Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport

MYSTIC PIZZA charts the lives and loves of three unforgettable waitresses in the harbor town of Mystic, CT.

The John W. Engeman Theater's production of MYSTIC PIZZA - A New Musical opened on Saturday, September 17th. Performances began on Thursday, September 15, 2022, and runs through Sunday, October 30, 2022.

Check out our photos from the opening below!

Based on the classic 1988 movie starring Julia Roberts, MYSTIC PIZZA charts the lives and loves of three unforgettable waitresses in the harbor town of Mystic, CT. Featuring some of the best pop songs of the '80s and '90s such as "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun," "Addicted To Love," "Small Town," "Hold On," and "Take My Breath Away," MYSTIC PIZZA has all the ingredients for a romantic comedy-with the works!

MYSTIC PIZZA is directed by Igor Goldin (Engeman Theater: Kinky Boots, Rock of Ages, Matilda, Newsies, Gypsy, Oklahoma, 1776; Off-Broadway: YANK!, With Glee, A Ritual of Faith; Regional: Seattle 5th Ave., Goodspeed Musicals, Cape Playhouse, Tuacahn Center for the Arts) and choreographed by Ashley Marinelli (Engeman: West Side Story; Off-Broadway: Stranger Sings!: The Parody Musical, Dorothy Parker: The Musical; Regional: Miller Theater, The Players Club, Ogunquit Playhouse, Tuacahn Center for the Arts).

The Creative Team includes SARAH WUSSOW (Musical Director), Kyle Dixon (Scenic Design), Dustin Cross (Costume Design), JOSE SANTIAGO (Lighting Design), Laura Shubert (Sound Design), Kristie Moschetta (Props Design), WOJCIK CASTING TEAM (Casting Directors), AARON A. WATSON (Production Stage Manager), KAYLA GOLDSBOROUGH (Assistant Stage Manager), TIGER BROWN (Associate Choreographer), JENNIFER COLLESTER (Director of Production) and RICHARD DOLCE (Producing Artistic Director).

The cast of MYSTIC PIZZA features EMILY ROSE LYONS as DAISY (National Tour: Legally Blonde; Regional: Norwegian Cruise Lines, Sierra Repertory Theatre, Royal Caribbean Cruises, Sundance Theatre, Hale Center Theatre), BROOKE STERLING as KAT (Regional: Richard Rodgers Amphitheater, Woodstock Playhouse, The Muny, Manhattan Theatre), Michelle Beth Herman as JOJO (National Tour: Les Miserables; Regional: Peterborough Players, MUNY, Northern Stage, TUTS, Mason Street Warehouse), Kathryn Markey as LEONA (Engeman: Memphis, A Christmas Story; Broadway: 3 From Brooklyn; Regional: InProximity Theatre, Depot Theatre, St. Michael's Playhouse, Alliance Theatre, Bay Street Theatre; TV/Film" "Law and Order," "All My Children"), CORBIN PAYNE as TIM (Off-Broadway: Cleopatra; Regional: Short North Stage, The Denver Center, The Arvada Center, Ignite! Theatre), Stephen Cerf as BILL (Engeman: Fiddler on the Roof; Broadway: Jersey Boys; National Tour: Motown The Musical, Spamalot, Rock Of Ages, Nevermore, That Bachelorette Show; Regional: Papermill Playhouse, Ogunquit Playhouse), and JAKE BENTLEY YOUNG as CHARLIE (Regional: Stages St. Louis, Wagon Wheel Center of the Arts, Lyric Theatre of Oklahoma).

The ensemble includes Carey Blackburn, Coleman Cummings, BRANDON KALLEN, Kent M. Lewis, PARIS MARTINO, MICHAEL MORLEY, ANDRYI NAHIRNIAK, BRANDT NORRIS, HANNAH RECORD, Molly Samson, and ELISE SHANGOLD.

