McCarter Theatre Center presents the world premiere of I & You: The Musical, featuring Broadway stars Jasmine Forsberg and Benji Santiago in lead roles. Based on Lauren Gunderson’s acclaimed play, this two-person musical unfolds as Caroline, confined at home due to illness, engages in a transformative late-night conversation with the enthusiastic Anthony. Directed by Sarah Rasmussen, the production features an original score by Ari Afsar and runs from September 13 to October 12, 2025.
Cast and Creative team for I & You: The Musical at McCarter Theatre Center
Cast
Jasmine Forsberg
Caroline
Jasmine Forsberg is an actor and songwriter from Orlando, Florida. Broadway: Six (Jane Seymour), Here Lies Love (Maria Luisa), Stephen Sondheim’s Old Friends. First National Tour: Six. Off-Broadway: Broadway Bounty Hunter. Regional: A Grand Night for Singing (Goodspeed), Love in Hate Nation (Two River Theater), Wild Fire (Denver Center). TV: “One
December Night” (Hallmark), “Llamas” (Nick Jr.). Jasmine’s debut single, “do you”, is streaming on all platforms. BFA from Penn State University. Thanks to
CESD, Telsey, and my loved ones for their endless support. IG: @jasmine_forsberg
www.JasmineForsberg.com
Benji Santiago
Anthony
Benji Santiago most recently made his Broadway debut as Younger Noah in The Notebook. Last summer, he starred as Usnavi in The Muny's In The Heights. He studied at Carnegie Mellon School of Drama. Thank you, Mom! IG: @bennjisantiago
SUBMIT UPDATES
McCarter Theatre Center Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
A Christmas Carol (12/9/25-12/28/25)
300 Paintings (10/29/25-11/2/25)
Primary Trust (5/9/25-5/25/25)
Noli Timere (2/7/25-2/8/25)
Ship Happens: A Cruisical! (5/24/24-5/25/24)
The Sound of (Black) Music (11/17/23-11/17/23)
Ship Happens, A Cruisical (11/10/23-11/12/23)
The Woman in Black (10/13/23-10/29/23)
Bulrusher (9/13/23-10/7/23)
Holiday POPS! (12/14/21-12/14/21)
Kim's Convenience (1/23/26-2/15/26)
Circus Quixote (3/4/26-3/15/26)
Mrs. Christie (5/6/26-5/31/26)
McCarter Theatre Center is at 91 University Place, Princeton, NJ.
Videos
 |
Chicago the Musical
Mayo Performing Arts Center (1/16 - 1/18) | |
 |
The Wolves
Old Library Theatre (12/12 - 12/14)
PHOTOS
| |
|
Beethoven's Fifth Symphony
New Jersey Performing Arts Center (2/27 - 2/27) | |
|
Comedy Night
Surflight Theatre (1/17 - 1/17) | |
|
Who's Bad
State Theatre New Jersey (2/7 - 2/7) | |
|
The Wonder of Christmas
Jersey Shore Arts Center - Palaia Theatre (12/18 - 12/19) | |
|
Beethoven's Pastoral Symphony
Mayo Performing Arts Center (3/29 - 3/29) | |
|
Kinky Boots
State Theatre New Jersey (2/27 - 3/1) | |
|
Joy Meets Girl
Skyline Theatre Company (12/13 - 12/21) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get New Jersey's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for New Jersey & beyond.
