Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA Is Here With A Striking Cast And Glittering Production

Review: THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA Is Here With A Striking Cast And Glittering Production

It's one of the most well-known musicals, but THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA continues to surprise, featuring a stellar cast, design, and dozens of special effects that all add up to a massive spectacle of a show.

Presented by Mirvish, Cameron Mackintosh's production of Andrew Lloyd Webber's THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA makes its return to Toronto. Set in the Paris Opera House in the 1870s, the story is centered on the opera house's Phantom (Derrick Davis), a genius who lives below the theatre and wears a mask to conceal a facial deformity, and his twisted love for dancer-turned-singer Christine Daaé (Emma Grimsley) who ends up falling for her childhood sweetheart Raoul (Jordan Craig) instead.

It's a classic love triangle set to some of the most well-known music in the musical theatre catalogue, and this cast delivers exceptional performances that don't just sell their characters, but the world as well. As the titular Phantom, Davis is a complete scene-stealer - his rich voice and expressive acting don't hide the atrocities that the character commits, but he manages to make a deeply flawed character extremely sympathetic. Grimsley makes Christine a true heroine, forced into difficult circumstances but with a desire - and willingness - to maintain her own morals throughout. Craig is a sturdy Raoul, serving as the voice of reason with just enough edge to make the darker aspects of the character work.

The supporting cast are just as evenly matched, with ballet master Madame Giry (Susan Moniz) balancing the new and comically out-of-their-depth opera house owners Monsieurs Firmin (David Benoit) and André (Rob Lindley), both of whom land the few jokes in the story with perfect timing and chemistry. Prima donna Carlotta (Trista Moldovan) is a classic mean-girl antagonist, and her impressive range only makes her catty attitude that much more hilarious against her tenor husband Piangi's (Phumzile Sojola) easygoing nature.

THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA's touring production features static and local musicians in its orchestra and is conducted by Jamie Johns. Despite its smaller size, Webber's score booms through the theatre. Not only can the sweeping strings and intimidating organs be heard, but they can be felt, too.

Right down to the smallest details, PHANTOM is nothing short of spectacular. Something as simple as having stagehands don costumes and operate in plain sight makes it even more immersive - after all, the story takes place in a theatre, and director Laurence Connor leans into the meta-ness of it all wonderfully. This PHANTOM wisely maintains the original Broadway production's lavish costume design (Maria Björnson), and the elaborate set (Paul Brown) shifts between the opera house stage, complete with boxes on the sides, and a massive cylindrical piece that houses several locations within the theatre. Lighting (Paule Constable) and projection (Nina Dunn) create gorgeous silhouettes off the sets' many angles and manage to convey several settings with ease, from a brightly lit stage to a dark, damp underground lair.

While there are plenty of chances taken in terms of creativity, THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA sees a great return on all of them. Its innovative approach to live theatre, and a cast that maintains a relentless pace, ensures a spectacle from the moment the organs blare and the chandelier rises right through to curtain call.


Mirvish's THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA runs through February 2 at the Princess of Wales Theatre, 300 King Street West, Toronto, ON.

For more information or to purchase tickets, visit https://www.mirvish.com/shows/the-phantom-of-the-opera-2020

Photo credit: Matthew Murphy




From This Author - Isabella Perrone

Isabella Perrone is a writer with a love for musicals and theatre that goes all the way back to her childhood. Born and raised in St. Catharines, ON, she would blast Broadway cast albums at home on... (read more about this author)


Review: & JULIET is an Empowering Celebration of Life, Love, and the Freedom to Be YourselfReview: & JULIET is an Empowering Celebration of Life, Love, and the Freedom to Be Yourself
July 10, 2022

Gone are the days where Juliet is a tragic, gone-to-soon character in a Shakespeare play; she’s given a new lease on life in a new musical, with a diverse cast of characters and enough pop power anthems to have audiences dancing in their seats, no matter their age.

Review: HARRY POTTER AND THE CURSED CHILD Bewitches In Canadian PremiereReview: HARRY POTTER AND THE CURSED CHILD Bewitches In Canadian Premiere
June 20, 2022

Mirvish has brought a truly spellbinding production to the CAA Ed Mirvish Theatre this season. After over two years sitting empty, the theatre was packed on an opening weekend showing of the latest show in their 2022 season: the Canadian premiere of HARRY POTTER AND THE CURSED CHILD.

BWW Review: SWAN LAKE Soars in New National Ballet of Canada ProductionBWW Review: SWAN LAKE Soars in New National Ballet of Canada Production
June 14, 2022

It’s been nearly two years since the National Ballet of Canada had planned on premiering their new SWAN LAKE, but in this case late is definitely better than never. The stunning new production, directed by former Artistic Director Karen Kain, has finally arrived on the Four Seasons Centre’s stage.  

BWW Review: THE MAGIC FLUTE makes a triumphant return to TorontoBWW Review: THE MAGIC FLUTE makes a triumphant return to Toronto
May 9, 2022

If you’ve ever wanted to experience Mozart’s work live, there’s no time like the present to do so in Toronto. The Canadian Opera Company has brought their acclaimed production of THE MAGIC FLUTE back - delayed after a few years of theatre shut-downs, but better late than never in the case of this fantastical, funny, and thought-provoking story.

BWW Review: LA TRAVIATA's Powerhouse Cast and Crew Provide a Timeless, Stunning Production of The Verdi Classic at the Canadian Opera CompanyBWW Review: LA TRAVIATA's Powerhouse Cast and Crew Provide a Timeless, Stunning Production of The Verdi Classic at the Canadian Opera Company
April 27, 2022

The Canadian Opera Company marked its return-to-stage after nearly two years with this all-around stunning production of one of Verdi’s most well-known works. Clocking in at just shy of three hours, the four-act opera tells the tale of Parisian courtesan Violetta (Amina Edris, making her COC debut) and her lover Alfredo (Matthew Polenzani).