The John W. Engeman Theater at Northport is Long Island's only year-round professional theater company, casting actors from the Broadway talent pool. From curb to curtain, we have made it our business to provide affordable, quality theater in an elegant one-of-a-kind location with outstanding facilities and extraordinary service. The renovated theater offers stadium-style seating, state-of-the-art lighting and sound, a full orchestra pit, and a classic wood-paneled piano lounge with full bar.

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Mystic Pizza Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Emily Rose Lyons and Jake Bentley Young

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kathryn Markey, Michelle Beth Herman, Brooke Sterling and Emily Rose Lyons

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michelle Beth Herman, Brooke Sterling and Emily Rose Lyons

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michelle Beth Herman, Brooke Sterling and Emily Rose Lyons

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kathryn Markey

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kathryn Markey, Stephen Cerf, Michelle Beth Herman, Brooke Sterling, Emily Rose Lyons, Jake Bentley Young and Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michelle Beth Herman, Brooke Sterling, Emily Rose Lyons and Jake Bentley Young

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kathryn Markey, Stephen Cerf, Michelle Beth Herman, Brooke Sterling, Emily Rose Lyons, Jake Bentley Young and Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kathryn Markey, Stephen Cerf, Michelle Beth Herman, Brooke Sterling, Emily Rose Lyons, Jake Bentley Young and Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Music Director Sarah Wussow with members of the band that includes- Rich Adams, Gary Meyer, Russ Brown and Jim Waddel

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Ashley Marinelli (Choreographer) and Tiger Brown (Associate Choreographer)

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Ashley Marinelli and Tiger Brown

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling and Tiger Brown

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling and her sister

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling and Paris Martino

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Paris Martino

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brandon Kallen

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Elise Shangold

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Carey Blackburn

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Andryi Nahirniak

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michael Morley

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Coleman Cummings

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Jake Bentley Young

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Jake Bentley Young

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brandt Norris

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Andryi Nahirniak and Elise Shangold

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling and Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Stephen Cerf

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Emily Rose Lyons Brooke Sterling and Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Emily Rose Lyons Brooke Sterling and Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Emily Rose Lyons Brooke Sterling and Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Stephen Cerf and Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Stephen Cerf and Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Stephen Cerf, Jake Bentley Young and Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Stephen Cerf, Michelle Beth Herman, Jake Bentley Young, Emily Rose Lyons, Brooke Sterling and Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Stephen Cerf, Michelle Beth Herman, Jake Bentley Young, Emily Rose Lyons, Brooke Sterling and Corbin Payne

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Jake Bentley Young and Emily Rose Lyons

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Emily Rose Lyons

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Emily Rose Lyons

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michelle Beth Herman

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Michael Morley and Paris Martino

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling, Emily Rose Lyons, Michelle Beth Herman and Kathryn Markey

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Brooke Sterling, Emily Rose Lyons, Michelle Beth Herman and Kathryn Markey

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kent M. Lewis

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Hannah Record

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Molly Samson

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Carey Blackburn and Kent M. Lewis

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Carey Blackburn and Kent M. Lewis

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kathryn Markey

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Kathryn Markey

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Carey Blackburn and Coleman Cummings

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Igor Goldin (Director), Ashley Marinelli, Tiger Brown and the Cast of Mystic Pizza that includes-Carey Blackburn, Stephen Cerf, Coleman Cummings, Michelle Beth Herman, Brando Kallen, Kent M. Lewis, Emily Rose Lyons, Kathryn Markey, Andryi Nahirniak, Brandt Norris, Corbin Payne, Hannah Record, Molly Samson, Elise Shangold, Brooke Sterling, Jake Bentley Young, Paris Martino and Michael Morley

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
Richard Dolce (Producing Artistic Director) Jennifer Collester (Director of Production) join Igor Goldin (Director), Ashley Marinelli, Tiger Brown and the Cast of Mystic Pizza that includes-Carey Blackburn, Stephen Cerf, Coleman Cummings, Michelle Beth Herman, Brandon Kallen, Kent M. Lewis, Emily Rose Lyons, Kathryn Markey, Andryi Nahirniak, Brandt Norris, Corbin Payne, Hannah Record, Molly Samson, Elise Shangold, Brooke Sterling, Jake Bentley Young, Paris Martino and Michael Morley

