Now and Then at Sunset Playhouse
Dates: 1/9/2026 - 1/17/2026
📍 Theatre: Sunset Playhouse
Sunset Playhouse
700 Wall Street
Elm Grove, WI 53122
Phone: (262) 782-4430
Sometimes what happens after last call just might change your life. It’s 1981 and just as Jamie is closing up the bar where he works, a desperate last-minute customer offers him and his girlfriend, Abby, two thousand dollars to sit and have a drink with him. Who wouldn’t take it? As the trio swaps stories about life and the future, the unbelievable truth about this man is slowly revealed. What unfolds is a heartfelt romantic comedy about time, choices, and the love we share.
Jan 9-10 at 7:30 PM/January 11 at 2PM
January 16-17 at 7:30 PM
News About Now and Then at Sunset Playhouse
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
🌙 Make a Night of It
Loading nearby places…
Sunset Playhouse Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
What shows are coming up next at Sunset Playhouse?
Where is Sunset Playhouse located?
What shows have played recently at Sunset Playhouse?
Tapestry: Kerry Sings Carol King (06/16/26-06/16/26)
Sing Along with Sinatra (06/04/26-06/07/26)
AUDITIONS - Legally Blond (05/11/26-05/13/26)
All Shook Up, Jr. (05/11/26-05/12/26)
Woodstock & Beyond (04/27/26-04/28/26)
All Shook Up (04/23/26-05/10/26)
When I Look in the Mirror (04/22/26-04/25/26)
AUDITIONS - Sleuth (04/13/26-04/14/26)
{PROOF} (04/10/26-04/18/26)
|
Legally Blonde The Musical Sunset Playhouse (7/16-8/09) |
|
The Super Pickle: A Hilarious Musical Parody Fox Cities PAC (10/10-10/10) |
|
Sisters Christmas Catechism: The Mystery Of The Magi''s Gold Fox Cities PAC (11/20-11/20) |
|
Shakespeare's As You Like It Schmeeckle Reserve Amphitheatre (8/13-8/16) |
|
The Great Leap Renaissance Theataerworks (1/10-1/31) |
|
Legally Blond, Jr Sunset Playhouse (8/14-8/16) |
|
Hadestown (Non-Equity) Fox Cities Performing Arts Center (10/16-10/17) |
|
|
Hadestown Fox Cities Performing Arts Center (10/16-10/17) |
|
Come From Away Stage Ten Seventeen (9/03-9/13) |
|
Luke Bryan Alpine Valley Music Theatre (9/26-9/26) |