Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Photos: Nic Rouleau, Shereen Pimentel And More Star In I WISH: THE ROLES THAT COULD HAVE BEEN At Feinstein's/54 Below

This past Sunday, October 24th, I WISH: The Roles That Could Have Been, returned to Feinstein's/54 Below, with another full and vaccinated crowd!

This past Sunday, October 24th, I WISH: The Roles That Could Have Been, returned to Feinstein's/54 Below, with another full and vaccinated crowd!

Check out photos below!

Everyone has dreams that we fear will pass us by. For actors those come in the shape and form of roles-whether they're grown up and become too old for that child star turn, to the soprano never being considered for the baritone lead, everyone has a song in their heart that they'll likely never get to see come to fruition with a crowd and in lights.

From the crazy amazing mind of Alexandra Silber is, I Wish: The Roles That Could Have Been. The evening again gave performers a chance to embody their "roles come true". The concert boasted some of Broadway's favorite performers for a night of surprise, in ways one would never imagine. I WISH will be back at 54 Below in January, April and June, with more dates in 2022 to be announced soon! More news to follow on what stars will pop up at future incarnations of this amazing 54 Below concert series!

The evening was again produced by Jen Sandler and had music direction by Ben Caplan.

The October 2021 edition was hosted by theatre personality Ben Cameron (Wicked, Footloose), due to Silber's commitment to the London production of Indecent.

Performers in this incarnation included Major Attaway (Aladdin), Annie Golden (Netflix's "Orange Is The New Black," Broadway Bounty Hunter), Andrew Kober (School Of Rock, Hair), Fergie L. Philippe (Hamilton), Shereen Pimentel (West Side Story), Nic Rouleau (The Book of Mormon, Hello, Dolly!) and Stephanie Torns (Waitress, Wicked).

Photo Credit: Rebecca J Michelson



NAKED BOYS SINGING!s David Hernandez to Join LIVE WITH RYE & FRIENDS in April Photo
Live with Rye & Friends will be at the iconic, famous, and New York City renown cabaret supper club venue DON’T TELL MAMA NYC on Sunday, April 23, 2023 at 7:00pm in The Brick Room.

FEINBERG & ROSE: THE ROUND TABLE to be Presented at 54 Below in April Photo
54 BELOW, Broadway’s Supper Club, will present another edition of Feinberg & Rose: The Round Table  on April 27th, 2023 at 9:30pm.

Marilyn Maye Will Celebrate Her 95th Birthday at 54 Below Photo
54 BELOW, Broadway's Supper Club and 2022 Tony Awards Honoree for Excellence in the Theatre, is thrilled to welcome back Marilyn Maye for an exclusive run of shows ringing in her 95th birthday from April 8 & 9 at 7:00pm, April 10 at 8:00pm, and May 24 – 27 & 29 –31 at 7:00pm.

John Lloyd Young Returns to Cafe Carlyle Tonight Photo
John Lloyd Young, the Tony and Grammy Award-winning original star of Jersey Boys, returns to the Café Carlyle, March 28 through April 1, with an all-new set of Golden Era classics.


More Hot Stories For You


NAKED BOYS SINGING!'s David Hernandez to Join LIVE WITH RYE & FRIENDS in AprilNAKED BOYS SINGING!'s David Hernandez to Join LIVE WITH RYE & FRIENDS in April
March 28, 2023

Live with Rye & Friends will be at the iconic, famous, and New York City renown cabaret supper club venue DON’T TELL MAMA NYC on Sunday, April 23, 2023 at 7:00pm in The Brick Room.

FEINBERG & ROSE: THE ROUND TABLE to be Presented at 54 Below in AprilFEINBERG & ROSE: THE ROUND TABLE to be Presented at 54 Below in April
March 28, 2023

54 BELOW, Broadway’s Supper Club, will present another edition of Feinberg & Rose: The Round Table  on April 27th, 2023 at 9:30pm.

Marilyn Maye Will Celebrate Her 95th Birthday at 54 BelowMarilyn Maye Will Celebrate Her 95th Birthday at 54 Below
March 28, 2023

54 BELOW, Broadway's Supper Club and 2022 Tony Awards Honoree for Excellence in the Theatre, is thrilled to welcome back Marilyn Maye for an exclusive run of shows ringing in her 95th birthday from April 8 & 9 at 7:00pm, April 10 at 8:00pm, and May 24 – 27 & 29 –31 at 7:00pm.

John Lloyd Young Returns to Cafe Carlyle TonightJohn Lloyd Young Returns to Cafe Carlyle Tonight
March 28, 2023

John Lloyd Young, the Tony and Grammy Award-winning original star of Jersey Boys, returns to the Café Carlyle, March 28 through April 1, with an all-new set of Golden Era classics.

Andrew Keenan Bolger & Krysta Rodriguez to Perform With The Skivvies at Chelsea Table + StageAndrew Keenan Bolger & Krysta Rodriguez to Perform With The Skivvies at Chelsea Table + Stage
March 27, 2023

The Skivvies will perform at Chelsea Table + Stage on April 17th at 7pm, joined by special guests Andrew Keenan Bolger and Krysta Rodriguez!