Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: AMERICA'S SWEETHEARTS is a Modern Day USO Show at The Green Room 42

America's Sweethearts Pay Tribute to Girl Groups

Review: AMERICA'S SWEETHEARTS is a Modern Day USO Show at The Green Room 42

At the height of the war, if you had a night out in NYC, it went something like this. All the Eager Beavers had a brainchild to sweep up your best dame and drop a few nickels at the Automat where all the hep cats were cooking with gas. Then if you were feeling off the cob, you might snap your cap and hotfoot it over to Roseland to cut a rug and wear out a pair of stompers going fishing among the Khaki-wacky set. No floy floy about it.

If any of that made sense, then AMERICA'S SWEETHEARTS at The Green Room 42 is the show for you. They are a girl group that pays tribute to the girl groups of the 40s, 50s, and 60s with an emphasis on tight harmonies and wholesome energy. They are clearly modeled on the Andrews Sisters, but they are not impersonators. It's more like they use Patty, Maxene, and LaVerne as a jumping-off point to celebrate all the famous sister acts. In many ways, it's like experiencing a USO show without the pesky inconvenience of having to go to war. In fact, each of the women has members of her family who have served in the military, and so their show had a ring of authenticity to it.

AMERICA'S SWEETHEARTS is a bit of an organization. The group consists of eleven women but only three perform at any one performance. Tonight's trio consisted of group founder Carly Kincannon, Amanda LaVergne (Annie, The People in the Picture, ) and Kristen Michelle (Once Upon a Mattress.) Their show is a bundle of joy that makes you want to tap your toes and dance in the aisles. Their energy is infectious. They even managed a costume change going from modified WACS uniforms to slinky burgundy sequin gowns.

They avoided any sentimental ballads and kept to the uptempo numbers for the most part. In addition to the Andrews Sisters classics "Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy," "In the Mood," and "Rum Boogie Woogie," they breezed through a rotogravure full of hit tunes like " Straighten Up and Fly Right," Lullaby of Broadway," "Good Mornin''," Java Jive," "Why Do Fools Fall in Love?" "It's My Party," and "The Shoop Shoop Song."

Each of the women also took a solo turn to vary the pace. Kristen Michelle gave us a Judy Garland-worthy "Zing Went the Strings of My Heart." Amanda LaVergne belted out a great rendition of Cole Porter's "Too Darn Hot." And Carly Kincannon gave us a steamy "Fever," using the mic stand in ways that might not be entirely kid-friendly. All three of the Sweethearts have pipes. They can belt to the rafters. But they also are skillful enough to blend perfectly with each other. They may not be actual sisters, but their rapport onstage is completely familial.

They are backed up by an excellent trio of men led by musical director Chris Bonner. I would have loved to have seen a little more interplay between the women and the band, but in the end, this is a show about female empowerment, with women front and center. It is a delight for lovers of girl groups, for lovers of the 1940s, for lovers of Americana, and lovers of music everywhere.

For more information on America's Sweethearts, go to To find more greats acts at the Green Room 42 or to make a reservation at the adjacent terrace restaurant The Green Fig, go to

Join Team BroadwayWorld

Are you an avid Cabaret fan in NYC? We're looking for people like you to share your thoughts and insights with our readers. Team BroadwayWorld members get access to shows to review, conduct interviews with artists, and the opportunity to meet and network with fellow theatre lovers and arts workers.

Interested? Learn more here.

From This Author - Ricky Pope

Ricky Pope is a very busy actor/musical director/vocal coach who has toured the country with the national tours of ANNIE, ALL SHOOK UP AND TITANIC. He has worked in regional theatres in 49 states in... (read more about this author)

BWW Review: TORI SCOTT Leaves It All on the Stage in JETLAGGED at Joe's Pub
March 31, 2022

There is a phenomenon that occurs at Joe’s pub sometimes. Once in a while, you feel a little tremor underneath the seats while you’re watching a show like you’re experiencing a small earthquake. It’s attributable to the 6 train that runs directly below the Public Theatre on Lafayette Street. However last night, the tremor that was felt was completely due to the act onstage. Tori Scott was in complete command of the room, a room packed with fans there to celebrate her return to Joe’s Pub after a 2-year absence. For ten years she has been making appearances at the downtown cabaret and has developed a sizeable following. If her show, TORI SCOTT: JETLAGGED is any indication, it’s no wonder she has such devoted followers.

BWW Review: CHEEYANG NG is an Artist on the Rise at Feinstein's 54 Below
March 21, 2022

Cheeyang Ng is an impressive human. They are celebrating nearly a decade as a resident of New York. The native of Singapore came here, as they said to escape some traditions and find a truer, more authentic version of themself. That journey is reflected in many of their songs, which focus on the joys and the uncertainty of being in unfamiliar territory, whether it be relationships or career ambitions of just self-actualization. They seem drawn to examining the multitude of thoughts and feelings that occur in a split second of actual time. In short, Cheeyang Ng writes about the active mind.

BWW Review: BETTY BUCKLEY & FRIENDS Deliver a Beautifully Thoughtful Evening at Joe's Pub
March 19, 2022

Betty Buckley is in great form. Her control over her instrument is remarkable, singing soft and gently, making her audience wait for the clarion tones that are her trademark. But when it’s time to belt, she delivers. She is masterful at creating musical monologues. For all her musical gifts you never forget that you are watching a great actress at work.

BWW Interview: Broadway Veteran Liz Callaway of TO STEVE, WITH LOVE at Feinstein's 54 Below Talks Sondheim and More
March 17, 2022

At every point of her career, Liz Callaway has been closely associated with the work of Stephen Sondheim. Her Broadway debut was in Merrily We Roll Along, which despite its sadly brief run has gone on to be the ultimate cult musical. Along with Merrily co-star, Jim Walton, she sang excerpts of Sondheim’s work when he appeared on Bravo’s Inside the Actors Studio. She has also appeared in a number of Sondheim tributes including You’re Gonna Love Tomorrow and the much-heralded concert of Follies in which she played Young Sally. This month, Liz Callaway pays tribute to the recently departed maestro in a very personal evening entitled TO STEVE, WITH LOVE which will premiere at Feinstein’s 54 Below on March 23. I had the pleasure of talking to Ms. Callaway about the show and her body of work with Stephen Sondheim.

BWW Review: NY Pops Enchants With GET HAPPY: THE NELSON RIDDLE SOUND at Carnegie Hall
March 17, 2022

Nelson Riddle, the legendary arranger/orchestrator/composer is largely responsible for what we think of as the sound of The Great American Songbook. His arrangements and orchestrations for artists like Ella Fitzgerald, Frank Sinatra, Peggy Lee, Nat King Cole Dean Martin, Judy Garland, Johnny Mathis, Rosemary Clooney, and Doris Day, created for the Capitol label defined the sound of the 40s, 50s, and 60s. He is responsible for resuscitating Sinatra’s career and turning him into the legend he became. Riddle is the creator of the “Rat Pack” sound, composing scores for Robin and the Seven Hoods and Ocean’s 11 among dozens of other films. He won an Oscar for the score of 1974’s The Great Gatsby in addition to 3 Grammy awards, two of them for his album collaborations with Linda Ronstadt that revived his extraordinary career shortly before his death in 1985. It’s hard to overestimate his importance to American popular music.