My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Photos: AND THEN WE WERE NO MORE At La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club

The new drama from Tim Blake Nelson opens this Sunday, September 28.

By:
Powered by Ticketmaster
Get Show Info Info
Get Tickets
Cast
Photos
Videos

And Then We Were No More, a new play written by Tim Blake Nelson (The Public's Socrates, MCC Theater's The Grey Zone), currently playing at La MaMa (66 E. 4th Street), opens this Sunday, September 28. Check out new production photos below.

Directed by Mark Wing-Davey (The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy; Caryl Churchill's Mad Forest [Obie Award for Direction]; Caryl Churchill’s The Skriker), the off-Broadway production is produced by La MaMa and Carol Ostrow of Stop The Wind Theatricals.

In the not-too-distant future a lawyer is forced to represent a prisoner deemed ‘beyond rehabilitation’ and destined to perish in a newly developed machine designed to execute ‘without pain.’ The attorney must strive for justice in a system devoid of mercy.

The cast of And Then We Were No More features Elizabeth Marvel (Broadway: King Lear, Other Desert Cities; Long Day’s Journey Into Night; House of Cards; Homeland), Scott Shepherd (Ulysses, Bridge of Spies), Jennifer Mogbock (Half-God of Rainfall; Merry Wives), Henry Stram (Titanic, The Elephant Man), Elizabeth Yeoman (Airtime; The Children’s Hour), William Appiah (Fences; Hamlet), E.J. An (A Dream of Red Pavilions; Clubhouse), Kasey Connolly (Four Women Entering Paradise; FBI), and Craig Wesley Divino (London Assurance; Round Table).

And Then We Were No More features scenic design by David Meyer (A Sucker Emcee; Hedwig…), lighting design by Reza Behjat (English; Wish You Were Here), costume design by Marina Draghici (Tony® Award Winner – Fela!; Mother Courage), and sound design by Henry Nelson and Will Curry (Asleep In My Palm, the band Early Worm).

“I am honored to present my play with Carol Ostrow at La MaMa, a New York institution I have long admired for its willingness to stage challenging, boundary-pushing new works for the American theater," said playwright Tim Blake Nelson. “My favorite plays and productions provoke, in a smart but visceral way, tough conversations about the world in which we live. My hope is that New York audiences will find some of that in what we’re up to with this piece."

"When I read Tim's urgent and remarkable new play, I knew I wanted to bring this story to the stage, and La MaMa is the perfect partner and venue to do so,” said producer Carol Ostrow. “And Then We Were No More invites audiences to grapple with thorny questions we are often too afraid to ask. I couldn’t be more excited to work with Tim and the entire creative team on this prescient, thought-provoking work.”

And Then We Were No More plays La MaMa (66 E. 4th Street). Performances are Tuesday - Saturday evenings at 7PM, with matinees on Saturday and Sunday at 2PM. Tickets begin at $49.00 and are available now .

Photo Credit: Bronwen Sharp


Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Orchestrations - Top 3
1. Ethan Popp, The Rescues - The Lost Boys
30.5% of votes
2. Lux Pyramid - Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
14.8% of votes
3. Anders Eljas, Brian Usifer - Chess
12.1% of votes

Don't Miss a Off-Broadway News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
Spirit of the Game: The Ultimate Musical in Off-Broadway Spirit of the Game: The Ultimate Musical
Asylum NYC (5/14-5/17)
WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND | Stage & Film Summer Season at Bardavon in Off-Broadway WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND | Stage & Film Summer Season at Bardavon
Bardavon 1869 Opera House (7/31-7/31)
UNMOORED | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University in Off-Broadway UNMOORED | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University
Marist University Symphonic Hall (7/12-7/12)
LA CASA DE BERNARDA ALBA in Off-Broadway LA CASA DE BERNARDA ALBA
Repertorio (11/15-12/31)
PAPER MENAGERIE | Stage & Film Summer Season at the Bardavon in Off-Broadway PAPER MENAGERIE | Stage & Film Summer Season at the Bardavon
Bardavon 1869 Opera House (7/19-7/19)
New Owner in Off-Broadway New Owner
New Victory Theater (5/09-5/17)
LAGNIAPPE | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University in Off-Broadway LAGNIAPPE | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University
Marist University Symphonic Hall (7/11-7/11)
Once Upon A Mattress in Off-Broadway Once Upon A Mattress
Gremlin Theatre (5/14-5/24)
THE DEATH CHRONICLES (portraits)|S&F Summer Season at Marist in Off-Broadway THE DEATH CHRONICLES (portraits)|S&F Summer Season at Marist
Marist University Symphonic Hall (8/01-8/01)
MENAFEE | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University in Off-Broadway MENAFEE | Stage & Film Summer Season at Marist University
Marist University Symphonic Hall (7/25-7/25)


Videos