Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

BORROWED BABIES World Premiere is Coming to American Lives Theatre

The production features an ensemble of eight local women, led by Jennifer Johansen.

By:
BORROWED BABIES World Premiere is Coming to American Lives Theatre

American Lives Theatre will present the World Premiere of Borrowed Babies by acclaimed playwright Jennifer Blackmer. Running from February 5 through February 22 at The Phoenix Theatre Cultural Centre, this provocative new drama uncovers the real-world historical practice of "practice babies" - infants "borrowed" from orphanages for use in collegiate Home Economics "Practice Houses."

As part of ALT's sixth season, "Our American Legacy," Borrowed Babies marks a reunion for the creative powerhouse team behind the 2023 ALT hit Predictor, which recently concluded a successful Off-Broadway run. Bridget Haight returns to direct this fictionalized account that examines the complexities of feminism, the commodification of care, and the evolving roles of women in mid-century America.

In Blackmer's script, we follow Home Economics teacher Judy London (played by Jennifer Johansen) as she navigates the rigid expectations of midcentury American with the feminist opportunities of the ensuing decades. 

The production features an ensemble of eight local women, led by Jennifer Johansen. Known for her nuanced portrayals of modern femininity in productions like Gloria: A Life (where she played Gloria Steinem) and The Pill by Tom Horan, Johansen brings a sophisticated depth to the role of Judy London.

The cast also includes Lauren Briggeman, Julie Dixon, Carmia Imani, Rachel Ivie, Sarah Powell, Hannah Luciani, Dorian Underwood.

On Sun, Feb 15, ALT will host a post-show talkback featuring playwright Jennifer Blackmer and author Jill Christman. Christman, who wrote a definitive nonfiction account of the practice, joins Blackmer to discuss their shared research and the discoveries they made while investigating their home institution, Ball State University, where they both currently teach. This conversation will bridge the gap between historical fact and theatrical fiction.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Phoenix Theatre Cultural Centre
Recent Articles
Review: EVERYBODY'S FAVORITE MOTHER at Phoenix Theatre
Review: EVERYBODY'S FAVORITE MOTHER at Phoenix Theatre
9/8/2026


BroadwayWorld TV


Memphis The Musical in Indianapolis Memphis The Musical
Basile Theatre at the Historic Athenaeum (9/26-9/27) PHOTOS
Dionne Warwick: Over and Out – A Farewell Tour in Indianapolis Dionne Warwick: Over and Out – A Farewell Tour
Payne & Mencias Palladium (3/20-3/20)
Always... Patsy Cline in Indianapolis Always... Patsy Cline
Fort Wayne Civic Theatre (3/13-3/28)
Frank Basile's If These Walls Could Tell: Ben Hur Building featuring Jos Holman in Indianapolis Frank Basile's If These Walls Could Tell: Ben Hur Building featuring Jos Holman
Storytelling Arts of Indiana (3/21-3/21)
Mojo & Jimmy: The Totally Awesome Magic Show in Indianapolis Mojo & Jimmy: The Totally Awesome Magic Show
Waldron Arts Center (3/26-4/11)
A Blue Ridge Christmas featuring Michael Reno Harrell and Josh Goforth in Indianapolis A Blue Ridge Christmas featuring Michael Reno Harrell and Josh Goforth
Storytelling Arts of Indiana (12/05-12/05)
An Evening with Victoria Clark: Songs and Stories from a Not-So-Brief Career in the Theater in Indianapolis An Evening with Victoria Clark: Songs and Stories from a Not-So-Brief Career in the Theater
Payne & Mencias Palladium (3/12-3/12)
The Wiz in Indianapolis The Wiz
Indiana University (1/27-1/27)
An Evening with Bernadette Peters in Indianapolis An Evening with Bernadette Peters
Payne & Mencias Palladium (11/13-11/13)
The ConstelLate Show: Holiday Special in Indianapolis The ConstelLate Show: Holiday Special
Waldron Firebay (12/17-12/27)