Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: BROADWAY AT THE GOOD THEATER Serves Up Holiday Cheer

Review: BROADWAY AT THE GOOD THEATER Serves Up Holiday Cheer

Among the many holiday season theatrical offerings, the annual musical revue, Broadway at the Good Theater inevitably proves to be a refreshing and original approach to ushering in a season of good cheer. The 2017 production, conceived, written, and directed by Brian P. Allen, is no exception; in fact, if anything, this year's show is bigger, bolder, and full of delightful surprises.

Devoting the stage to the Broadway musicals of the 1950s, Allen presents a collection of thirty-six songs and medleys that range from blockbusters like The King and I, The Music Man, and The Sound of Music to virtually forgotten little gems like Saratoga, John Murray Anderson's Almanac, and Pipe Dream. Allen's encyclopedic knowledge of the Broadway genre allows him to choose cleverly and juxtapose the pieces to create a brisk, witty, and melodically memorable evening. Working with three New York guest artists, some new regional and local talent, and the returning regulars of the ensemble, he assigns songs to each performer based on individual strengths and creates contexts that are engaging.

Musical Director Victoria Stubbs on keyboards leads the onstage excellent trio (Bill Manning-percussion & Asher Barreras-bass), and provides the skillful arrangements, especially of the extended medleys, which allow the evening to cover more music and make smooth transitions.

Steve Underwood's set design (with set decoration by Justin Cote) is more elaborate than usual: a handsome wine-colored, well-appointed interior drawing room festooned with garlands, lights, and a glittering tree. Ian Odlin lights the stage with a cozy hearthside warmth, and the uncredited costume designs (likely selected by the individual artists) give just the right hint of character and period while capturing the colorful charm and occasional silliness of the season. Stage Manager Michael Lynch and Technical Director Craig Robinson round out the production team.

The three guest artists each contribute special moments to the show's tapestry. Displaying a strong lyric baritone and crisp diction, Daniel Patrick Smith delivers a characterful "Trouble in River City" (Music Man) and a touching rendition of "The Man I Used to Be" (Pipe Dream). Replacing the originally scheduled Kathy Voytko on short notice, Jessica Phillips sings with lyric musicality and proves winsome in the Damn Yankees duet, "A Man Doesn't Know" (with Eric Kunze), and sings an elegant "Getting to Know You" from King and I. Kunze, who has played a number of "legitimate" leading men on Broadway, creates magic with his exquisite rendition of "Maria" from West Side Story and wrapped up the concert with a heart wrenching performance of a new song from a work in development, "Thank you," which deals with the relationship of a hearing man and deaf woman. The haunting melody and lyrics paired with the use of American Sign Language creates a stunning closing moment.

Review: BROADWAY AT THE GOOD THEATER Serves Up Holiday Cheer The thirteen-member supporting cast makes a lively ensemble, and each is given a moment to shine. Laura Houck excels in portraying jaded, brassy, sophisticated women in her strong, smoky voice; Her rendition of "Boston Bequine" (New Faces of 1952) is wickedly funny, and her brief selection from Gypsy touching. Marissa Brown uses her light coloratura to deliver a Barbara Cook medley, while Hannah Daly projects a sweet ingénue presence in songs like "That's the Way It Happens" (Me and Juliet). Jen Means demonstrates once again that she is a consummate interpreter of a song and text, delighting in "It's a Helluva Way to Run a Love Affair" (Plain and Fancy) and "I'll Never Be Jealous Again" (Pajama Game). Lynne McGhee belts out the vocals and the broad comedy in "Flings" (New Girl in Town) and in the closing number, "Give It All You Got" (Oh Captain). Shannon Thurston displays a voice of considerable flexibility, range, and power and practically steals the show with her performance (together with Allen as the Inspector) of "Is It a Crime" (Bells Are Ringing). High school sophomore and newcomer to the Good, Madeline Fitzgerald, gives a sultry performance of "Ain't It De Truth *(Jamaica) and catches the eye with stage presence in the ensemble.

Among the men, veteran Glenn Anderson again demonstrates his flair for comedy and his skill with dialects. His witty, waltzing Captain Hook ("Captain Hook's Waltz, Peter Pan) is delightfully memorable moment. Jim Gaddis contributes a very funny "Maria Medley" which - when juxtaposed with Kunze's mellifluous rendition of Bernstein's song - proves hilarious. Conor Riordan Martin makes a goofy L'il Abner ("If I Had My Druthers"), while Steve Leighton brings color and character to several pieces, among them the opening "Fixin' for a Long Cold Winter" from Courtin' Time and the title song from Take Me Along. Newcomer John Lanham proves a pleasing discovery. He brings a firm, focused, lovely tenor and a winning presence to numbers like "Sing You Sinners" (Mr. Wonderful) and "What a Waste" (Wonderful Town). Rounding out the male ensemble is young Halim Moldaver, who continues to hone his stage skills.

