An Outrageous Outcome at Hudson Guild Theater

JUAN CASTRO (he/him) is thrilled to make his New York Theater Festival debut! He returns to the role of Man 1 after being part of the Green Room 42 concert reading in 2023. He is a New York based singer and actor originally from Los Angeles, California. Credits include Quasimodo in The Hunchback of Notre Dame (Cabrillo Stage), Willy in Flora the Red Menace (Forager Theatre Company), William Barfée in The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee (Artistree VT), and Bobby Strong in Urinetown (The Secret Theatre). He would like to thank Colby for the opportunity to originate this role! @juancastrophe | juancastroofficial.com

ROCKY NARDONE has been acting in New York State for over a decade and is so proud to be a part of this production. This is his fourth time collaborating with Colby Thompson, and second time performing in AOO. Notable roles include Charlemagne (Pippin), Czolgosz (Assassins), and Captain Horster (An Enemy Of The People). Rocky works as a schoolteacher and is currently working toward his Master of Arts in Teaching. Incredibly big thank you to Colby and everyone on the AOO team! Also, thanks and love to Mom and Dad, and most of all, you, valued audience member!

ANNIKA STENSTEDT (she/her) is a graduate of NYU/Tisch School of the Arts, where she trained at the Stella Adler Studio of Acting and the Department of Drama’s New Studio on Broadway. Previous credits include: Bandstand (Mrs. Adams), Stage Door (Judith, Pat), Legally Blonde (Kate, u/s Vivienne), Head over Heels (u/s Pamela, Ensemble), and Dogfight (Rose). Annika is also a musical theater composer/lyricist; her Rosie the Riveter musical, ROSIE: A New Musical, premiered in concert at 54 Below in 2024, and she is a composer for Pixel Playhouse (1m subs on Youtube). @annikagirlbird annikastenstedt.com

EMILY ROSE UNNASCH is thrilled to be performing in her first show in New York after moving to the city from Southern California! Regional: Nice Work If You Can Get it, Cabaret, The Light In The Piazza (CVRep). Other notable roles include Belle (Beauty and the Beast), Cassie (A Chorus Line), and Annie Oakley (Annie Get Your Gun). Film/TV: “Take Back” (Amazon Prime), “Expedition Unknown” (Discovery). Many thanks to the team of An Outrageous Outcome! IG: @emily.r.unnasch

ALAINA BOZARTH is an NYC based performer originally from St. Louis! She graduated with a BFA in musical theatre from Belmont University. She loves plants, books, writing, and her dog, Macy. Special thanks to Mom, Dad, and agent, Michael!

JOSHUA ORSI is an actor from Omaha, Nebraska, is excited to find his footing in the NYC scene. Familiar with both stage and screen, Joshua has been in off-off broadway’s The Airport and the Strange Package as well as indie horror film Legado. Joshua has recently joined the cast of MechWest, adding to his voice acting resume that includes video games and commercials. Joshua lives in Jersey City with his two fluffy cats and his partner, who he loves equally.

Colby is a NYC-based composer, playwright, and occasional actor and director. He is a graduate of the University of Vermont, where he wrote his first complete musical, The Tempest, with a book by Amanda Hill. Since then, he’s written A Mysterious Affair; Hey, Look Up, Love; Making Banks (with the Showpeople Theatre Collective); This Side of Paradise; An Outrageous Outcome; Chocolatier. The final three have been presented in NYC with Chocolatier getting a studio cast album released in late 2025. Colby is currently in the development process of another musical, Yes, Virginia, and his first non-musical play, The Shape of Everything.