Review: ANYTHING GOES at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre

By: Oct. 23, 2016
Enter Your Email to Unlock This Article

Plus, get the best of BroadwayWorld delivered to your inbox, and unlimited access to our editorial content across the globe.

Existing user? Just click login.

Most eighty-some-year-olds creak a bit, but others really get around, and that's the truth about ANYTHING GOES. Cole Porter is, of course, one of the great lyrical geniuses of history, which is a huge part of the reason, but there's another truth about it - heavily worked-over as the book was, and has been, it hasn't aged badly... possibly because it's purely frothy silliness, like GUYS AND DOLLS. In this day, however, the frothy silliness is almost realistic, since part of the plot revolves around hysterical celebrity-worship. Is that young man really Public Enemy Number One? Grab a selfie with him before the police get him! Wait, he's not a famous criminal? Well, then, get him out of our way!

Over at Dutch Apple, the stage has become a ship, and insanity on the high seas has taken over. Onor Robert Falon, as Billy Crocker, is dazed and confused as he makes his way from accidental stowaway to gangster sidekick to Public Enemy Number One. His old friend, entertainer Reno Sweeney, is singing her heart out, as Christina Tompkins holds the audience in the palm of her hand with her numbers, from "I Get a Kick Out of You" and "You're the Top" to the Act One close of "Anything Goes" and a spectacular "Blow, Gabriel, Blow." This is her first appearance at Dutch Apple, but one hopes it won't be her last.

Allison Fund plays Hope, Billy's love interest, as a sweet, winsome thing that's perfect for Billy, just as Reno is just the thing for Lord Evelyn Oakleigh, played with great good humor and delightful pratfalls by Craig Smith, Dutch Apple's veteran comic relief master. Oakleigh loves American words, American phrases, and every note out of Reno's throat, despite his engagement to Hope. Can these couples be worked out? It's a comedy, so there's a very good chance of it. Don't Miss Smith's incredibly delightful "The Gypsy In Me."

Best of all is Victor Legaretta as Moonface Martin, the gangster who's nowhere near Public Enemy Number One and suffers from insufficient respect because of it. Legaretta's duet on "Friendship" with Tompkins is a highlight of the first act, and his solo, "Be Like the Bluebird," in the second act is riotously funny. Legaretta, Tompkins, and Smith are worth the price of admission.

But the story of star-crossed and sea-tossed Billy and Hope is at the center of all things, and it's hard not to root for such an adorable couple, even while you root for the less-than-heroic Moonface to pull off his disguises as he hides out on shipboard.

The ensemble numbers, especially "Anything Goes" and "Blow, Gabriel, Blow," are heaven for tap fans - this is a tap-dancing show if ever there was one, and Samantha Hewes Cramer, the choreographer, and director Paul Bernier, have pulled out all the stops. If it's possible to tap all the way through the stage floor, this show may just do it. This is some of the best dance at Dutch Apple since WEST SIDE STORY, and it's worth seeing for any dance fan. John P. White, quite possibly the best costume designer in the area, also pulled out all the stops; it's a lavishly costumed Deco riot of colors and patterns.

With a great cast, classic songs, colorful costuming, and non-stop dance, there's no way not to feel good after watching this show. It's the best dessert Dutch Apple can offer its dinner guests - it has plenty of eye appeal, it's got good taste, and it has no calories at all. What's not to like?

At Dutch Apple through November 12, and enough fun for anyone. Visit for tickets and information.