Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: A MIDNIGHT DREARY at We Happy Few

Through November 22 at the Capitol Hill Arts Workshop

By:
Review: A MIDNIGHT DREARY at We Happy Few

I watched the first Simpsons "Treehouse of Horror" episode when it first aired on October 25, 1990, when I was eight years old. This was my introduction to Edgar Allan Poe's immortal poem "The Raven," which I suspect is true of many of my generation. I've loved it ever since, and to this day, whenever I read it, I can't help but hear James Earl Jones' thundering narration interspersed with Dan Castellaneta voicing the words of the poem's speaker as Homer-"D'oh! Be that word our sign of parting, bird or fiend..." 35 years later, I'm a college English professor, and just last Thursday led my class in a discussion of the poem. Because, as I told my students, when it's All Hallows Eve Eve, we're starting the poetry unit, and we're in Maryland, what other poem can we focus on?

I further celebrated my "Poe-versary"  by attending We Happy Few's new production, which invites the audience into an immersive visit to Poe's dark, Gothic world. The audience is invited to pour themselves a sherry or Amontillado in the lobby of the Capitol Hill Arts Workshop, then three actors all dressed as Poe lead them into the theater, ornately designed by Jon Reynolds and eerily lit by Jason Aufdem-Brinke. Over the course of an hour the three Poe actors then perform unique interpretations of three of Poe's most famous works. First, in "The Masque of the Red Death,"  we are in Prince Prospero's abbey as he hosts his masquerade ball and a silent, menacing, uninvited guest arrives. Next, in "A Cask of Amontillado," which my students read earlier in the semester, Montresor beckons the audience to follow him into the catacombs where he tricks and traps Fortunato. The third and, in my opinion, most harrowing segment is "The Tell-Tale Heart," in which the unnamed narrator pulls us along on his tale of meticulous murder preparation, madness, and eventual confession.  The production ends with an abridged reading of "The Raven."

As I discussed with my students, it is easy to see Poe's unhappy life and times reflected in his work. Orphaned at a young age, he struggled with alcoholism and compulsive gambling. His beloved wife Virginia died in 1847 and his own life would end at age 40 two years later under mysterious circumstances. Having Poe look-alikes perform these stories gives us the impression of observing the author's tortured thought processes as he channels these painful experiences into his famous tales of insanity, isolation, and horror.

Director Esteban Marmolejo-Suarez achieves compelling synergy among his enesmble. The play is performed by two trios of actors on alternating nights. On the night I attended, it was performed by the "A cast," consisting of  Rachel Dixon, Victor Salinas, and Paige O'Malley (who also serves as Costume Designer.)  "B cast" consists of Em German, Andrew Quilpa, and Gill Rydholm.

"A Midnight Dreary" will appeal to Poe aficionados and casual fans alike. And if you'd like to cling to Halloween a bit longer and hide from the Christmas advertising blitz-which has already started-it's good for that, too.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on We Happy Few
Recent Articles
Review: THE MANNEQUIN at We Happy Few
Review: THE MANNEQUIN at We Happy Few
5/24/2026

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Washington, DC News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


CrazySexyCool – The TLC Musical in Washington, DC CrazySexyCool – The TLC Musical
Arena Stage (6/12-8/09)
Macbeth - Academy Summer Repertory in Washington, DC Macbeth - Academy Summer Repertory
Shakespeare Theatre Company (7/16-7/25)
Pete the Cat: A Live Rock Musical in Washington, DC Pete the Cat: A Live Rock Musical
Imagination Stage (6/17-7/26)
Twelfth Night - Academy Summer Repertory in Washington, DC Twelfth Night - Academy Summer Repertory
Shakespeare Theatre Company (7/15-7/25)
BAD KREYÒL in Washington, DC BAD KREYÒL
Mosaic Theater Company (5/20-6/13)
The Jersey Four A Tribute to Frankie Valli and The 4 Seasons, featuring original member Gerry Polci in Washington, DC The Jersey Four A Tribute to Frankie Valli and The 4 Seasons, featuring original member Gerry Polci
F. Scott Fitzgerald Theatre (9/13-9/13)
Rockville Little Theatre presents "Lettice & Lovage"  in Washington, DC Rockville Little Theatre presents "Lettice & Lovage" 
F. Scott Fitzgerald Theatre (1/29-2/07)
Ford''s Theatre presents: Come From Away in Washington, DC Ford''s Theatre presents: Come From Away
Ford's Theatre (9/10-10/18)
ArmEvents presents: An Evening of Elegance & Virtuosity Live Concert in Washington, DC ArmEvents presents: An Evening of Elegance & Virtuosity Live Concert
F. Scott Fitzgerald Theatre (9/12-9/12)
One Night at Gatsby's in Washington, DC One Night at Gatsby's
George C. Marshall's Dodona Manor (7/11-7/11) VIDEOS