Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: So Wrong, It's Right in THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG at Clowes Memorial Hall

The Play That Goes Wrong

The premise is simple: a theatrical group who comes together in the hopes of producing their first "professional" performance, a dramatic murder mystery. The action of it is far from simple as everyone's best intentions turns into everyone's worst nightmares. The Play That Goes Wrong is burgeoning with classic physical humor and over-the-top personalities that will consume your attention from start to finish.


I had heard tell that The Play That Goes Wrong was exceptionally funny, had even heard it directly from cast member Chris French (Jonathan Harris), but nothing could prepare me for the tidal waves of humor and laughter that enveloped me opening night. Creating humor is a craft that takes excellent timing and no small amount of charisma. Every single cast member produced that in abundance. I laughed so hard and so long that my face was fixed in a massive smile by curtain call.

There are a few "insiders' tips" that will make this play even more entertaining from the outset. First, be sure to show up a bit early. The cast begins the comedy before the true action ever gets started. This is all the work of Ashley D. Kelley (Annie Twilloil) and Ryan Vincent Anderson (Trevor Watson). They set the stage both literally and figuratively with their pre-show antics. Second tip, check out the first few pages of the program to get to know the characters. It's not only funny but also gives you insight into the development of the characters' characters.

It is nearly impossible to pick a standout in a cast of so much talent. However, I personally enjoyed the talents of Adam Petherbridge as Max Bennett. He had a clear personality as his character as well as a clear personality as the actor behind the character. His reactions to the audience were priceless. I also could not get over the physicality of Chris French as Jonathan Harris, AKA the dead body. He may have been dead for the majority of the play, but his acting was beyond lively.

THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG was a welcome escape from everyday stressors that bring you down. It left me feeling lighter than when I arrived, and I felt refreshed by the whole experience. It will give me memories to turn to when I just need a good laugh.


Literally not a single second goes by where the audience - my and wife and I included - isn't howling, chuckling, or doubling over laughing starting before the show even begins until the final bow. Quick tip: be sure to be in your seat about 10 minutes early, and be sure to read the program, so you don't miss the clever preshow set-up of what's to come.

With an intense devotion to the saying "the show must go on," The Play That Goes Wrong is a ridiculous comedy in which a group of actors are resolute in putting on their murder mystery all while contending with falling set pieces, unconscious cast members, faulty props, and a inattentive sound operator.

Written and created by the uproarious team of Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, with direction from Matt DiCarlo (following the original Broadway direction by Mark Bell), the theatrical spoof (after its premiere in London and winning the prestigious Olivier Award for Best New Comedy in 2015) is within the format of a play-within-a-play, in which a university drama troupe puts on a fictitious 1920's murder mystery called The Murder at Haversham Manor. When an endless string of "minor disasters" wreak havoc on opening night, the cast and production team maintain their disastrous performance with a last-ditch commitment until the end.

Nigel Hook's Tony Award winner of a set design played a central aspect in the spoof, but in no way did it suffer in the smaller venue and stage of Clowes Hall. In my opinion, it happened to benefit and offered closer and more intimate experience for the audience, and offered nice sight-lines from the side seating, which can be difficult in boxes. Costuming by Roberto Surace evoked the era of the 1920's perfectly and contributed well to silliness of the show.

Honestly, the best part of the show were the effects and I was often left wondering, "how did they do that?" With a door on the set that refuses to open or close to wall decoration that crashes to the ground perfectly on time, to some pyrotechnics, the technical aspects of the show are a wonder and something I've never seen in a show. The actors themselves are complete masters of all-things physical comedy that is so perfect in a farce.

Don't miss your chance to see what's right about things going wrong until March 1st!

Related Stories
THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG Welcomes New Cast Members and Celebrates Its 200,001st Audience M Photo
Changes are afoot at The Play That Goes Wrong, which welcomes three new cast members to the production now playing at New World Stages starting tonight. Adam Petherbridge will take over the role of Max, reprising the role he played on the national tour, Trevor Braun joins as Dennis, and Clyde Voce makes his Off-Broadway debut as Jonathan.

THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG to Celebrate Shark Week With $34 Tickets at Seven Performances Photo
Shark Week has been an inescapable part of summer in the U.S.  for 34 years. The fear is real. The fascination is palpable. It ended on Sunday. And finally, a week late, the off-Broadway smash The Play That Goes Wrong will celebrate the nation’s obsession with sharks with its own SHARK WEEK at any performance from August 11-14, offering $34.

THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG Off-Broadway Welcomes New Cast Members Photo
The long running hit, The Play That Goes Wrong has a whole lotta changes going on and is celebrating a few milestones. It plays at New World Stages. Beginning Monday July 25, Chris Lanceley takes over the role of Chris Bean, Chris French goes on as Jonathan, and Russell Mernagh temporarily joins the company in the role of Max until August 22.

THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG Cancels Performances Through 5/9 Photo
Performances of The Play That Goes Wrong have been cancelled through Monday, May 9 due to breakthrough COVID-19 cases.

From This Author - The Marriage Matinee

The Marriage Matinee is the joint effort of Mr. and Mrs. Caraker, newlyweds who live in Indianapolis, Indiana. Now that they’ve formed the bond of holy matrimony, they’re hoping to form... (read more about this author)

Review: A CHRISTMAS STORY, THE MUSICAL Brings the Holiday Spirit at Civic TheatreReview: A CHRISTMAS STORY, THE MUSICAL Brings the Holiday Spirit at Civic Theatre
December 6, 2022

A Christmas Story, the Musical reimagines the 1983 holiday movie masterpiece with boisterous songs and dance that brought new life and excellent vocals to the season. Loving fans, rest easy. Joseph Robinette’s adaption, directed by Emily Rogge Tzucker, brightens iconic scenes and characters and enhances the humor. The lamp, the flag pole, and the turkey-mad Bumpus Hounds are all there.

Review: A (Happy) Holiday: A Festive Season ReimaginedReview: A (Happy) Holiday: A Festive Season Reimagined
December 6, 2022

It’s the holiday season and all reviewers are going to their required holiday shows... You know... Elf, A Christmas Story, A Christmas Carol. It's the same stuff, different year. Not this show. This is a brand new show by a unique writers' room collaboration called A (Happy) Holiday. Feeling down or out by the holidays while everyone one else around you has holiday cheer? This is the show for you. It's got everything -- singing, dancing, a unique story, and a drag queen. Who could honestly want more?

Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE At Beef & Boards: A Sparkling Holiday ClassicReview: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE At Beef & Boards: A Sparkling Holiday Classic
November 28, 2022

The holiday season brings with it many familiar sights, sounds, smells, and of course, beloved cinematic and stage treasures like IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE. Beef & Boards chose a true gem to get every audience member into the right spirit while always recalling what’s truly important and truly worth fighting for: each other.

Review: Caves and Worlds of Wonder in ALADDIN at Clowes Memorial HallReview: Caves and Worlds of Wonder in ALADDIN at Clowes Memorial Hall
November 22, 2022

For all those growing up watching Disney movies, and for the kids who absolutely loved Aladdin, the Genie and Princess Jasmine or even Abu, this is a must-watch! Big band, big sound, big show — with enough energy to light up a few thousand lamps.

Review: Have You Heard? ANASTASIA Brings Indy Audiences to Their FeetReview: Have You Heard? ANASTASIA Brings Indy Audiences to Their Feet
October 20, 2022

The rumors are true: ANASTASIA has finally made its way to Indianapolis. You may be thinking it’s just another movie turned musical, but there are new twists and turns to this rendition of the beloved animated film. There’s the romance, the legend of Anastasia, the glittering costumes and crowns, but there’s also battles with personal principles and a sense of national pride that leaves people emotionally and morally torn. In short, it has it all.