Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: Mel Brooks' YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN, THE MUSICAL at Bay Street Theater

What did our critic think of MEL BROOKS' YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN, THE MUSICAL at Bay Street Theater?

By:
Review: Mel Brooks' YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN, THE MUSICAL at Bay Street Theater

Bay Street Theater delivers a dazzling performance of Mel Brooks' Young Frankenstein, The Musical thrillingly closing out their amazing 2024 season. Directed with flair by Gerry McIntyre, this fan-favorite, running through September 1st at the renowned Sag Harbor venue, promises an evening of uproarious entertainment that you won’t want to miss.

At its core, this show is a delightful parody of the horror film genre, crafted by the legendary Mel Brooks, who provides both music and lyrics. The book, co-written with Thomas Meehan, follows the comical misadventures of Dr. Frederick Frankenstein, brought to life with great finesse by Matthew Hydzik. As Frederick grapples with the legacy of his notorious grandfather, Dr. Victor Frankenstein, he embarks on a hilariously fraught attempt to reanimate a corpse. Hydzik’s performances of "The Brain" and "Man About Town" are particularly engaging, drawing enthusiastic applause from the audience.

Hydzik’s chemistry with Kyla Stone, who plays Inga—Frederick’s well-meaning assistant—adds an extra layer of humor to the production. Stone’s rendition of "Roll In The Hay," performed with Hydzik and James Romney, who masterfully embodies Igor, who worked for the elder Frankenstein, is a standout moment filled with laughter and exuberance.

Sean Bell also deserves special mention for his portrayal of The Monster. His performance, which includes an impressive tap dance number in "Puttin' on the Ritz," earned him an extended round of applause. Bell’s physicality and comic timing bring a new dimension to the character, making his scenes truly memorable.

The cast’s talents are further elevated by Tony and Emmy nominee Veanne Cox, who plays Frau Blucher. Cox’s dynamic performance, including her show-stopping number "He Vas My Boyfriend," is a highlight of the evening, showcasing her exceptional comedic skill and charisma.

McIntyre’s creative team has also done an outstanding job. Mike Billings’ set design effectively utilizes the intimate stage with movable pieces that facilitate smooth scene transitions. This seamless flow is beautifully complemented by Billings’ lighting design, which, along with McIntyre’s fun, quirky choreography, enhances the overall visual experience. Kudos also to Barbara Erin Delo for the beautiful costumes and Liz Printz for the amazing makeup & hair design which contribute significantly to the show’s comedic and aesthetic appeal.

And so, Mel Brooks' Young Frankenstein, The Musical is a resounding success for the East End's Bay Street Theater. With its exceptional cast, clever direction, and high-energy performances, it offers a thoroughly enjoyable and entertaining evening.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Bay Street Theater
Upcoming Shows
Dear Evan Hansen
Dear Evan Hansen
8/4 - 8/29/2026
Recent Articles
DEAR EVAN HANSEN Opens at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor
DEAR EVAN HANSEN Opens at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor
8/10/2026
Video: DEAR EVAN HANSEN Runs at Bay Street Theater Through August 29
Video: DEAR EVAN HANSEN Runs at Bay Street Theater Through August 29
8/5/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Long Island News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Come From Away in Long Island Come From Away
The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (8/07-9/06)
Little Shop of Horrors: 40th Anniversary Screening Hosted By Ellen Greene in Long Island Little Shop of Horrors: 40th Anniversary Screening Hosted By Ellen Greene
Patchogue Theatre (8/30-8/30)
THE WEDDING SINGER in Long Island THE WEDDING SINGER
The John W. Engeman Theater (7/09-8/23)
Megan Hilty in Long Island Megan Hilty
Westhampton Beach Performing Arts Center (8/22-8/22)
Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra in Long Island Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra
Staller Center for the Arts (12/05-12/05)
South Shore Theatre Experience present 15th Annual One Act Festival in Long Island South Shore Theatre Experience present 15th Annual One Act Festival
South Shore Theatre (9/04-9/04)
Harry Chapin: I Wanna Learn A Love Song in Long Island Harry Chapin: I Wanna Learn A Love Song
The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (3/12-4/04)
The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show in Long Island The Dinner Detective Murder Mystery Dinner Show
The Dinner Detective Long Island (9/12-9/12)
The Rocky Horror Picture Show Spooktacular Tour with Patricia Quinn in Long Island The Rocky Horror Picture Show Spooktacular Tour with Patricia Quinn
Patchogue Theatre (10/29-10/29)
An Evening with Smith and Mertzlufft in Long Island An Evening with Smith and Mertzlufft
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (5/06-5/06)