Photos: MYSTIC PIZZA Opens at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
The Creative Team- Ashley Marinelli, Tiger Brown, Igor Goldin and Sarah Wussow



FIRESIDE SESSIONS WITH NANCY ATLAS to Return toBay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center  Photo
The popular concert series, Fireside Sessions with Nancy Atlas, is returning to Bay Street Theater in January, with four live concerts at the theater starting Saturday, January 7, at 8 p.m. Performances continue every Saturday through January at 8 p.m.

Review: THE WIZARD OF OZ at CM Performing Arts Center Photo
What did our critic think of THE WIZARD OF OZ at CM Performing Arts Center? As soon as CM Performing Arts Center's live orchestra struck up the first few chords of 'The Wizard of Oz's' iconic overture, a wave of nostalgia hummed throughout the Noel S Ruiz Theatre. Multiple generations filled the house at the opening weekend matinee. Children, parents, grandparents, and children at heart visibly delighted in the stellar stagecraft, vibrant costumery, and charming performances featured in CM's Season 49 finale.

Review: A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater Photo
What did our critic think of A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater?

Feature: Cant Miss Childrens Theater This Holiday Season! Photo
'Tis the season for theatre! With Long Island being such a buzzing hub for regional and local theaters, you have plenty of options when it comes to bringing your children to experience the magic of live theater.


From This Author - Genevieve Rafter Keddy


Photos: TRU Returns To In-Person Gatherings With A Town Hall ForumPhotos: TRU Returns To In-Person Gatherings With A Town Hall Forum
November 30, 2022

On November 29th, Theater Resources Unlimited (TRU), the leading network for developing theater professionals, returned to in-person gatherings with an opening networking opportunity, roundtable forum, and book signing with Stewart F. Lane. Check out photos from the event here!

Photos: Gloria Estefan, The Radio City Rockettes, and More Rehearse For the Macy's Thanksgiving Day ParadePhotos: Gloria Estefan, The Radio City Rockettes, and More Rehearse For the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade
November 23, 2022

Rehearsals are underway for the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, taking place this Thursday morning on the streets of New York City. Check out photos from day two of rehearsals, featuring Gloria Estefan, The Radio City Rockettes, Jordin Sparks, and more!

Photos: FUNNY GIRL, A BEAUTIFUL NOISE, and More Rehearse For the Macy's Thanksgiving Day ParadePhotos: FUNNY GIRL, A BEAUTIFUL NOISE, and More Rehearse For the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade
November 22, 2022

Rehearsals are underway for the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, taking place this Thursday morning on the streets of New York City. The 2022 lineup includes Lea Michele and the cast of Funny Girl, as well as the casts of A Beautiful Noise, Some Like It Hot, and The Lion King. Check out photos from day one of rehearsal, featuring Funny Girl, A Beautiful Noise, and more.

Photos: A CHRISTMAS STORY Cast Celebrates Opening Night at The John W. Engeman Theater NorthportPhotos: A CHRISTMAS STORY Cast Celebrates Opening Night at The John W. Engeman Theater Northport
November 20, 2022

The John W. Engeman Theater's production of CHRISTMAS STORY, THE MUSICAL opened on Saturday, November 19th. Performances run through Saturday, December 31, 2022. Check out photos from the opening night here!

Photos: Go Inside BROADWAY BLOCKBUSTERS with The New York PopsPhotos: Go Inside BROADWAY BLOCKBUSTERS with The New York Pops
November 19, 2022

Last night, The New York Pops-led by Music Director and Conductor Steven Reineke was joined by guest artists Nikki Renée Daniels, Jordan Donica, Matt Doyle, and Melissa Errico, as well as Judith Clurman's Essential Voices USA in Stern Auditorium / Perelman Stage at Carnegie Hall for Broadway Blockbusters. Check out the photos here!