

PLAYS FOR THE PLAGUE YEAR to Return to The Public in 2023 Photo
After a truncated run as a result of several COVID-19 cases in the company, Suzan-Lori Parks’ theatrical concert PLAYS FOR THE PLAGUE YEAR will be returning for an engagement in The Public Theater's Joe’s Pub in April 2023.

From This Author - Taylor Brethauer-Hamling

Taylor Brethauer-Hamling is a Maryland native with a writing, design, video production, and social media background. She graduated from Manhattan College in May of 2019, receiving a Bachelor's ... (read more about this author)

RENT's Tommy Kaiser Takes Over Our Instagram Today!RENT's Tommy Kaiser Takes Over Our Instagram Today!
March 6, 2022

Tommy Kaiser, college winner of Next on Stage season two and current swing/Mark and Roger understudy, is taking over our Instagram story today, March 6! Don't miss his behind the scenes look at the tour's two show day in Philadelphia.

Student Blogs This Week - Audition Day Experiences, Study Break Tips, and MoreStudent Blogs This Week - Audition Day Experiences, Study Break Tips, and More
March 4, 2022

Our student bloggers write about how they're coping with the current global health crisis, give insight on their school's performing arts programs, share their opinions on the latest theater news, and so much more. Finding the joy in rejection, favorite theatre moments, a letter to college friends, New York Fashion Week, a love of Shakespeare, learning to say no, and more-- read the latest from our college student bloggers!

VIDEO: John Mulaney and the Cast of SNL Parody THE MUSIC MAN, FIDDLER ON THE ROOF, and More in New NYC Musical SketchVIDEO: John Mulaney and the Cast of SNL Parody THE MUSIC MAN, FIDDLER ON THE ROOF, and More in New NYC Musical Sketch
February 27, 2022

John Mulaney returned to Saturday Night Live on February 26 to host for a fifth time and brought back his recurring New York City musical sketch, this time about the New York City subway. Mulaney and the cast of the show performed parodies of South Pacific, Fiddler on the Roof, Little Shop of Horrors, The Music Man, Singin' in the Rain, Dream Girls, Les Miserables, and Jesus Christ Superstar.

VIDEO: Beanie Feldstein and Ramin Karimloo Talk FUNNY GIRL RehearsalsVIDEO: Beanie Feldstein and Ramin Karimloo Talk FUNNY GIRL Rehearsals
February 25, 2022

Funny Girl is about to make its return to Broadway! The first-ever revival of the musical will have its first preview at the August Wilson on March 26 and officially open on April 24. The show's stars Beanie Feldstein (Fanny Brice) and Ramin Karimloo (Nick Arnstein) sat down together to talk about their favorite moments from the show's rehearsal process.

SIX's Andrea Macasaet Takes Over Our Instagram Today!SIX's Andrea Macasaet Takes Over Our Instagram Today!
February 24, 2022

Don't lose your head-- Andrea Macasaet is taking over our Instagram story today, February 24! She'll be giving our followers a behind-the-scenes look at the Broadway production of Six and you don't want to miss it.