Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE MILK TRAIN DOESN'T STOP HERE ANYMORE, Charing Cross Theatre

Tennessee Williams' play that reveals his younger genius, but only in contrast to this pedestrian later work

Review: THE MILK TRAIN DOESN'T STOP HERE ANYMORE, Charing Cross Theatre Review: THE MILK TRAIN DOESN'T STOP HERE ANYMORE, Charing Cross Theatre Mrs Goforth is - wouldn't you know it? - a fading Southern Belle whose has worked her way up from provincial teenage showgirl, via four husbands, to a villa above Amalfi looking across the Bay of Naples towards Capri. There she drinks cocktails and scoffs codeine while berating the staff, bitching about her 'friends' and dictating her 'Kiss-And-Tell' memoirs - all with delusions of grandeur, afloat on a sea of inherited wealth. When a young man, a poet no less, turns up having narrowly evaded a mauling from her dogs, her comfortable balloon of boredom is pricked - but it turns out that the mysterious gentleman has a record of visiting ageing wealthy women just before their demise.

This is a rarely performed Tennessee Williams' play that flopped on Broadway in 1962 and then, re-written, flopped again a couple of years later. It's not hard to see why.

The tension between characters founded on that glorious dialogue that Williams could conjure almost at will (or so it appeared) in his earlier years, is absent, replaced by plodding speeches in which people announce their antipathy towards each other and their disappointments in life. There's a nod to the Japanese influence that Williams wanted to bring to his play in Rocco Vena's costumes, but director, Robert Chevara, never quite commits to the form, so it feels like the production is cosplaying Kabuki as much as the characters. They're never quite real enough to be real (as t'were) nor symbolic enough to be symbolic.

The support cast (looser, funnier, harsher) have a lot of fun. Lucie Shorthouse's PA, Blackie (berated for her Vassar Girl style in a rare moment of genuine biting wit that propmpted a much needed eye roll) gets to be impatient and efficient, Joe Ferrera is thuggishly out for number one as bodyguard Rudy and Matteo Johnson is Giulio, the pool boy with no pool.

The issues come more with the leads. Sara Kestelman fares best as the Witch of Capri, a visiting friend -also of a certain age - whose sardonic remarks spice up a love-hate relationship that gets her through the day (Giulio does his bit to get her through the night). It's always a disappointment when she leaves the stage - the play needs more of the Witch!

The two leads never really get going. Linda Marlowe gives her Flora Goforth a glamour now receding swiftly into the rear view mirror, but, too often, her observations are tedious and dull rather than suggestive of a woman who is living in the past because it was a great place to spend time. Sanee Raval looks the part as a beatnikish poet, but he speaks in riddles and never acquires the seductive sheen that an Angel of Death surely requires. Chemistry is there none.

The play may appeal to fans of Williams who will seize the chance to tick off a play from his canon, but this fan of Williams was mainly reminded of just how good so many of his other works are. There's room for improvement in the performances - there was certainly a bit of polishing still to be done on press night - but it's hard to see how this script can produce anything beyond a curio that captures Williams' obsessions, but not his genius.

The Milk Train Doesn't Stop Here Anymore is at the Charing Cross Theatre until 22 October

Photo Credit: Nick Haeffner




From This Author - Gary Naylor

Gary Naylor is chief London reviewer for BroadwayWorld (https://www.broadwayworld.com/author/Gary-Naylor) and feels privileged to... (read more about this author)


Review: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE, London ColiseumReview: IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE, London Coliseum
November 27, 2022

Opera based on much loved 1946 film offers a vision of a town without music, without joy, without love and, in doing so, compels us to value what we have - a moral shared by everyone in the house, but not outside it.

Review: ROALD DAHL'S MATILDA THE MUSICAL, UK cinemasReview: ROALD DAHL'S MATILDA THE MUSICAL, UK cinemas
November 25, 2022

Super fun for 7 year-olds to 77 year-olds with all that stage magic up there on the screen

Review: A SHERLOCK CAROL, Marylebone TheatreReview: A SHERLOCK CAROL, Marylebone Theatre
November 24, 2022

Super fun for Christmas with two of the world's most loved Victorian characters together at last

Review: DINNER WITH GROUCHO, Arcola TheatreReview: DINNER WITH GROUCHO, Arcola Theatre
November 22, 2022

Frank McGuinness's new play puts two giants of 20th century culture together but fails to ignite a spark between them

Review: THE CRITIC, The Calder Bookshop and TheatreReview: THE CRITIC, The Calder Bookshop and Theatre
November 21, 2022

John Hill's play touches on a range of interesting themes, but its narrative meanders and its tension falls away