My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses
The Shark is Broken show poster

The Shark is Broken at Fulton Theatre

Dates: 2/27/2026 - 3/22/2026

📍 Theatre:
Fulton Theatre
Fulton Theatre Logo


12 N Prince St
Lancaster, PA 17603

Phone: 7173977425

Tickets: Range


Man vs. Man vs Man vs. Mechanical Shark  

JAWS, the first summer blockbuster movie is being filmed, but no one working on the film would know it. Dive deep into the tumultuous, murky waters of the making of a major motion picture with testy, feuding costars, unpredictable weather, and a shark prop whose constant breakdowns are looking like an omen for the future of the movie. In this comedy co-written by Ian Shaw and Joseph Nixon, the short tempers of Jaws stars Robert Shaw (father of co-writer Ian), Richard Dreyfuss, and Roy Scheider take center stage as they bond, argue, drink, gamble, and pray for an end to the shoot, not knowing it will change their lives forever.

Cast and Creative Team for The Shark is Broken at Fulton Theatre

Cast

Dan Fenaughty
Roy Scheider
Fulton Debut! Recent Credits include: The Cher Show (North Shore Music Theater), The 39 Steps (Hippodrome Theatre), Footloose (Engeman Theatre), Noise Off (Gulfshore Playhouse), Ragtime (Stages/St. Louis), White Christmas (Tuachan), Little Shop of Horrors (Meadow Brook), Beautiful (Theatre Aspen), I Do, I Do (Ozark Actors Theater), Million Dollar Quartet (Saugatuck Center for the Arts) and 42nd Street (Palace Theater). Grateful to Trey for our third voyage together and to all involved from the cast, crew, production team, theater staff, and most of all to you, the audience. All my love to Larissa. TV/FILM: The Good Fight, The Blacklist, Madame Secretary. Proud AEA member
John Hays
Richard Dreyfuss
John Hays is an actor and musician with a degree in theatre from Pepperdine University. Since then, he has spent most of his time performing around the country, most notably as Billy in the Broadway National Tour of Once, and, until recently, as the lead guitarist for the band Nicotine Dolls. He is thrilled to be acting in his second production under the direction of Trey Compton and is deeply grateful for the opportunity. Endless thanks to his beautiful girlfriend, whose unwavering support—and strength through so many days apart—means everything. Love to Kendal Fries, the best High School theatre teacher anyone could ask for.
Geoffrey Kent
Robert Shaw
(He/They) Recent credits: Mark Antony in Antony & Cleopatra, Master Ford in The Merry Wives of Windsor and Billy Bones in Treasure Island for the Utah Shakespeare Festival; Benedick in Much Ado About Nothing and Bob Cratchit in A Christmas Carol for the Denver Center for the Performing Arts; Dracula in Dracula, Col. Brandon in Sense & Sensibility and The Mastiff in The Moors for the Arvada Center; Mercutio in Romeo & Juliet and Petruchio in The Taming of the Shrew for the Orlando Shakespeare Theater; Iago in Othello and Hotspur in Henry 4 Part 1 for the Colorado Shakespeare Festival. Geoffrey also directs, fight directs, and teaches stage combat and Shakespeare around the US. www.GeoffreyKent.com @geoffreykent
Peter Herrick
u/s Robert Shaw
David Bliss: Hay Fever / George Standby: Who’s Afraid Of Virginia Woolf (Walnut Street Theatre); Lloyd: Noises Off (Clear Space Theatre); Charlie: The Foreigner/ Jean-François Millet: Is He Dead? (Greenbrier Valley Theatre); Twin Brothers: Corpse! (Cortland Rep.); How To Save Jimmy Mcclintock (The Actors Studio); Great Expectatons / Glory Girls (Abingdon Theatre Co.). Other: The Seagull; Richard II; King Lear; Angels In America; Dracula; Gint; Murder On The Nile; I Hate Hamlet (as Barrymore); Macbeth; and Camelot. TV/film: The Whitehouse Plumbers / The Deuce (HBO), The Blacklist (NBC), Bull (CBS), Little Accidents (feature film). Thank you to the Fulton and to my husband Brian and the Hell’s Kitchen Agency.
James Arthel Riley
u/s Richard Dreyfuss
James is thrilled to be back at the Fulton! Previous Fulton credits: Deceived (Jack u/s). Previous Lancaster credits: The Mousetrap (Giles Ralston), Fiddler on the Roof (Constable), Camelot (Male Swing) at the Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre. Select regional credits: Little Women (John, Hedgerow Theatre Co.), Sherlock Holmes: The Final Adventure (Prof. Moriarty, West Virginia Public Theatre), The Burnt Part Boys (Miner Boggs, Mountain Theatre Co.). Film/Television: Chicago P.D. (NBC Universal). James is a proud board member of the Summit Theatre Project in Anchorage, Alaska. Learn more at www.summittheatreproject.org. Many thanks to Marc, Joey and everyone that makes the Fulton so special, including you, the audience! Love to Kaitlyn, Mom, Dad and Paul. For Jean Houck. Thanks be to God.
Joshua Schwartz
u/s Roy Scheider
is thrilled and grateful to make his Fulton Theatre Groff Series debut. Previous Fulton: Holiday Cabaret (2022, 2023); Ragtime Concert (Admiral Peary). Other recent favorites: Marvin – Falsettos (Susquehanna Stage), Professor Callahan – Legally Blonde (Hershey Area Playhouse), Robert – Company (Susquehanna Stage ’19, Dreamwrights ’21), Beadle Banford – Sweeney Todd (Hershey Area Playhouse); Narrator – Rocky Horror Show (Mickey’s Black Box). Come see Josh as Leo Frank in Parade at Hershey Area Playhouse October 15–25, 2026. Offstage, Josh is an attorney at Barley Snyder. Thanks to Mark, Joey, and the entire Fulton team for the opportunity. All my love to Carey, Eli, and Casey.

News About The Shark is Broken at Fulton Theatre


We have no news on this show at the current time.

About the Theatre

Fulton Theatre

Fulton Theatre

12 N Prince St
Lancaster, PA 17603

Phone: 7173977425

Visit Website

Facebook Instagram TikTok
📍
View Map
12 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA

A nationally-regarded, professional regional theatre that produces musicals and plays featuring exceptional Broadway, national, and local talent and design. See extraordinary performances in a nationally-registered historic landmark with newly-expanded, modern, facilities. Find show information and schedules at theFulton.org

Fulton Theatre Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ

Fulton Theatre is at 12 N Prince St, Lancaster, PA.

And Then There Were None (2/13/26-3/8/26)
Every Brilliant Thing (1/16/26-2/1/26)
Robin & Clark's The Nutcracker (12/6/25-12/27/25)
It's a Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play (12/5/25-12/28/25)
Elf: The Musical (11/21/25-12/28/25)
Deceived (10/24/25-11/16/25)
Jekyll & Hyde: The Musical (10/10/25-11/2/25)
Driving Miss Daisy (9/12/25-9/28/25)
Cats (6/13/25-7/20/25)

More Central Pennsylvania Coverage

Videos