My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: ONCE UPON A CHRISTMAS TIME at Southwest Florida Theatre Company

The production runs through December 6.

By:
Review: ONCE UPON A CHRISTMAS TIME at Southwest Florida Theatre Company

Clearly, Maestro Andrew Kurtz is a master delegator. He got the idea of a Christmas show featuring fairy tale characters and promptly handed it off to his musical director Julie Beardon Carver. She took the idea and ran with it.

The result is an original musical, Once Upon a Christmas Time presented by the Southwest Florida Theatre Company at the Music & Arts Community Center.

The play begins with a rather complicated prologue by an off stage narrator. But the backstory is necessary to explain how Hansel and Gretel end up friends with Rapunzel. The three characters are portrayed by Matt Michael, Natalie Brouwer, and Reba Hartman respectively, and three more gorgeous voices would be hard to find.

Carver has created a delightful pastiche of a show, weaving a host of familiar holiday songs together. Plotwise, it’s Brothers Grimm meet O Henry.

Brouwer does double duty as she succumbs to the evil emanating from Snow White’s mirror and becomes a dark queen figure. Her rendition of “Winter Wonderland” set by Carver in a minor key is chilling and sinister.  

Michael and Hartman make a cute couple. Both give off sweet, wholesome vibes. Actually, that can be said of the entire show. Ultimately, it’s about all the things that make Christmas so wonderful: love, friendship, and family.

Once Upon a Christmas Time runs through December 6. For tickets, call 239.277.1700. And don’t be afraid to bring the kids.



Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Lighting Design - Top 3
1. Jen Schriever, Michael Arden - The Lost Boys
35.5% of votes
2. Jack Knowles - Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
9.9% of votes
3. Kevin Adams - Chess
7.6% of votes

Need more Ft. Myers/Naples Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Rocket Man in Ft. Myers/Naples Rocket Man
The Naples Players (10/21-11/22)
Say Goodnight, Gracie in Ft. Myers/Naples Say Goodnight, Gracie
Players Circle Theater (6/25-7/05)
Beers About Songs in Ft. Myers/Naples Beers About Songs
Theatre Conspiracy (5/29-5/31)
Les Miserables in Ft. Myers/Naples Les Miserables
The Naples Players (7/24-8/26)
Murder On The Orient Express in Ft. Myers/Naples Murder On The Orient Express
The Naples Players (1/13-2/14)
Comedian Erica Rhodes Live In Naples, Florida! in Ft. Myers/Naples Comedian Erica Rhodes Live In Naples, Florida!
Off The Hook Comedy Club (5/15-5/17)
Fire in the Meth Lab - Fort Myers Fringe in Ft. Myers/Naples Fire in the Meth Lab - Fort Myers Fringe
Theatre Conspiracy (5/28-5/31)
Why Won't Zee Quack - Fort Myers Kids Fringe in Ft. Myers/Naples Why Won't Zee Quack - Fort Myers Kids Fringe
Theatre Conspiracy (5/30-5/30)
Elektra - Fort Myers Teen Fringe in Ft. Myers/Naples Elektra - Fort Myers Teen Fringe
Theatre Conspiracy (5/30-5/30)
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical in Ft. Myers/Naples Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
Gulfshore Playhouse (4/26-5/31)


Videos