Get theatre news and discounts for Appleton, WI
Home Appleton, WI For You Chat My Shows (beta) Register/Login Games Grosses
Now and Then show poster

Now and Then at Sunset Playhouse

Dates: 1/9/2026 - 1/17/2026

Theatre:

Sunset Playhouse

Sunset Playhouse

700 Wall Street
Elm Grove,WI 53122

Phone: (262) 782-4430

Buy Tickets

  1. View All Appleton, WI Shows
    2.  > 
  2. Now and Then


Sometimes what happens after last call just might change your life. It’s 1981 and just as Jamie is closing up the bar where he works, a desperate last-minute customer offers him and his girlfriend, Abby, two thousand dollars to sit and have a drink with him. Who wouldn’t take it? As the trio swaps stories about life and the future, the unbelievable truth about this man is slowly revealed. What unfolds is a heartfelt romantic comedy about time, choices, and the love we share.

Jan 9-10 at 7:30 PM/January 11 at 2PM
January 16-17 at 7:30 PM

 

SUBMIT UPDATES
Photos Videos Discount
Cast Creative Edit


Sunset Playhouse Frequently Asked Questions FAQ

What shows are coming up next at Sunset Playhouse?

AUDITIONS - All Shook Up (2/9/26-2/11/26)
Marvelous Motown (3/9/26-3/10/26)
Diva Dynasty: A Trubute to Judy & Lisa (3/26/26-3/29/26)
{PROOF} (4/10/26-4/18/26)
AUDITIONS - Sleuth (4/13/26-4/14/26)
Woodstock & Beyond (4/27/26-4/28/26)
AUDITIONS - Legally Blond (5/11/26-5/13/26)
All Shook Up, Jr. (5/11/26-5/12/26)
Sing Along with Sinatra (6/4/26-6/7/26)
Tapestry: Kerry Sings Carol King (6/16/26-6/16/26)
Legally Blond, Jr (8/14/26-8/16/26)

Where is Sunset Playhouse located?

Sunset Playhouse is at 700 Wall Street, Elm Grove, WI.

What shows have played recently at Sunset Playhouse?

'80s Mix Tape: Sweet Dreams Are Made of This (1/26/26-1/27/26)
Beetlejuice (1/23/26-2/1/26)
Happy Elvis Eve - Furlan Theater (12/31/25-12/31/25)
Tenors MKE Holiday Concert 2025 (12/16/25-12/16/25)
Dean Martin's Coolest Yule (12/11/25-12/14/25)
Musical Mainstage - Coffeehouse Christmas: Folk Favorites (12/8/25-12/9/25)
Nuncrackers (12/4/25-12/21/25)
AUDITIONS - Unnecessary Farce (11/10/25-11/11/25)
Musical Mainstage - What Goes Up: Horn Bands (10/20/25-10/21/25)
Pippin (10/16/25-11/2/25)

Videos

View all Videos

APPLETON, WI SHOWS
Avenue Q in Appleton, WI Avenue Q
Bombshell Studio Theatre (2/26 - 3/15)

COMEDY Tracker
Girls' Weekend in Appleton, WI Girls' Weekend
Sentry Theater (1/30 - 2/7)
The Great Gatsby in Appleton, WI The Great Gatsby
Fox Cities Performing Arts Center (4/14 - 4/19)
All Shook Up in Appleton, WI All Shook Up
Sunset Playhouse (4/23 - 5/10)
Legally Blonde The Musical in Appleton, WI Legally Blonde The Musical
Sunset Playhouse (7/16 - 8/9)
Flamenco Vivo Carlota Santana in Appleton, WI Flamenco Vivo Carlota Santana
Fox Cities Performing Arts Center (5/1 - 5/1)
Kimberly Akimbo in Appleton, WI Kimberly Akimbo
Fox Cities PAC (3/3 - 3/8)
VIEW SHOWS  ADD A SHOW  

Recommended For You