Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: LOVE, LOSS, AND WHAT I WORE at Oyster Mill Playhouse

A lovely and highly relatable production.

By:
Review: LOVE, LOSS, AND WHAT I WORE at Oyster Mill Playhouse

Nora and Delia Ephron’s play Love, Loss, and What I Wore premiered in 2008. The play is based on the 1995 book by Ilene Beckerman. A series of monologues that explore relationships, moments in the lives of women, identity, and clothing, Love, Loss, and What I Wore is a highly relatable piece of theatre. Under the direction of Marcie Warner and assistant director Nancy Parson, Oyster Mill Playhouse presents this humorous, poignant, authentically emotional play through March 22nd.

The all-female production team includes, in addition to director Marcie Warner, producer/Costume Designer/poster artist Bethany Butler, producer Sam Speraw, stage manager/lighting tech Abby Armstrong, assistant stage manager Becky Jenkins, lighting designer Tessa Arnold, and assistant director/sound designer Nancy Parson. The set, props, and costuming highlight, in a subtle and lovely way, the various themes that tie the show together. The lighting and blocking help to keep the audience’s attention focused on the story and those telling the story.

The cast features Diane McCormick as Gingy, the storyteller who provides the thread that weaves the monologues and vignettes together. Joining McCormick are Riley Artis, Kristen Borgersen, Sarah Carson, Jackie Dougherty, Lois Heagy, Jila Rusavage, Delainey Shroy, and Gerren Wagner. McCormick’s performance is delightful. She fills Gingy’s story with vivacity and authenticity, making the audience feel as though they are listening to a dear friend’s life story.

Review: LOVE, LOSS, AND WHAT I WORE at Oyster Mill Playhouse Image

Artis, Borgersen, Carson, Dougherty, Heagy, Rusavage, Shroy, and Wagner each take on various characters throughout the performance, demonstrating wonderful versatility, whether through altering their voices and accents like Heagy and Rusavage, changing their expressions and line delivery like Borgerson, Wagner, and Carson, or varying their attitudes like Artis, Dougherty, and Shroy. Even when they are not actively taking part in the scene, each of these actors are fully involved in the story so that no matter where the audience is looking, they are never distracted or disengaged.

There are so many wonderful and relatable moments in this play, audience members of various ages and backgrounds are sure to find themselves drawn into the humor and emotions. This reviewer particularly enjoyed the “Clothesline” scenes, “I Hate My Purse”, and “Brides”. “The Bathrobe” and “Geralyn’s Story” are particularly powerful and heart-rending. “Madonna” and “Sisters” are delightful.

Love, Loss, and What I Wore reminds us that our life experiences and memories of those experiences make us who we are and that there are threads in life that tie us all together no matter how far apart we may be from one another in time and space. The production of Love, Loss, and What I Wore at Oyster Mill Playhouse is full of heart, inviting the audience to laugh and cry with them. It is just the type of play the world needs right now to remind us how important the little things in life really are. Check out oystermillplayhouse.com for your tickets.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Oyster Mill Playhouse
Recent Articles
Review: SABRINA FAIR at Oyster Mill Playhouse
Review: SABRINA FAIR at Oyster Mill Playhouse
5/9/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Central Pennsylvania News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


HAIR in Central Pennsylvania HAIR
Gretna Theatre (7/23-8/02)
Musical: Annie in Central Pennsylvania Musical: Annie
Milford Theater (7/18-8/09)
Golden Girls The Laughs Continue in Central Pennsylvania Golden Girls The Laughs Continue
Mishler Theatre (11/17-11/17)
Disney Princess - the Concert - Venue Premium Tickets in Central Pennsylvania Disney Princess - the Concert - Venue Premium Tickets
York Barbican (4/09-4/09)
THE THANKSGIVING PLAY in Central Pennsylvania THE THANKSGIVING PLAY
Ephrata Performing Arts Center (9/03-9/13)
Culmination '27: Spring Dance Concert in Central Pennsylvania Culmination '27: Spring Dance Concert
Messiah University Department of Theatre and Dance (4/23-4/24)
BAT! 50th Anniversary - Bat Out of Hell - Venue Premium Tickets in Central Pennsylvania BAT! 50th Anniversary - Bat Out of Hell - Venue Premium Tickets
York Barbican (4/30-4/30)
33 Variations  in Central Pennsylvania 33 Variations
Messiah University Department of Theatre and Dance (10/01-10/04)
The Boy Band Project in Central Pennsylvania The Boy Band Project
Totem Pole Playhouse (8/18-8/18)
The Christmas Rush in Central Pennsylvania The Christmas Rush
Bird-in-Hand Stage (10/30-12/31)