Review: Lamplighters' NEW MIKADO is Excellence Itself

By: Aug. 16, 2016

There has been plenty of talk about the "lack of sensitivity" in Gilbert and Sullivan's British farce, "The Mikado," set in a Japan most often comprised of a white ensemble. But - as ready as this critic may be to defend the "great and virtuous man" - this review must sing the praises of a "new," albeit familiar Mikado, or rather, Ducato.

Lamplighters Music Theatre has reset the operetta to Tiramisu, Milan, and what an excellent production it is. The music and story are as enjoyable as ever, but half the fun comes from discovery of reinvented names and slight references to the original. Not to mention Ellen Brook's fresh direction of a show that Lamplighters has produced - with equal excellence - multiple times.

Nanki Poo becomes Niccolù, a wandering minstrel of the Italian Renaissance, and Yum Yum, the maiden he loves, becomes Amiam, the ward of the Lord High Executioner. Other innovative names include Coco, engaged to marry Amiam; Catiscià, who claims her perjured lover Niccolù; Poobà, whose family pride can be denied with a small insult; Piccia Tuccia, a gentleman of Milan; and Pizzi, Amiam's friend who adds corroborative details.

If these names sound amusing, Miriam Lewis' costume designs are even more so. The tall CharLes Martin steals the production in Poobà's outlandish garbs, including multiple oversized hats to accentuate his uproarious ego. Samuel Rabinowitz's Coco sports a multi-colored garb, complete with rounded glasses and a measuring tape he uses quite frequently to humorous effect. And Michael Orlinsky's Piccia Tuccia carries two daggers at all times, giving the casual character an air of comical menace. There are also two delightful "street entertainers" in all white that mimic unfolding follies.

Musically, "The New Mikado" could do no better than conductor Baker Peeples and his flawless orchestra and cast. Erin O'Meally and Patrick Hagen are spectacular as the romantic lovers Amiam and Niccolù. Ben Brady seems to truly enjoy himself as the self-assured Ducato. Elana Cowen's Pizzi is a pleasure. And Anne Hubble adds a beautiful vulnerability to Catiscià not often seen in the role. Her lighthearted moments with Rabinowitz's boyish Coco are sweet and diverting highlights.

As in most cases, Lamplighters double casts all the roles, but most of the alternating actors have proven themselves elsewhere. The one (sort of) downside of this "Mikado" comes with its scenic design, which borrows from other Lamplighters musicals, but works well. The whimsical world of Gilbert and Sullivan reimagined is more than enough to regale its audience for two and a half hours.


Lamplighters Music Theatre

Yerba Buena Center for the Arts, San Francisco
Tickets: 415-978-2787 or

Friday August, 19, 8pm
Saturday August 20, 2pm & 8pm
Sunday August 21, 2pm

Bankhead Theater, Livermore
Tickets: 925-373-6800 or

Saturday August 27, 8pm
Sunday August 28, 2pm

Follow all the latest Bay Area Theatre and Arts news on our San Francisco Facebook Page. Click here to visit the page today!

Follow Harmony Wheeler's theatre and opera adventures on Instagram and Twitter @HarmonyWheeler.

RELATED STORIES - San Francisco / Bay Area

Emergency Rally “Catch Up, California: Bay Area for SB 1116” Asks State Senate Photo
Emergency Rally “Catch Up, California: Bay Area for SB 1116” Asks State Senate to Reverse Devastating Arts Underfunding

A coalition of Bay Area performing artists are holding an emergency rally, Catch Up, California: Bay Area for SB 1116, on Friday, June 9, 2023, at Bayfront Theatre in San Francisco. Senate Bill 1116, which was signed into law by Governor Newsom last year, establishes the Equitable Payroll Fund for the nonprofit arts sector and would create jobs and revitalize local economies, but currently remains unfunded. 

Photos: First Look At Ray Of Light Theatres SPRING AWAKENING Photo
Photos: First Look At Ray Of Light Theatre's SPRING AWAKENING

Ray of Light Theatre’s production of the Tony Award-winning rock musical, SPRING AWAKENING opens tonight in San Francisco. Performances begin June 8th at the Victoria Theatre and run for one weekend only, through Sunday, June 11th. Get a first look at the photos here!

THE NUTCRACKER, CINDERELLA & More Set for New Ballet 2023-24 Season Photo
THE NUTCRACKER, CINDERELLA & More Set for New Ballet 2023-24 Season

New Ballet, the institution that Silicon Valley looks to for excellence in the art of ballet, has announced the 2023-24 season and Company roster.

Northern Nights Music Festival Reveals Phase Two Music Lineup For 10th Anniversary Photo
Northern Nights Music Festival Reveals Phase Two Music Lineup For 10th Anniversary

Northern Nights Music Festival has announced the phase two music lineup and revealed more cannabis details for its 10th anniversary, taking place in Northern California's iconic Redwood Forest this July 14-16.

From This Author - Harmony Wheeler


#repshow# in[i]# Spring Awakening
Victoria Theatre (6/08-6/11)Tracker
#repshow# in[i]# "Best of Enemies" (NT Live)
Hammer Theatre Center (6/14-6/18)
#repshow# in[i]# Steel Magnolias
Mountain View Center for the Performing Arts (6/07-7/02)
#repshow# in[i]# "The Mushroom Cure"
The Marsh (4/29-6/17)
#repshow# in[i]# "The Waiting Period"
The Marsh San Francisco (5/21-7/23)
#repshow# in[i]# Killing My Lobster Presents: Toon Out
447 Minna (5/25-6/10)
#repshow# in[i]# King Lear
Santa Cruz Shakespeare (7/26-8/27)
#repshow# in[i]# The Taming of the Shrew
Santa Cruz Shakespeare (7/09-8/26)
#repshow# in[i]# Axle Surgeons of California, Inc.
Axle Surgeons of California & Northern California - Axle Doctor (5/26-12/31)
#repshow# in[i]# She Loves Me
Gateway Theater (6/10-6/25)

Recommended For You