Over the years, Brian P. Allen has made these holiday revues much-anticipated events, and the sold-out crowd at the Good Theater last night bore witness to the dynamic impact this little theatre continues to have on Portland's cultural scene.

Photos courtesy of the Good Theater, Steve Underwood, photographer

Broadway at the Good Theater runs November 29-December 3, 2017, at 76 Congress St., Portland, ME 207-835-0895

Related Articles View More Maine Stories

From This Author - Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold

Born and raised in the metropolitan New York area, Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold took her degrees at Sarah Lawrence College and Fairleigh Dickinson University. She began her career as a teacher... (read more about this author)

Maine State Music Theatre's JOSEPH & THE AMAZING TECHNICOLOR DREAMCOAT Explodes with Color, Energy, and Joy
June 30, 2022

Maine State Music Theatre’s second main stage production, perennial favorite, JOSEPH & THE AMAZING TECHNICOLOR DREAMCOAT, takes the Pickard stage by storm, exploding with color, energy, and sheer irrepressible joy. Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice’s early collaboration based on the Book of Genesis has as its central metaphor the coat of many colors, and like that kaleidoscopic garment, the show itself is a rich, eclectic tapestry that weaves together musical and choreographic genres, ancient and modern sensibilities, and perhaps best of all in this production – a diverse and deeply talented cast that is beautiful to behold.

Fresh & Fun: Blake Hammond & Jeff Max Reprise Signature Roles in MSMT's JOSEPH
June 26, 2022

“This production is new, fun, fresh,” says actor Blake Hammond who plays Jacob and Potiphar in Maine State Music Theatre’s production of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice’s JOSEPH AND THE AMAZING TECHNICOLOR DREAMCOAT that runs from June 29-July 16. “The show is pure joy,” concurs his castmate Jeff Max, who plays the role of Pharoah. “There is something in it for everyone.” This praise, coming from Hammond and Max, has a special resonance. Both actors have a long history with this show and the parts they play, and both have worked together in memorable previous productions. Recounts Hammond, “I first played Jacob and Potiphar thirty-five years ago in summer stock and since then have also played Napthali and the Baker as well, so it is fun to come back to the original track of Jacob/Potiphar in this production. [Director/choreographer] Alex Sanchez doesn’t have a lot of experience with this show, so he has fresh eyes for it; he’s not repeating anything else he’s done; it is as if we are learning for the first time.”

An Exquisite Heidi Kettenring Opens MSMT's Concert Series
June 19, 2022

Chicago’s Leading Lady and beloved superstar of MSMT, Heidi Kettenring returns to the Pickard Theatre for three splendid concerts featuring the music of Carole King, Karen Carpenter, Linda Ronstadt, and Joni Mitchell. An exquisite chanteuse, Kettenring combines vocal richness and power, interpretive flair, and sheer elegance and class in an evening of song and sentiment that goes straight to the heart.

Alive with Music: SOUND OF MUSIC Stars Open MSMT Library Series
June 18, 2022

For two weeks now Brunswick’s Pickard Theater has been “alive with the sound of music,’ but on June 15 Hanley Smith and Will Ray, the stars of MSMT’s brilliant new production of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s THE SOUND OF MUSIC, joined MSMT Artistic Director Curt Dale Clark and BWW Maine Regional Editor Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold to celebrate the joy, inspiration, and continued resonance of this timeless musical at the first Peek Behind the Curtain program in three years. The popular panel discussion series held at Curtis Memorial Library returned to an enthusiastic, capacity audience for an hour of conversation about what Clark called “the quintessential American musical and the perfect show to launch post-pandemic MSMT’s Revival Season.”

BWW Review: A Boy with Big Dreams: MSMT's JACK & THE BEANSTALK
June 13, 2022

Maine State Music Theatre opened its Theatre for Young Audiences series with a delightful, energetic, and amusing production of Robin and Clark’s JACK AND THE BEANSTALK that drew a crowd of enthusiastic youngsters, their teachers, parents, and grandparents for the four performances on June 13.