My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater!

Opening took place on November 15, 2025 @ Bay Street!

By:

NOVEMBER 15, 2025, SAG HARBOR, NY — Bay Strect Theater's recent opening night of Fahrenheit 45/ lit up the stage with Ray Bradbury's iconic dystopian tale, reimagined in a vivid new production directed by Stephen Hamilton. The show captivated audiences with its gripping portrayal of a world where firemen burn books and independent thought is forbiddenuntil one fireman dares to question the system.

Presented with stunning visuals and emotional intensity, the production transported attendees into Bradbury's chilling universe. The audience watched as the narrative unfolded around themes of censorship, conformity, and couragean ever-timely reminder of the importance of critical thinking and the title's enduring relevance. Bay Street's adaptation showcased not only the power of live theater but also the power of a single individual's imagination to challenge the status quo.

Hamilton's inventive direction, paired with dynamic visual elements and a talented ensemble cast, brought Bradbury's story to life in bold and contemporary ways. The production embraced the novel's tension and beauty while inviting a new generation of theatergoers to reflect on freedom and the value of knowledge. The opening-night crowd responded enthusiastically and was visibly moved by the show's message, underscoring the production's impact long after the curtain fell.

The cast included J. Stephen Brantley, Bonnie Comley, Matthew Conlon, Nicole Marie Hunt, John Kroft, Stewart F. Lane, Daniela Mastropietro, Dan Pavacic, and Anna Francesca Schiavoni. The creative team included Stephen Hamilton (Director), Tracy Mitchell (Executive Director), Scott Schwartz (Artistic Director), Mike Billings (Scenic & Projections Designer), Rick Sordelet (Fight Director), Brian Clemente (Assistant Director), Yuka Silvera (Costume Designer), Garett Pembrook (Lighting Designer), David M. Brandenburg (Sound Designer), Murnane Casting (Additional Casting), Chris Daly (Production Stage Manager), Kat Hansell (Assistant Stage Manager), Alisha Kraus (Wardrobe Supervisor), and Hannah Corbett (Lighting & Technical Supervisor).

Bay Street Theater's Literature Live Sponsors included Alan & Annette Leve Family Foundation (initiated by Elise Leve), Klingenstein-Martell Foundation, Sunny and Abe Rosenberg Foundation, Kenneth L. Grief Foundation, The Neuwirth Foundation, The Bridgehampton Association, Town of Southampton, Stony Brook Southampton Hospital, Susan Dusenberry, Nancy Stearns, Riverhead Building
Supply.

For more information, visit: www.BayStreet.org

Photos by Eugene Gologursky with an additional photo from Phillip Lehans

Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Director Stephen Hamilton (center) with the cast back row: Dan Pavacic & John Kroft; Middle row: Daniela Mastropietro, Stewart F. Lane, J. Stephen Brantley, Nicole Marie Hunt, Matthew Conlon; Front row: Bonnie Comley & Anna Francesca Schiavoni 
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Anna Francesca Schiavoni
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Stewart F.Lane, Bonnie Comley, Jason Amis & Carrie Rebora Barratt
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Bay Street Board of Trustees- Elise Levy, Tracy Mitchell, Lynn Mestel, John Frawley, Stewart F. Lane & Wendy Harrison Hashmall
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Cast of Fahrenheit 451 at Curtain Call
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Brian Clemente, Stephen Hamilton, Tracy Mitchell and the cast of Fahrenheit 451
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Dan Pavacic
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Elise Herget, Christian Scheider, Bonnie Comley, Stewart F. Lane, Shelby Freda & Phillip Lehans
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Lynn Mestel, Tracy Mitchell & Hayes Roth
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Mattia Monti, Paola Balazarotti Monti, Bonnie Comley & Stewart F. Lane
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Nicole Marie Hunt
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Simon Kinsella & David Fink
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Stewart F. Lane, Victoria Schneps & Bonnie Comley
Photos: Opening Night of Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater! Image
Stewart F. Lane & Chris Daly

BroadwayWorld My Shows

Don't Miss a Long Island News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
CAMELOT in Long Island CAMELOT
The John W. Engeman Theater (5/14-6/28)
Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations in Long Island Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations
The Gateway Playhouse (6/19-7/19)
Cagney - The Musical  in Long Island Cagney - The Musical
Bay Street Theater (6/30-7/26)
Urinetown the musical in Long Island Urinetown the musical
South Shore Theatre Experience (7/25-7/25)
Leopoldstadt in Long Island Leopoldstadt
BACCA Arts Center (12/05-1/03)
Urinetown the musical in Long Island Urinetown the musical
South Shore Theatre (7/18-7/18)
Gravity & Other Myths Presents: Ten Thousand Hours in Long Island Gravity & Other Myths Presents: Ten Thousand Hours
Staller Center for the Arts (10/18-10/18)
Melissa Errico: The Streisand Effect | Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor in Long Island Melissa Errico: The Streisand Effect | Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor
Bay Street Theater (8/17-8/17)
Urinetown the musical in Long Island Urinetown the musical
South Shore Theatre (7/19-7/19)
Golden Girls The Laughs Continue in Long Island Golden Girls The Laughs Continue
Patchogue Theatre (10/09-10/09)


Videos