Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Weathervane Not Afraid of Finding Alternate Ways to Pay RENT

Photo by Chad DiBlasio

How do you write a song when the chords sound wrong
Though they once sounded right and rare?
When the notes are sour
Where is the power you once had to ignite the air?

-- "Rent" from RENT

When it first came out in 1996, Jonathan Larson's RENT took Broadway by storm because its rock score, gritty characters and edgy lyrics made it sound anything but typical.

It's hard to believe that is close to being 20 years ago. The challenge the Weathervane Playhouse (100 Price Street in Newark, Ohio) faced in bringing back the musical is the audience's familiarity with RENT has worn down some of the show's rough edges. RENT opened June 4 and will run through June 13.

Director Adam Karsten, however, tweaked his theatre's performance just enough to give a new feel to the show without losing its original power.

RENT, which won the Pulitzer Prize and four Tony Awards when it was first released in 1996, follows the year in the lives of a handful of starving artists living in the squalor of New York City's East Side.

Struggling filmmaker Mark Cohen (played by Layne Roate) documents the lives of his roommate Roger Davis (Joe Essig), a once-promising rock front man who has been diagnosed with AIDS, and a host of eclectic friends trying to survive. Davis and Cohen live in a dilapidated building owned by Benjamin Coffin III (E.J. King), who plans on turning the building to a cyber-arts studio. The friction among his friends and the environment around their building provides Cohen with a vast plethora of material with which to work.

Roate and Essig provide a strong punch-counter punch vocally for the two's confrontations like "Tune Up A" and "What You Own." In a nice Weathervane touch, Essig plays Roger with more bravado. He occasionally flips over chairs and sofas and the overturned furniture becomes part of the set design in the next scene.

RENT needs several strong characters to fill out the dimensions of the story. Weathervane has put together a solid cast with strong performers in the roles of Tom Collins (William Tipton), Mimi (Tori Palin), and Angel (Kirk Lydell). Tipton's achingly powerful reprise of "I'll Cover You" is one of the top individual performances of the show. The strained relationship between Maureen Johnson (Katrina Colletti) and Joanne Jefferson (Iris Beaumier) comes off beautifully in songs like "Take Me Or Leave Me." Colletti's over the top "Over the Moon" and Beaumier and Roate's "Tango Maureen" are among the show's highlights.

However at its core, RENT is only as strong as depth. The cast numbers "Seasons of Love," "Will I" and "Goodbye Love" are the support beams of the two act musical. If they don't hold together, the show collapses. The supporting cast of Travis Burch, Emily Crawford, Kaitlin Descutner, Brendan Henderson, Nick McQuillen, Kerbie Minor, Josh Schirtzinger and Kayla Walsh and the band of keyboardists Kevin Wines, Tony Richardson and Brian Naille, guitarist Benson Anderson, bassist Cole Rumora and drummer William Blount provide the robust foundation for the show.

Karsten also adds some new touches to the show, changing up "Contact" and "Your Eyes," with the latter shocking RENT purists. The performances should draw in those who have never seen the show and the added twists should bring back those who have seen RENT before.

Weathervane Playhouse presents RENT 8 p.m. June 5-6 and 9-13 with a 2 p.m. matinee June 6. Call 740-366-4616 for information.

From This Author - Paul Batterson

Review: ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide ArenaReview: ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide Arena
August 15, 2022

What did our critic think of ROGER WATERS' THIS IS NOT A DRILL at Nationwide Arena? A little mini drama took place at the will call window moments before Roger Waters was scheduled to take the stage for his 'This is not a drill' concert on Aug. 10 at Nationwide Arena (200 West Nationwide Boulevard in downtown Columbus). A mother and son were trying to straighten out a ticket purchase and she repeatedly asked her son, 'Do you really want to see this? Do you really want to see this?'

July 14, 2022

What did our critic think of BWW REVIEWS: OTTERBEIN’S PIRATES OF PENZANCE at Cowen Hall? Otterbein University offers a much-needed refresher course in Gilbert and Sullivan with its presentation of THE PIRATES OF PENZANCE for its final production of the summer season. The two-act comedic musical closes this week with shows on July 14-16 at Cowan Hall (30 S. Grove Street in Westerville). Directed by Lenny Leibowitz and produced by T.J. Gerckens, the show features a whimsical plot with outlandish lyrics, outstanding performances, and spectacular costuming and music orchestration.

BWW Review: SPRING AWAKENING  at Garden TheaterBWW Review: SPRING AWAKENING at Garden Theater
May 19, 2022

It has been over 130 years since German playwright Frank Wedekind first published SPRING AWAKENING. In 2006, the play was reinvented when Duncan Sheik and Steven Sater turned it into a musical.

BWW Review: AJR at Value City ArenaBWW Review: AJR at Value City Arena
May 16, 2022

At AJR's May 13 concert at Value City Arena, Jack Met estimated he and his brothers Ryan and Adam Brett have played Columbus the second most out of any city behind their native home, New York City.

BWW Interview: It's Not Easy Being Green for WICKED's Deguzman at Ohio TheaterBWW Interview: It's Not Easy Being Green for WICKED's Deguzman at Ohio Theater
May 12, 2022

Some nights Lissa deGuzman (who plays Elphaba in the national tour of WICKED) and Jennafer Newberry (who plays Glinda) walk out of a theater together and run into a throng of fans of the 2003 musical.