Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Play Ball with DAMN YANKEES at MPAC

Review: Play Ball with DAMN YANKEES at MPAC

Spring is in the air which means the start of baseball season. Baseball is my all-time favorite sport. While many say it is boring, there is such a passion and purity to the American Pastime that its enjoyment and place in our culture cannot be ignored. So, when you take my favorite sport and combine it with my love of theatre, well there is the show I want to see. "Damn Yankees" at Manatee Performing Arts Center opened Thursday night and is sure to have that rare breed who love both sports and theatre in "Heaven."

The musical is based on the novel "The Year the Yankees Lost the Pennant." With a book by George Abbott and music and lyrics by Richard Adler and Jerry Ross "Damn Yankees" is a modern retelling of the Faust legend set during the 1950s in Washington, D.C., during a time when the New York Yankees dominated Major League Baseball. Long-time baseball and Pittsburgh Pirates lover, Joe Boyd makes a deal with the "Devil" (Applegate) and is transformed into Joe Hardy who is destined to become the greatest baseball player of all-time. Joe is on a mission to beat those "Damn Yankees" and help his beloved Pirates win the Pennant. Of course, any deal with devil has consequences and Joe must battle the trek of life choices as he searches to find true happiness both in and out of baseball.

The musical begins in true baseball fashion as the audience stands for the National Anthem. Each night the theatre will have a different guest singer and on Opening Night, Stephanie Roberts from ABC7 Suncoast View got the game (I mean musical) started. The show had several cute, integrated sports features including singing "Take Me Out to the Ball Game" during intermission.

Director Cory Boyas has assembled a wonderful cast that is full of talent and immense energy. The numbers are engaging and he has molded his characters to tell a story with a message that is clearly delivered. I was especially impressed with the comradery of the cast. They made choices and delivered those choices without compromise. This allowed for unmistakable chemistry on stage which is a credit to Boyas and his team. The music was at times a little weak especially in the group numbers, but I anticipate this area will strengthen as the run continues.

Joey Panek (who you have most likely seen on ABC7 Suncoast View) plays Joe Hardy. That incredible personality that we see on TV transferred perfectly to the stage and there was no question why he was a professional actor for many years. From the first note he sings, your expectations are immediately raised to a new level as you begin to wrap your brain around the quality performance you are about to witness. Panel is dynamic in every sense of the word. He is bold when he has to be and can do a complete 180 degrees when the role calls for his weaknesses to be shown. Panek adds a spark that is filtered to his entire cast which is paramount for this role. His character has many layers and he does a magnificent job of carefully pulling back each one of those layers for the audience to see.

The role of Applegate is played by Kevin Steele. If I hadn't looked at his bio, I would never have known he played Bert in MPAC's "Mary Poppins" last year. This is a true credit to Steele and his ability to play two vastly different characters. There was a flare every time he stepped on the stage. As the "villain" it is easy to be hated, but in this case, you will love him at every turn. Steele is simply hilarious and adds a dimension to Applegate I had not seen previously. At one point, the audience actually started cheering for him (rare for a villain). Steele wraps you into his evil web of destruction and is polarizing as he navigates through his plan of destruction.

Kathryn Parks plays Lola, a fellow villain, who ends up changing her wicked ways when she experiences the love and true heart of Joe Hardy. Parks displays crisp and solid vocals throughout the show in addition to a few eccentric dance moves. She carefully shows the heart of her character as you see the transformation of her beliefs and desires. Like most changes with one's character, it is a process and Parks does a nice job in not rushing the process and allowing the audience to experience the change she is undergoing.

Ellen Kleinschmidt and Ric Stroup are precious as Joe and Meg Boyd. They have a sweet bond on stage that makes you smile. Victoria Gross (Sister) and Sami Blouin (Doris) add comedic relief throughout the performance. Dave Springer (Van Buren), Tanner Fultz (Eddie) and the entire ensemble of Pirate's Players all deliver noteworthy performances and give the audience true moments of laughter.

"Damn Yankees" lacks a bit of flow at times but the characters keep the laughs coming. The start of baseball season is still a month away. Lucky for you "Damn Yankees" will allow you to get a head start on the season and even better, provide you with a memorable theatrical experience.

"Damn Yankees" runs through March 8th at Manatee Performing Arts Center. Tickets and more information can be found at

Sarasota Jewish Theatre Announces Change To 2023 Season Lineup Photo
Sarasota Jewish Theatre announces a change in one of its upcoming plays this season. Due to a scheduling conflict, Family Secrets by Sherry Glaser will replace Collected Stories, on March 22-27, 2023.

The Beach Boys Return To The Van Wezel in February Photo
The Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall will welcome THE BEACH BOYS to Sarasota on Tuesday, February 21, 2023 at 7:30 p.m. Tickets on sale Friday at 10 a.m.

Sarasota Orchestra Receives Grant From Barancik Foundation Photo
Sarasota Orchestra has been awarded a ­­­­­$65,000 grant from Charles & Margery Barancik Foundation to bolster the programming of the 2022-2023 season. Sarasota Orchestra's mission is to engage, educate and enrich the community through high-quality, live musical experiences.

Florida Studio Theatre Extends Production of SOMETHING ROTTEN! Photo
Florida Studio Theatre has announced the extension of its opening Winter Mainstage production, Something Rotten!, which is now held over through Sunday, January 8, 2023, in FST's Gompertz Theatre. 

From This Author - Jacob Ruscoe

Dr. Jacob Ruscoe has been involved with local theatre in Sarasota for the last several decades. Jacob has spent time serving on the Board of Directors for Virtuoso Inc and Rise Above Performing Art... (read more about this author)

Review: THE BURDENS at Urbanite TheatreReview: THE BURDENS at Urbanite Theatre
November 9, 2022

“The Burdens” should not be missed. If you love to text message, (and who doesn’t) this is the show for you.

Review: LET IT BE at Players Centre For The Performing ArtsReview: LET IT BE at Players Centre For The Performing Arts
August 25, 2022

Let It Be is a great way to experience the classic songs of the Beatles! The Players Centre for the Performing Arts is continuing its 92nd season with the concert revue style musical, 'Let It Be.' Director, Sunny Smith, notes that the musical is 'the journey of Beatles songs through the turmoil of war and loss in the 60's, and the battle of holding on to your family and trying to find yourself.'

BWW Review: A SKEPTIC AND A BRUJA  at Urbanite Theatre a Haunting ExperienceBWW Review: A SKEPTIC AND A BRUJA at Urbanite Theatre a Haunting Experience
April 12, 2022

In a deviation from your typical theatrical experience, may I present you Urbanite Theatre’s World Premiere of “A Skeptic and a Bruja.” Much to its title premise, this new work takes you on a paranormal journey.

BWW Review: THE LAST FIVE YEARS at Venice Theatre Provides Raw EmotionBWW Review: THE LAST FIVE YEARS at Venice Theatre Provides Raw Emotion
March 29, 2022

Some shows get away from all the glitz and glamour and just tell a story. There are times where musical theatre transcends the fancy costume and strobe lights; a place where the big numbers wait for another time. What we are left during those moments is something raw and powerful. What we have is “The Last Five Years.”

BWW Review: THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG at Florida Studio Theatre is Comedic PerfectionBWW Review: THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG at Florida Studio Theatre is Comedic Perfection
March 6, 2022

By nature, musicals are vastly more popular than plays. They have a natural ability to engage an audience and if there are any lulls in the action, you have a high-flying musical number to bring the show back to life. A play has no safety nets. The actors must be dynamic and make genuine connections in order for thee beauty of a show to be felt.