Review: LEND ME A TENOR at Westchester Broadway Theatre Sends In the Clowns

By: Jan. 12, 2020
Review: LEND ME A TENOR at Westchester Broadway Theatre Sends In the Clowns
The shenanigans build to a farcical fever in "Lend Me a Tenor," with J. D. Daw as Max and Molly McCaskill as his girlfriend Molly. Photo credit: John Vecchiolla

Like a famous, old candy bar commercial sang, "Sometimes you feel like a nut... sometimes you don't."

For the times you do, though, a stage farce is the ticket to let yourself go, as you go along in totally suspended disbelief with the hellzapoppin hijinks on stage. After all, who says grown-ups aren't allowed to groan every now and then in the name of mirth.

Ken Ludwig's Lend Me a Tenor, now at Westchester Broadway Theatre through Jan. 26, is a soap opera of a farce (which may not be too different from saying it's a farce of a soap opera). Either way, it's fun enough, if not Marxian funny in the manner of A Night at the Opera.

Get a Free Dinner

There's another reason to give it a try. To underscore the distinction of Lend Me a Tenor as the first straight play (not a musical) in the dinner theater's 45-year history, it is doing something else for the first time: not charging for the dinner portion of the meal-and-show package. You pay $57 a person for both. Quite a deal for a very tasty meal.

Mr. Ludwig's farce fared very well when it opened on Broadway run in the late '80s, snaring several prestigious awards. Since then, it's been revived on The Great White Way and has become a favorite on the local theater circuit. (914-592-2222;

'Il Stupendo'

It may not be a Broadway musical, but music does play a leading role in the show. In fact, while Lend Me a Tenor's tenor is typically farcical -- breakneck pace, mistaken identities, misunderstandings, overactive hormones, sexual wordplay, frenetic and improbable physicality, and a panoply of slamming doors -- what sets it apart from others of its ilk is the musical conceit that drives the nutty plot.

That reaches its high note as the two tenors -- opera star Tito (Joey Sorge), known as "Il Stupendo," and opera wannabe Max (J.D. Daw) -- perform a complete duet that is all business, no joking intended.

Opera's Tragic Clown

Max, assistant to the opera company's manager, is the play's titular tenor, who is pressed into duty in an emergency when Tito topples over into a deathly unconsciousness after ingesting several muscle relaxants too many to calm his nerves before taking the stage for Pagliacci (Clowns), best known for the iconic aria Vesti La Giubba, sung by a clown who is crying on the inside because of his wife's newfound infidelity.

By the time Il Stupendo emerges from his ill stupor, Max is gone, ready to stand in for him. Tito, unaware of the substitution, rushes to the theater to make the curtain. He becomes detained by the police, who think he is delusional, but Tito escapes their clutches and the obligatory farce runaround is off and running.

Launching Laughs

With both Tito and Max dressed in identical clown regalia, the audience is asked to accept that the other characters would readily mistake one for the other. And we do accept it, because it's a farce, for goodness' sake, not a reality TV show. That visual gag becomes the fulcrum on which many a hearty laugh is launched in Act II. The first act moves at a more purposeful pace, as Act I farce set-ups are wont to do.

Running in circles around the twin tenors are a cacophony of characters that include habitually harried and fuming opera boss Saunders (Philip Hoffman), Tito's volcanic wife Maria (Kathy Voytko), Max's main squeeze Maggie (Molly McCaskill), soprano diva Diana (Hannah Jane McMurray), opera patron grand dame Julia (Tregoney Shepherd), who is fun to watch as a Margaret DuMontesque foil, and the bouncy, brazen bellhop who irritates Saunders like sandpaper (Sam Seferian).

The play is crisply and cannily directed by Harry Bouvy, and the functional, period set design (evoking a 1930s hotel, with a cut-away wall separating a sitting room on the left from the suite's bedroom (on right), is by Steve Loftus.

RELATED STORIES - Rockland / Westchester

Mala Waldron Quartet to Perform in Westchester Collaborative Theaters MUSIC IN THE BOX Ser Photo
Mala Waldron Quartet to Perform in Westchester Collaborative Theater's MUSIC IN THE BOX Series

Don't miss the internationally acclaimed Mala Waldron Quartet in concert at Westchester Collaborative Theater. Jazz virtuosos performing live on October 7th.

Review: DRACULA at Elmwood Playhouse Photo
Review: DRACULA at Elmwood Playhouse

What did our critic think of DRACULA at Elmwood Playhouse?

Arc Stages Presents MARRY ME A LITTLE Photo
Arc Stages Presents MARRY ME A LITTLE

Arc Stages presents Marry Me A Little, a musical revue featuring the songs of Stephen Sondheim. Don't miss this intimate and heartfelt production.

Westchester Collaborative Theater Presents Two New One-Act Plays For Its September PLAY IN Photo
Westchester Collaborative Theater Presents Two New One-Act Plays For Its September PLAY IN THE BOX Production

Westchester Collaborative Theater (WCT) presents two new one-act plays in its September Play in the Box Production. Join us for an evening of captivating theater.

From This Author - Bruce Apar

Bruce Apar is principal of boutique marketing agency APAR PR. His career in media spans publishing, acting, writing, marketing, digital production, Hollywood, home entertainment, event production, and... Bruce Apar">(read more about this author)


#repshow# in[i]# In the Heights
White Plains Performing Arts Center (10/06-10/22)
#repshow# in[i]# Katonah Classic Stage presents Harold Pinter Play Festival
Whippoorwill Hall, at the North Castle Library (10/05-10/29)
#repshow# in[i]# Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
The Harrison Players, Inc. (10/20-10/22)
#repshow# in[i]# Marry Me A Little
Arc Stages (9/29-10/15)
#repshow# in[i]# The Rocky Horror Show
Roosevelt Hall (10/19-10/27)
#repshow# in[i]# Let There Be Love
Penguin Rep Theatre (9/22-10/15)
#repshow# in[i]# Anastasia
White Plains Performing Arts Center (12/15-1/07)

Recommended For You