Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: BUTTERFLIES ~ A Powerful And Poignant Anti-Bullying Allegory

Review: BUTTERFLIES ~ A Powerful And Poignant Anti-Bullying Allegory

BUTTERFLIES, directed by Cady McClain and written by and featuring Carlotta Summers, is a riveting, emotionally powerful, and important anti-bullying allegory of survival and empowerment.

Important, because, in the brief span of a gut-wrenchingly intense and spiritually uplifting fourteen minutes, it accomplishes what the alarming and devastating statistics about bullying can only suggest. Its power and relevance lie not only in its ability to transport us into the body of torment and humiliation that a child struggles daily to endure. It ventures a next critical step (and, perhaps, this is the essence of the film's ultimate value) to reveal a pathway to self-actualization and liberation.

As a child, Melanie Holmes is a dreamer and a free spirit, enthralled by her environment, dancing among the flowers, trusting in the inviolability of her friendship with a girl named Paris, and fascinated by the life of the butterfly. Her language is poetic.

Somewhere and somehow, between the halcyon times of her early childhood and the opening days of high school, happiness turns into despair and friendship alters to alienation. Her idealism, intelligence, and her identity (she is biracial) have become, incomprehensibly, a magnet for scorn and persecution.

Ms. Summers's portrayal of the teenage Melanie ~ a distraught and forlorn figure navigating as though among a sea of predators ~ is mesmerizing. Her face is a roadmap of her emotions, her dark eyes windows into the depths of her pain. Borne of her own life experiences, Summers imbues her character with authenticity and passion.

Thanks to A. J. Wilhelm's keen eye, the camera captures every nuance of Melanie's emotional journey and transformation. The film's mood and tension are enhanced by the music of PROM (Ella Zoller and Gabriel Stanley).

Melanie's life is a test of endurance. She absorbs the heckling, teasing and insults of her peers. She's threatened by a bully. She's brought to tears as she's chided for wearing her mother's ethnic earrings and blouse. She suffers the betrayal of Paris (Kristina Reyes). On and on it goes ~ a narrative all too familiar to far too many teens!

Yet, Melanie cannot be overcome.

She finds solace in the arms of her mother (Linda Powell) who has discovered a portfolio of drawings that are a teenager's desperate cry for help. Mom knows that these trials are hard, but she also affirms the injustice of being punished for being smart.

She discovers an invaluable and instructive metaphor for her journey in a science class. While her fellow-students are self-absorbed and languish through Mr. Washington's (Julian Elfer) lectures about the adaptive behavior patterns of the butterfly, Melanie is listening attentively. She seizes on the essence of his lesson ~ that these creatures, like all creatures, are important to our survival, that they have a right to exist, and that they survive because they evolve.

The butterfly becomes Melanie's metaphor!

There is a progression to Melanie's awakening that BUTTERFLIES tracks with awesome precision and sensitivity. It is in the revelatory moments that flow from the anchor of her mother's love and empathy and from the science of life that Melanie finally realizes her innate power. There are indeed lifelines to grab onto. She has the right to exist and to be who she wants to be. Melanie chooses to evolve. She emerges from her cocoon a mighty force.

The enduring message of BUTTERFLIES resonates in Melanie's victorious and inexorable affirmation, "I have the right to exist!"

A remarkable assemblage of talents was recruited to create this vitally important statement, a testament to their commitments to fight the epidemic of bullying.

BUTTERFLIES is currently on the festival circuit. It is a film not to be missed and, certainly, one that should be considered by school administrators and youth organizations as an essential component of their educational toolkit.

Poster credit to BUTTERFLIES Movie



Related Articles View More Phoenix Stories


From This Author - Herbert Paine

Herb Paine is President of Paine Consulting Services, now in its thirtieth year of operation, specializing in organizational development, strategic planning, turnaround management, mergers, and governance.... (read more about this author)

Review: Theatre Artists Studio's NEW SUMMER SHORTS 2022
June 22, 2022

What did our critic think? Whether poking fun at human foibles or reflecting on critical social issues, Theatre Artists Studio’s NEW SUMMER SHORTS offers an entertaining potpourri of perspectives. Runs through June 26th at The Studio in Scottsdale, AZ.

BWW Review: ASSASSINS at Stray Cat Theatre
May 10, 2022

Guest contributor David Appleford's review of Stray Cat Theatre's production of Stephen Sondheim's ASSASSINS, directed by Ron May. Runs through May 21st at Tempe Center for the Arts. A stunning reminder about the kind of emotional power that only a live theatrical experience can create.

BWW Review: Unique Takes - Kerry Lengel on Ballet Arizona's World Premiere of JUAN GABRIEL
May 8, 2022

Another major first from Ballet Arizona ~ the World Premiere of JUAN GABRIEL, with choreography by Ib Andersen. Kerry Stewart Lengel offers his unique perspective ~ THIS IS NOT A REVIEW: Lonesome George Goes to the Theatre ~ on this remarkable production. Runs through May 8th at Phoenix's Symphony Hall.

BWW Review: Theatre Artists Studio Presents Sharyn Rothstein's BY THE WATER
April 4, 2022

Sharyn Rothstein's compelling human drama, BY THE WATER, on stage through April 24th at Theatre Artists Studio, benefits from the well-paced direction of Janis Webb and the finely-drawn performances of her seasoned cast.

BWW Review: CAMELOT at Don Bluth Front Row Theatre
March 27, 2022

Co-directors Joe and Lorraine Bousard stage a refreshing and imaginative revival of CAMELOT, featuring shining performances by Alexandra Utpadel as Guinevere, Adam Shelton as Arthur, and Matthew Dodaro as Lancelot ~ running through April 30th at Don Bluth Front Row Theatre in Scottsdale AZ.