Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: Jeff Harnar's SAMMY CAHN THE SECOND TIME AROUND Delights at 54 Below

The king of cabaret honored Sammy Cahn in celebration of his latest album

By:
Review: Jeff Harnar's SAMMY CAHN THE SECOND TIME AROUND Delights at 54 Below

On Saturday July 27th, Jeff Harnar entered the stage singing the sweet lyrics of Sammy Cahn. That lyricist was the subject both of that night’s tribute show, and of Harnar’s new album, aptly titled Sammy Cahn: The Second Time Around. Harnar is one of New York’s finest cabaret singers, approaching songs with a subtlety and nuance of expression that allows them to shine. Harnar picked some choice Cahn favorites to sing at the July 27th show, showcasing the work of a masterful lyricist and interspersing the songs with theater history and personal stories. Harnar's ability to connect with his audience and place himself squarely in the mindset of each song's point of view is a delight to behold.

The night was celebrating the release of Harnar’s new Cahn album, which is a re-recording and re-imagining of an older, now out of print album. The album features some of the same songs plus a few new tracks. This time, Harnar recorded with over 20 years more experience and “the correct pronouns,” he reported to laughs from the audience at 54 Below, waggling his eyebrows suggestively. “I’ll Only Miss Her When I Think of Her” from Skyscraper is now “I’ll Only Miss Him When I Think of Him,” for example, a move that makes the song more personal to Harnar. (For more about the process of putting together the album re-recording project, read a Q&A with Harnar.)

The appreciative audience listened to Harnar’s spin on a number of Cahn classics, from a boppy version of “Teach Me Tonight” sung with an infectious smile to a medley from Skyscraper.  Harnar has impeccable comedic delivery; he sang “Everybody Has The Right To Be Wrong (At Least Once)”, moving from the very funny verse to the silky smooth refrain, originally sung by Peter Marshall. Harnar imbued each repetition of “I’m in Love” with variation and nuance in Cahn’s “I'm In Love” (from Romance On the High Seas). Harnar has a few special guests on the album, all of whom were in attendance at the Saturday night show: Clint Holmes, MOIPEl and Grammy winner Nicole Zuraitis. Harnar and Holmes sang a spirited mashup of “Come Dance with Me” (Harnar) and “I Like to Lead When I Dance” (Holmes). After once through a traditional rendition of each song, the pair switched solo parts, singing in counterpoint, and having fun changing up the arrangements. Each of Harnar’s guests is a vocal powerhouse in their own right. On a duet of “Come Fly With Me” with Harnar, Nicole Zuraitis scatted and twisted the lyrics wonderfully, bringing a new perspective to one of Cahn’s most well known classics. MOPEI (a group composed of identical triplets Mary, Maggy and Marta Moipei) dueted with Harnar on a “Bei Mir Bistu Shein” with arrangements influenced by their Kenyan roots and some of the original lyrics translated into another language (I believe French, if I’m not mistaken). Even Alex Rybeck, Harnar’s music director and dutiful companion on the piano all evening, got a duet in, singing across from Harnar on “Opposites” from Skyscraper, another very funny number.

The entire show was a delightful escape into another era of music performed by a master and his very talented friends. As an aside, I watched the show via livestream, a very pleasant experience with multiple camera angles providing views of the entire room at 54 Below and making me feel just like I was there. In a chat displayed alongside the video, some fellow livestream viewers shared their locations and appreciation for the livestream allowing them to dip into the club despite not being in NYC.

The show was directed by Barry Kleinbort, with Music Director Alex Rybeck. The band featured Steve Doyle on bass, Ray Marchica on drums, Marc Phaneuf on sax and flute, and Alex Rybeck on piano


Harnar’s album is available now from PS Classics.

Header photo credit: Conor Weiss. (See his full set of photos from the July 26th show here.)

Find more upcoming shows at 54 Below on their website.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on 54 Below
Upcoming Shows
54 Holds Space: For Good
54 Holds Space: For Good
8/7 - 8/7/2026
Casey Likes: Back To The Past
Casey Likes: Back To The Past
8/7 - 8/7/2026
Recent Articles
Review: Christine Andreas Soars in S'WONDERFUL at 54 Below
Review: Christine Andreas Soars in S'WONDERFUL at 54 Below
8/7/2026
Isaac Mizrahi and More Set for 54 Below Lineup Next Week
Isaac Mizrahi and More Set for 54 Below Lineup Next Week
8/7/2026

Reader Reviews

Need more Cabaret Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne in Cabaret Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne
54 Below (8/23-8/23) PHOTOS VIDEOS
DiGangi With A “G” in Cabaret DiGangi With A “G”
The Green Room 42 (8/18-8/18) PHOTOS
Broadway Sin Vergüenza: Telenovela Nights in Cabaret Broadway Sin Vergüenza: Telenovela Nights
54 Below (10/15-10/15)
Orfeh: Unbound in Cabaret Orfeh: Unbound
54 Below (9/26-9/26)
Raise Our Voices: A Cabaret for Cecilia Chorus in Cabaret Raise Our Voices: A Cabaret for Cecilia Chorus
54 Below (10/14-10/14)
Tiano: The Tenor & Piano Duo in Cabaret Tiano: The Tenor & Piano Duo
54 Below (8/21-8/21)
54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits! in Cabaret 54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits!
54 Below (11/28-11/28)
Jack Roden: My Days in Cabaret Jack Roden: My Days
54 Below (8/10-8/10)
Migguel Anggelo: ICONS – Latin Rhythms in Cabaret Migguel Anggelo: ICONS – Latin Rhythms
Joe's Pub (10/21-10/21)
KID OF NEW YORK in Cabaret KID OF NEW YORK
54 Below (9/25-9/25)